Topic: Mini Rig card = 2 x Altera Arria II EP2AGX260 (Read 39231 times)

Quote from: DiabloD3 on June 02, 2012, 08:08:17 AM

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

If we made some wild assumptions that these were it, and that they could get them for $300 each, that means:

$300 x 17 cards per rig x 2 chips per card == $10,200.00

Mini-rig price: $15,295.00 minus $10,200.00 == $5,095.00

So are the PCBs, supporting components, PSU, enclosure, and fans enough to eat that ~$5k? Seems like there could be a decent bit of profit here.

certainly not.
by experience, as a small amount product (bitcoin mining equipment will NEVER grow up to a traditionally BIG market you know), if the final price is twice as the cost, you will run at loss unless you careful calculation and strict budgeting, and it must be a easy to make stuff. sell the product at least triple of the cost will much better for a flat.

"certainly not.
by experience, as a small amount product (bitcoin mining equipment will NEVER grow up to a traditionally BIG market you know), if the final price is twice as the cost, you will run at loss unless you careful calculation and strict budgeting, and it must be a easy to make stuff. sell the product at least triple of the cost will much better for a flat. "

I dont ander stand "sell the product at least triple of the cost will" do you mean this product (mini rig)should be sold at 3 x $15,295 = $45,885

that means if you produce a stuff cost you 100$, and it's a low quantity product. then in a general way, sell it at 200-300$ will make ends meet.
it doesn't matter what BFL do. they could make the singles and minirigs at a unbelievable low cost, or just don't want to earn any money "now". who knows.

My bet is they dont want to earn money now and use ASIC scheme to get more money later. It would possibly the best con job ever.

How many minirigs have they actually shipped? They already take preorder for ASIC and announce trade-in program.

kano

legendary

Activity: 4592

Merit: 1851

Linux since 1997 RedHat 4

...
BFL FPGAs COULD be repurposed, but BFL requires encrypted bitstreams.

Who told you this?

hardpick

sr. member

Activity: 265

Merit: 250

Football President

Maybe the low margins makes the mini rig ($15000 for 25 GB/s -- $0.61 per M/h) good value for money product is to get people to pre pay.
So BFL balance sheet very looks good for the vulture capitalist opps I mean venture capitalist. I would think the trade in is because there will be a high margin on asic rigs from day one and you would expect the new asic products to half in price after the trade in period expires .

MrTeal

legendary

Activity: 1274

Merit: 1004

I wonder what the quantity of Minirigs they have sold is? 30 would get them up to a quantity of 1000 FPGAs, which might be another price break for them.

Even then, they probably aren't making a ton of money on Minirigs if they're even paying $250 per FPGA. That would still be 8500 in FPGAs, and other components in the system would likely push it up closer to $10k. If they sell 30 FPGA MiniRigs, that would only leave 150k to pay for the space, keeping the lights on, paying employees, etc. There might be money in it, but not much.

ngzhang

hero member

Activity: 592

Merit: 501

We will stand and fight.

Quote from: lame.duck on June 20, 2012, 06:11:45 AM

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

Just for curiosity, what does 'moderate quantity' means (probably for such largish FPGAs)?

200-500

lame.duck

legendary

Activity: 1270

Merit: 1000

Quote from: hardpick on June 20, 2012, 12:33:35 AM

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

Just for curiosity, what does 'moderate quantity' means (probably for such largish FPGAs)?

ngzhang

hero member

Activity: 592

Merit: 501

We will stand and fight.

Quote from: ngzhang on June 19, 2012, 01:14:49 PM

Quote from: ngzhang on June 19, 2012, 01:14:49 PM

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

If we made some wild assumptions that these were it, and that they could get them for $300 each, that means:

$300 x 17 cards per rig x 2 chips per card == $10,200.00

Mini-rig price: $15,295.00 minus $10,200.00 == $5,095.00

So are the PCBs, supporting components, PSU, enclosure, and fans enough to eat that ~$5k? Seems like there could be a decent bit of profit here.

certainly not.
by experience, as a small amount product (bitcoin mining equipment will NEVER grow up to a traditionally BIG market you know), if the final price is twice as the cost, you will run at loss unless you careful calculation and strict budgeting, and it must be a easy to make stuff. sell the product at least triple of the cost will much better for a flat.

