This is all kind of abstract so I'll try to make a real-life analogy.. it's definitely not perfect but the best I could come up with at 2:30 in the morning. Imagine instead of a dedicated NLG miner I am a coal miner. Every morning I wake up and put in an honest day's work. And at the end of the day, I get my fair share of the reward that is split between all the other dedicated workers at the site. As I'm walking home, you come by, show me you are 200x more powerful than me, and take half my earnings. Then you tell me "see those big guys over there.. you don't want them messing with you.. they are really rough, maybe they'd break your leg and would put you out of commission for a few days.. and they'd probably take all your reward.. now me.. I'm a good guy.. I only take 50% and don't mess up your legs.. and! I can protect you!.. so you become good friends with me, and I'll take care of you." So you're essentially what? the crypto-mafia? Is this wall street 2.0?
This analogy is all wrong. Nobody rips you of any coins which you mined, and if somebody does, it isn't us. Let me straighten your analogy.
You're this honest and hardworking miner who gets up every morning and takes his shovel to dig some coal. You enjoy this hard work with your friends and you are happy to make a profit from it. Now here comes someone else who is equipped with heavier gear and can mine the coal easier and they start mining alongside with you. You swing your shovel and you are angry that someone with a digger have it easier than you with a shovel. You would like everyone to have just shovels and be one happy shovely family. But this is XXI century and this is not going to happen.
I won't discuss with your opinions wether coin-switch pools are good or not, because everyone can have their own opinion. But there's a huge demand for coin-switch pools and much more people are mining with them than are mining NLG, so this isn't only just one crazy Terk who had some crazy idea. You won't change this. People demand this and this is why profit-based pools exist. These pools still provide service to coins by mining transactions and securing the network. You would simply like to be the one who does this and profit from it and would like to deny this opportunity to other people. Nobody likes competition I guess.
If I were greedy, I would squeeze NLG as much as possible. I could create much much higher and crazier difficulty swings by jumping on and off our full hashrate and I would mine extremely low difficulty blocks with average profitability of 150% LTC, leaving you to mine extremely high difficulty blocks with average 50% profitability. And I would mine 85% of all blocks. This is what using digger vs shovel could look like (and this is how it looked like in September before you pointed me this problem and before I adjusted our algorithms to make it easier for you). I don't do this. Instead I limit our hashpower to don't swing your difficulty that much and we mine blocks with average profitability of ~110%, leaving you to mine blocks with average profitability of ~90%. This is the best what I can do when using digger vs. shovels. Will using diggers will always be more easy and more profitable than shovels? Yes, of course. But I can leave you some space and make my mining only 20% more profitable than yours or I can squeeze your coin and make my mining 300% more profitable than yours. I chose to decrease our profits to give you some space, but you also need to understand and accept that miners with more than shovels exist in this world.
My opinion is that coin-switching pools killed the profitable mining! Clevermining or any other coin-switching pool is not profitable at all, they won't even cover electricity! That is one of my problem with those pools, the other is more simplier than that, if a huge pool get into mining a coin, it will lowering the profit coming from the coin to the level of litecoin and Bitcoin, which is not worth to mine to an honest person who pay electricity bill. So till the point when any coin-switching pool find a new coin that coin can be 2-3-5 times more profitable then Litecoin or Bitcoin mining, after that a strange thing happens, profitability decreasing to the level of Litecoin or Bitcoin level or 2-5% above.
This observation come from my own experience, I mined new altcoins from day 1, 1st minute and I offen made 100x more profit in the first day then later, or maybe the first week was ok as well. Then it went to coinwarz or other shit sites which discovered the coin and ruined it entirely.
So, if you are talking about raping a coin, that is what a coin-switching pool is doing every time when they switch to a coin, they not harming the community or the miners, they harming the coin itself!! And this is a huge problem.
I wonder if someone can come up with a blockchain which prevent building an API for coin-switching pools around it. That could make a big difference in this game of mining. If some algorithm just could hide the low difficulty from the multipools and people can just blindly mining a coin. That could make a difference.