Topic: MTGOX recovery imminent! - page 2. (Read 5811 times)

Well sure.  But limits like these are not exactly new to exchanges.  I agree it would be peachy if the world was totally unlimited. But nobody in this world operates like that. The fiat world is ALL about those kind of limitations.  A run on a fiat bank is only a problem to the consumer because, literally, they don't have that kind of money in their vaults to give out all at once.  It's a system build on deception.  Now it's possible, but not likely, that bitcoin exchange houses are totally responsible and trustworthy and actually have the BTC and USD to back up all of their accounts.  In which case, they could afford, in the short term, to just let people withdraw unlimited amounts freely, because they'd make money on the transaction fees.  But then if all investors pulled completely out, there would be no longterm for them.  They'd be done, and when times are bad, I think it would be in their favor to implement any limitations that would slow the possibility of that worst case scenario. It's probably also good for consumers because I'd assume the faster the ship is sinking the more likely someone inside will be to hastily "off" with funds illegally.  Still, I agree with you, I believe when times are good the more freely people can access and exchange their funds the better off the exchange will be because it provides a better experience for the consumer.  Free market principles.

Thanks Mr.TheJoint
I think you are making some false assumptions here.  Seems GOX has a pretty high level of operational latitude here.  Going on the stated circumstances... So at some point they determined that there was a problem that required them to hault withdrawals.  Reportedly there are withdrawal orders that were placed at this time that have not yet been fulfilled.  Seems right. Sure. I would expect as much.

So they're basically just late on fullfilling those. Under the claimed circumstances I don't know that has any other impact or implications on the situation legal or otherwise.  I think they have the right to take the time they need to solve the problem without additional cost to them.  Don't they?  So:
- it's possible they will actually fulfill said withdrawals first prior to newer withdrawal orders.
- it also seems possible that, under the circumstances they could void withdrawal orders that occurred at that time, claiming that they were part of the problem, and under newly set withdrawal limits, ask those people to kindly reorder their withdrawals.

Either way, I'm not sure why any of that would make my originally posted theory impossible. My scenario could still play out.

I think that the biggest error of MTGox is trying to limit their customers.
Imagine that you walk into a shop to buy something and once you've paid your money, the owner of the shop don't give you the change inventing excuses, in order you come back tomorrow to have your change (hopping that you buy something else tomorrow for instance). Would you buy anything there any more? Once you've got your change would you ever come back to that shop?
So would all the MTGox customers right now. And if MTGox doesn't change their policy they will go on losing their customers in the same way and their business will die.

  It's odd but true that people often won't get off their butts and get something done simply because it's inconvenient.

I gave you a good reason why it's impossible.  Gox is reported to owe as many as 68,000 BTC, and your proposed solution does nothing to erase that debt.  You can't just set a withdrawal limit when a withdrawal of any amount is already owed to someone else.  What Gox needs is a solution to pull them out of debt, not just to get people who will never be able to withdraw their deposit trading again.

Because getting validation is a pain and those who have it might hesitate going through that with another exchange when MtGox is sat there ready to action.

Longterm trust is going to be an ongoing issue yes.  When GOX's prices and services are reasonably close in value to other exchanges why would you stay with them when peace of mind has been so lacking in the past? Well you probably won't.  But people don't need trust if they gain something. People who don't trust non organic food growers, but they still buy their food.  People who don't trust the oil industry could ride a bike, but they still buy gas.  Sooo...

In the short term, after you've withdrawn your limit and are waiting to withdraw more, people will realize there is working "buy low GOX/sell high elsewhere" scenario happening. then...

> When people buy the price will rise.
> When the price is high, due to trust issues, people will sell & the price will drop.
> When their price drops people will buy & the cycle will repeat.

Just ideas and opinions so far.  Of course these don't make my theory impossible. Successful people build their careers on proving ideas and opinions wrong Give me something solid that's not open for debate. Such as, its actually illegal, or mathematically impossible, etc. 

Trust can not be reestablished that way!
If they want trust they should let everyone withdraw everything they want from them!
And that would be loosing like 400k customers or more!