"certainly not.
by experience, as a small amount product (bitcoin mining equipment will NEVER grow up to a traditionally BIG market you know), if the final price is twice as the cost, you will run at loss unless you careful calculation and strict budgeting, and it must be a easy to make stuff. sell the product at least triple of the cost will much better for a flat. "

I dont ander stand "sell the product at least triple of the cost will" do you mean this product (mini rig)should be sold at 3 x $15,295 = $45,885

that means if you produce a stuff cost you 100$, and it's a low quantity product. then in a general way, sell it at 200-300$ will make ends meet.
it doesn't matter what BFL do. they could make the singles and minirigs at a unbelievable low cost, or just don't want to earn any money "now". who knows.

hardpick

sr. member

Activity: 265

Merit: 250

Football President

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

If we made some wild assumptions that these were it, and that they could get them for $300 each, that means:

$300 x 17 cards per rig x 2 chips per card == $10,200.00

Mini-rig price: $15,295.00 minus $10,200.00 == $5,095.00

So are the PCBs, supporting components, PSU, enclosure, and fans enough to eat that ~$5k? Seems like there could be a decent bit of profit here.

certainly not.
by experience, as a small amount product (bitcoin mining equipment will NEVER grow up to a traditionally BIG market you know), if the final price is twice as the cost, you will run at loss unless you careful calculation and strict budgeting, and it must be a easy to make stuff. sell the product at least triple of the cost will much better for a flat.

"certainly not.
by experience, as a small amount product (bitcoin mining equipment will NEVER grow up to a traditionally BIG market you know), if the final price is twice as the cost, you will run at loss unless you careful calculation and strict budgeting, and it must be a easy to make stuff. sell the product at least triple of the cost will much better for a flat. "

I dont ander stand "sell the product at least triple of the cost will" do you mean this product (mini rig)should be sold at 3 x $15,295 = $45,885

ngzhang

hero member

Activity: 592

Merit: 501

We will stand and fight.

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

If we made some wild assumptions that these were it, and that they could get them for $300 each, that means:

$300 x 17 cards per rig x 2 chips per card == $10,200.00

Mini-rig price: $15,295.00 minus $10,200.00 == $5,095.00

So are the PCBs, supporting components, PSU, enclosure, and fans enough to eat that ~$5k? Seems like there could be a decent bit of profit here.

certainly not.
by experience, as a small amount product (bitcoin mining equipment will NEVER grow up to a traditionally BIG market you know), if the final price is twice as the cost, you will run at loss unless you careful calculation and strict budgeting, and it must be a easy to make stuff. sell the product at least triple of the cost will much better for a flat.

rjk

sr. member

Activity: 448

Merit: 250

1ngldh

Quote from: hardpick on June 19, 2012, 11:43:42 AM

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

If we made some wild assumptions that these were it, and that they could get them for $300 each, that means:

$300 x 17 cards per rig x 2 chips per card == $10,200.00

Mini-rig price: $15,295.00 minus $10,200.00 == $5,095.00

So are the PCBs, supporting components, PSU, enclosure, and fans enough to eat that ~$5k? Seems like there could be a decent bit of profit here.

ngzhang

hero member

Activity: 592

Merit: 501

We will stand and fight.

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

From what I understand A2 GX260 are capable of about 750GH/S ie 1.5 GH/s for 2 = bfl new single (use 17 of them in mini rig)

ie if they where sold as singles at about $1000 for 1.5 GH/s ---

maybe you should consider using A2 GX260 in your next FPGA development

certainly not Cheesy

, 600USD (this is only chip cost) for only 1.5GH/s is unacceptable. plus 100$ additional charge, what is your expected final price for a 700USD cost product? 1000USD? Cheesy

and, A2 is a obsolescent product, A5(Arria V series, 28nm) is much cheaper (20%+)than A2 (at same capacity), but BFL didn't use the faster and cheaper one. maybe it's really hard for them to find enough 2nd hand A5 FPGAs.

for now though, let's see what will happen on spartan6 this year.

hardpick

sr. member

Activity: 265

Merit: 250

Football President

And how much would a factory wafer respin cost from an old maskset, ngzhang? Do you know any numbers there?

just contact with an altera FAE ( is on of my friends Cheesy

), he is unwilling to discuss about the price, but leak a message that the A2 GX260 is about 300 USD at a moderate quantity. Cheesy

From what I understand A2 GX260 are capable of about 750GH/S ie 1.5 GH/s for 2 = bfl new single (use 17 of them in mini rig)

ie if they where sold as singles at about $1000 for 1.5 GH/s ---

maybe you should consider using A2 GX260 in your next FPGA development

ngzhang

hero member

Activity: 592

Merit: 501

We will stand and fight.