***UPDATE***
Pulled and re-seated all of the connections (data and power)-No change
Replaced the riser entirely (sands USB cord)-No Change
Ran Stock Settings-No change
I'm mining verge at the moment and it's hash is stable around 1/3 of the other 2 (roughly 19 MH/S)
HOWEVER- Disabling the other 2 GPUs in device manager and running a miner produced good results: 68.6 MH/S with stock settings. I disabled the MSI card and then re-enabled all of them. The other 2 cards worked fine, but the MSI couldn't get above 33 MH/S. When I turn AB back on, even using stock settings for just that board, the hashrate drops to 14 MH/S.
If I reboot the miner without AB on, it runs as it should for a few minutes and then reverts back to stupid mode.
@grendel25 I think you're on the right track. Where do I take it from here based on that info?