And Mark wants his frappuccino hot! How can he buy more frappuccino if he gives all his money to mtgox members?

I disagree. The market has spoken, MTGOX is dying and insolvent by people's view of MTGOX's recent announcements and actions by their CEO on video to not even try to work with someone who flew half way around the world to talk to him face to face.

I think that's right.. the function of an exchange is a simple one and when it works, it's fluid. If they can evidence that the exchange now works, then that might restore confidence in their ability to action that simple function. I'm not sure people need to be loyal to any exchange, they just need one that works. There are enough new customers heading into Bitcoin that being an exchange that can roll with it, might turn out well. The only difficulty with this then, is whether they can risk that - whether they can honor all withdrawals; if it ceases up again, that would be fatal - certainly for the perception of current Bitcoiners.

The second point there is impt too. They need to act in the spirit of what Bitcoin is and not like ye olde banking industry.

What you suggest isn't possible, at least for a "full recovery" as you stated, because this does nothing to solve the problem of owing their customers as much as 68,000 BTC by some estimates.  Setting low withdrawal limits doesn't do much good if any number of coins requested for withdrawal are owed to others first.  As long as Gox owes ridiculous sums of money, there will always be jammed-up withdrawal requests.

I'm afraid that the reason is that MTgox has lost the trust of all his clients, by limiting withdrawals and trying to control and manipulate the market.
Whoever who has anything on MTGox would like to have their $ and BTC back as soon as possible.
If they give the possibility to the customers to withdraw freely their money in both directions ($ and BTC) without any limit maybe, I say maybe, they will save their business from closing.
But their problem is that they want to hold their predominant position on the market treating in very bad manner their clients: locking their money, non answering the support tickets ect
If they do in this way it's the end for them.
If they don't do in this way, probably it's too late as well, but there is some hope for them: if they immediately open all withdrawals, and solve all the tickets in a positive way, they may still save some little quantity of a very conservative clients they have, and than they'll have to build slowly the trust among other potential clients, by acting in a very serious way.
But this means that they have to accept being a 5th exchanger by now and than slowly growing again.
And as far as I understand, this way is out of question for them, because they want to hold their predominant position, which they already lost because of their ambiguous attitude.

Here is my BTC address, if you feel satisfied by my answer: 1PNxQVbtonv6Jhhm5m3N6Xvdkmy5VZ6Gn8

Look at the Ask side http://bitcoinity.org/markets The moment people start to buy the price will rush up to the level that sellers are willing to sell. Unless you already have BTC or fiat and withdraw that, you're very unlikely to be the very few who get the advantage you suggest. It does seem that there are 13k BTC for sell below the level of other exchanges but I'm not sure the data is reality at the moment.

Perhaps there's an opportunity if people have setup sells at a loss just to get out of MtGox but that difference could easily snap shut when they do sort out their problems. The tough problems might be if someone has tried to make undoing the errors hard by creating circular references of unconfirmed transactions, some of which are not valid. Good luck to them but they've landed themselves in a fix AND not done well communicating the real problem. I suspect then they have suffered a problem for a while and undoing it perhaps suggests they've lost money to whoever was scamming them with that bug in their software. The risk then until confirmed is that MtGox might not have the BTC and fiat to honor all withdrawals. I'd like to see them survive and thrive but it isn't looking good from the little we see atm.

Limiting withdrawals might work, so long as internal transfers to new accounts doesn't cause a problem. Restoring faith will require a clear message about what's occurred and a working exchange that turns over withdrawals within limit in a timely fashion.

Clearly the current situation for GOX is the biggest threat they've ever experienced, the primary problem being massive loss of trust.  However, under the circumstances, there is a very simple way for them to quickly reestablish trust and hasten their full recovery.  All they need to do is:

Ensure (via low withdrawal limits) that a "run" on mtgox cannot quickly occur.  The moment people realize they can successfully withdraw even a small amount from GOX and sell at a higher price somewhere else (arbitrage), GOX will see healthy deposits, their price will quickly rebound and all will be as it was.  MTGOX returns again.  Not a surprise. They've done it before.


I'll send BTCitcoin to anyone who can provide clear reason this isn't possible.