Pages:
Author

Topic: Newsweek could get sued for its dubious Bitcoin scoop | VOX Report - page 2. (Read 2067 times)

hero member
Activity: 588
Merit: 501
Back in March, Newsweek published what would have been one of the year's biggest technology scoops. An article by Leah McGrath Goodman claimed to have unmasked Satoshi Nakamoto, the reclusive — and likely pseudonymous — genius who invented Bitcoin. Goodman pointed to an elderly Japanese-American engineer named Dorian Satoshi Nakamoto who was living in Southern California.

Dorian vehemently denied any connection to Bitcoin, and Goodman's story — based overwhelmingly on circumstantial evidence, quickly crumbled. Yet Newsweek refused to admit that the story, which appeared on the cover of its first print edition under new ownership — was wrong.

The Bitcoin community saw the Newsweek article — which revealed intimate details of his personal life and quoted family members making unflattering comments about him — as a serious invasion of an elderly man's privacy. They quickly raised more than $20,000 to help him cover personal expenses. And now, Dorian's law firm has has created a website to raise more funds to file a lawsuit against Newsweek.

"A lawsuit against Newsweek will be very expensive," the website, created by the law firm of Kirschner and Associates, says. "Dorian does not have the resources to pay the costs of such a suit, let alone attorneys' fees. Monies raised by the Fund will be used to further Dorian's legal claims against Newsweek; anything remaining will be given directly to Dorian for his expenses."

Why would the Bitcoin community donate to support Dorian's lawsuit? Many in the Bitcoin community see the Newsweek's story as a symptom of the mainstream media's clumsy treatment of Bitcoin more generally. Bitcoin is a complex, technical subject; it has been widely misunderstood and even mocked by mainstream journalists.

Some Bitcoin fans see Goodman's bumbling investigation — she cites Dorian's skill machining parts for model trains as evidence that he had the engineering prowess to create Bitcoin, for examples — as a particularly egregious case of Bitcoin-related journalistic malpractice. They may be willing to contribute in order to hold the magazine accountable in court.


Source: http://www.vox.com/xpress/2014/10/13/6972337/bitcoin-fans-are-raising-money-to-sue-newsweek-for-that-infamous




Well said.

We are launching a tiny news site for cryptocurrency info in a few days, if you would like us to reprint this message under your authorship we can do that.  just let me know.

hero member
Activity: 510
Merit: 500
Is this serious?  What exactly did newsweek do wrong?  Everything they have is public information anyway.  Can't possibly be a lawsuit, otherwise criminals could always sue the news, am I right?

Dorian is not (was not) a public person. They published his name, photos, full details based on the incorrect assumption that he is the creator of bitcoin.

The question is did they have a reasonable information to violate his (and his family) privacy. Not to mention they might have put his safety on the risk, as the real Satoshi allegedly owns a huge amount of bitcoins.


Sounds like a bit of a slippery slope. 
hero member
Activity: 756
Merit: 500
some wannabe journalist wants to make a name for themselves.  deserve to be sued and fired!
newbie
Activity: 21
Merit: 0
And when will bitcoin users come up to that amount of money? Newsweek is worth a lot.
legendary
Activity: 1596
Merit: 1000
They deserve to get sued.  He deserves some money.  The lawyers will make out on both ends.
yes, they will get lesson from this. They must confirm the validity of the news' resource before publishing them.
legendary
Activity: 2436
Merit: 1561
Is this serious?  What exactly did newsweek do wrong?  Everything they have is public information anyway.  Can't possibly be a lawsuit, otherwise criminals could always sue the news, am I right?

Dorian is not (was not) a public person. They published his name, photos, full details based on the incorrect assumption that he is the creator of bitcoin.

The question is did they have a reasonable information to violate his (and his family) privacy. Not to mention they might have put his safety on the risk, as the real Satoshi allegedly owns a huge amount of bitcoins.
legendary
Activity: 2744
Merit: 1288
It seems that lawyer has quite bad reputation.
legendary
Activity: 1274
Merit: 1000
The Golden Rule Rules
Is this serious?  What exactly did newsweek do wrong?  Everything they have is public information anyway.  Can't possibly be a lawsuit, otherwise criminals could always sue the news, am I right?
full member
Activity: 210
Merit: 100
Looking for the next big thing
They deserve to get sued.  He deserves some money.  The lawyers will make out on both ends.
hero member
Activity: 896
Merit: 1000
Back in March, Newsweek published what would have been one of the year's biggest technology scoops. An article by Leah McGrath Goodman claimed to have unmasked Satoshi Nakamoto, the reclusive — and likely pseudonymous — genius who invented Bitcoin. Goodman pointed to an elderly Japanese-American engineer named Dorian Satoshi Nakamoto who was living in Southern California.

Dorian vehemently denied any connection to Bitcoin, and Goodman's story — based overwhelmingly on circumstantial evidence, quickly crumbled. Yet Newsweek refused to admit that the story, which appeared on the cover of its first print edition under new ownership — was wrong.

The Bitcoin community saw the Newsweek article — which revealed intimate details of his personal life and quoted family members making unflattering comments about him — as a serious invasion of an elderly man's privacy. They quickly raised more than $20,000 to help him cover personal expenses. And now, Dorian's law firm has has created a website to raise more funds to file a lawsuit against Newsweek.

"A lawsuit against Newsweek will be very expensive," the website, created by the law firm of Kirschner and Associates, says. "Dorian does not have the resources to pay the costs of such a suit, let alone attorneys' fees. Monies raised by the Fund will be used to further Dorian's legal claims against Newsweek; anything remaining will be given directly to Dorian for his expenses."

Why would the Bitcoin community donate to support Dorian's lawsuit? Many in the Bitcoin community see the Newsweek's story as a symptom of the mainstream media's clumsy treatment of Bitcoin more generally. Bitcoin is a complex, technical subject; it has been widely misunderstood and even mocked by mainstream journalists.

Some Bitcoin fans see Goodman's bumbling investigation — she cites Dorian's skill machining parts for model trains as evidence that he had the engineering prowess to create Bitcoin, for examples — as a particularly egregious case of Bitcoin-related journalistic malpractice. They may be willing to contribute in order to hold the magazine accountable in court.


Source: http://www.vox.com/xpress/2014/10/13/6972337/bitcoin-fans-are-raising-money-to-sue-newsweek-for-that-infamous
Pages:
Jump to: