PayPal Crypto Holdings Report | Bitcointalksearch.org

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18771

Quote from: NotATether on February 14, 2023, 02:58:03 AM

Is Paypal one of those platforms that has been giving interest to users for holding crypto on their own site? Hopefully not, as they should know better as to what has been happening to those kinds of services over the last few months.

No, but...

If you look at Paxos' Terms and Conditions, you'll find the following:

Quote from: NotATether on February 14, 2023, 05:10:53 AM

Unless Paypal plans to put some of their stock or earnings on the line, I cannot see this happening at all (besides it would only be available on like Coinbase considering Paypal won't let just any exchange list it).

Nah, it's super simple. You deposit money to your PayPal account, PayPal deem that as sufficient collateral to print an equal number of their new unstablecoin, and then they can use that unstablecoin to buy bitcoin for themselves, pay interest to entice more deposits, the usual shenanigans. Roll Eyes

crwth

copper member

Activity: 2940

Merit: 1280

https://linktr.ee/crwthopia

It's good that they have finally included their crypto holdings after two years. From what I understood, I think it will be a problem if that third party has become insolvent and has some hacking, which will be more problematic. I hope they answer that, make it available to users, and make themselves a genuine provider of cryptocurrency.

NotATether

legendary

Activity: 1568

Merit: 6660

bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org

Quote from: Rikafip on February 14, 2023, 03:19:01 AM

Quote from: o_e_l_e_o on February 13, 2023, 03:23:26 PM

I think stablecoins are scams as well. Tongue

Centralized, not fully backed up or collateralized, printed out of thin air, can be arbitrarily frozen or seized, have collapsed literally overnight... Worse than fiat!

Speaking of stablecoins, PayPal plans/planned to join the circus and issue their own but since their partner Paxos has problems with SEC as of lately (forcing them to stop minting BUSD and pressing charges) that will probably be put on hold.

Oh please. That is probably the dumbest thing that they could do right now, in light of all the controversy about how other stablecoin issuers don't have sufficient backing. Unless Paypal plans to put some of their stock or earnings on the line, I cannot see this happening at all (besides it would only be available on like Coinbase considering Paypal won't let just any exchange list it).

Quote from: Rikafip on February 14, 2023, 03:19:01 AM

Quote from: NotATether on February 14, 2023, 02:58:03 AM

Is Paypal one of those platforms that has been giving interest to users for holding crypto on their own site?

Nope, they didn't offer that.

Good. One less thing for customers to worry about at night.

Rikafip

legendary

Activity: 1722

Merit: 5937

Quote from: o_e_l_e_o on February 13, 2023, 03:23:26 PM

I think stablecoins are scams as well. Tongue

Centralized, not fully backed up or collateralized, printed out of thin air, can be arbitrarily frozen or seized, have collapsed literally overnight... Worse than fiat!

Speaking of stablecoins, PayPal plans/planned to join the circus and issue their own but since their partner Paxos has problems with SEC as of lately (forcing them to stop minting BUSD and pressing charges) that will probably be put on hold.

Quote from: NotATether on February 14, 2023, 02:58:03 AM

Is Paypal one of those platforms that has been giving interest to users for holding crypto on their own site?

Nope, they didn't offer that.

NotATether

legendary

Activity: 1568

Merit: 6660

bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org

Is Paypal one of those platforms that has been giving interest to users for holding crypto on their own site? Hopefully not, as they should know better as to what has been happening to those kinds of services over the last few months.

Quote from: o_e_l_e_o on February 12, 2023, 04:26:34 AM

Quote from: RapTarX on February 11, 2023, 01:04:26 PM

How come such a big institution can't operate its own Cold wallet?

They can, but they don't care. They don't actually care about what is best for their users, otherwise they would let them actually withdraw bitcoin to their own wallets. All PayPal care about is taking a cut of trading fees. Far easier to find some random third party to do all the work for them and just sit as a middle man taking a cut, rather than actually invest in their own infrastructure to do things properly.

There could be a legal aspect to it as well. If PayPal lose "your" bitcoin, then you can sue PayPal directly. If some unknown third party lose "your" bitcoin, then PayPal simply put in a claim against the third party while being able to say "Well, not our fault!", and the customer is the one left out of pocket.

We all know how this is going to end.

"Chill out until the next crypto winter"

If custodian go bankrupt, Paypal will be in big trouble with the Feds.

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18771

Quote from: mk4 on February 13, 2023, 01:04:25 PM

I wouldn't disagree if you'd say that they're very bad investments(wouldn't necessarily agree as a scam), but the fact that you can move USDT/USDC using their networks makes them at least somewhat useful networks in my book.

I think stablecoins are scams as well. Tongue

Centralized, not fully backed up or collateralized, printed out of thin air, can be arbitrarily frozen or seized, have collapsed literally overnight... Worse than fiat!

mk4

legendary

Activity: 2870

Merit: 3873

📟 t3rminal.xyz

Quote from: o_e_l_e_o on February 13, 2023, 05:00:02 AM

I don't own any LTC, but at least they are making interesting developments with mimblewimble. The other 4 you have listed there are outright scams as far as I am concerned.

I wouldn't disagree if you'd say that they're very bad investments(wouldn't necessarily agree as a scam), but the fact that you can move USDT/USDC using their networks makes them at least somewhat useful networks in my book.

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18771

Quote from: SFR10 on February 12, 2023, 03:35:38 PM

They're claiming that they're "holding user assets in bankruptcy-remote accounts and it comes with digital asset insurance", but I couldn't find any useful information about the insured part.

So, going through their Terms and Conditions, I found exactly one reference to insurance in relation to crypto (rather than in relation to fiat). Here it is:

Quote from: mk4 on February 13, 2023, 01:34:08 AM

Love em or hate em and call them centralized all you want, but at least BNB, TRX, and SOL are more usefull than both LTC and BCH.

I don't own any LTC, but at least they are making interesting developments with mimblewimble. The other 4 you have listed there are outright scams as far as I am concerned.

noorman0

hero member

Activity: 1778

Merit: 709

[Nope]No hype delivers more than hope

Quote from: RapTarX on February 11, 2023, 01:04:26 PM

How come such a big institution can't operate its own Cold wallet?

It is shifting responsibility. Instead of them having to guarantee complete security, why not pass it on to other services dedicated to that purpose. Not to mention if Paypal got a "lucrative" deal with it.

Quote from: Darker45 on February 11, 2023, 11:26:49 PM

I think PayPal users are now allowed to withdraw their crypto to their personal wallets.

Somebody could please confirm this,

It's true, here's the news.

mk4

legendary

Activity: 2870

Merit: 3873

📟 t3rminal.xyz

Up to this day it still boggles my mind why of all other cryptocurrencies, PayPal decided to add freakin Litecoin and BitcoinCash. Love em or hate em and call them centralized all you want, but at least BNB, TRX, and SOL are more usefull than both LTC and BCH.

SFR10

legendary

Activity: 2968

Merit: 3406

Crypto Swap Exchange

Quote from: o_e_l_e_o on February 11, 2023, 11:19:51 AM

unnamed third party

Looks like it's Paxos ^{["dkbit98" mentioned their name with regard to another issue]}: How Paxos Works with PayPal to Build Innovative Crypto Products
^{- They're claiming that they're "holding user assets in bankruptcy-remote accounts and it comes with digital asset insurance", but I couldn't find any useful information about the insured part.}

hugeblack

legendary

Activity: 2702

Merit: 4002

Quote from: FatFork on February 11, 2023, 05:55:17 AM

The company's total financial assets were over $25 billion. Despite offering cryptocurrency services for more than two years, this is the first time PayPal has provided a breakdown of its crypto holdings in its annual financial report.

The answer to this question comes here.

Quote

An article on Cointelegraph ^[2] reports that PayPal keeps its customers' cryptocurrencies through the use of a third-party custodian.

I think that after what happened with Luna and the FTX, there has been a fear and a question from legislators about disclosing reserves and whether the platform is able to fulfill its obligations to clients or not.

I am surprised that the percentage is close to 2.5%, which is something that if most companies did, we would see big changes.

Rikafip

legendary

Activity: 1722

Merit: 5937

Quote from: FatFork on February 11, 2023, 05:55:17 AM

However, it appears that many still don't fully grasp the significance of the adage "not your keys, not your coins."

An average PayPal user doesn't care about "not your keys, not your coins", "be your own bank" and everything else that bitcoin stands for. They rather prefer sense of false security because why else would they use a service with such a high fees, other than being "protected" in case they send money to scammers.

PayPal is perfectly aware of that and for that reason they enabled withdrawals to external wallets 6 months ago (afaik still only available for US users) knowing that majority of people will still keep holding crypto on their platform.

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18771

Quote from: RapTarX on February 11, 2023, 01:04:26 PM

How come such a big institution can't operate its own Cold wallet?

They can, but they don't care. They don't actually care about what is best for their users, otherwise they would let them actually withdraw bitcoin to their own wallets. All PayPal care about is taking a cut of trading fees. Far easier to find some random third party to do all the work for them and just sit as a middle man taking a cut, rather than actually invest in their own infrastructure to do things properly.

There could be a legal aspect to it as well. If PayPal lose "your" bitcoin, then you can sue PayPal directly. If some unknown third party lose "your" bitcoin, then PayPal simply put in a claim against the third party while being able to say "Well, not our fault!", and the customer is the one left out of pocket.

Darker45

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 1860

Quote from: Stalker22 on February 11, 2023, 05:05:49 PM

Quote from: RapTarX on February 11, 2023, 01:04:26 PM

Quote from: tbct_mt2 on February 11, 2023, 07:07:45 AM

Risk to see the contract broken by that third-party custodian company is real. You can use Paypal to buy cryptocurrency if you don't want to use other platforms but withdraw your cryptocurrency to your non custodial wallets instantly after your deal on Paypal is done.

Did you mean Paypal allow its user to withdraw their fund? IIRC, their platform wasn't allowing any such on-chain transaction. They didn't allow their users to withdraw the fund in form of cryptocurrency.

Yes, that's correct. Currently, PayPal does not allow all their users to withdraw their crypto holdings in the form of an on-chain transaction to a personal wallet. Instead, they allow users to buy and sell cryptocurrency within the PayPal platform, but the actual funds are held by PayPal and not under the control of the user.

The last news I read about this:

Quote

08/12/2022 Update: We are pleased to announce that all eligible PayPal account holders in the U.S. can now transfer, send and receive cryptocurrency with PayPal. Download the PayPal app or log in to your account to learn more.

We are thrilled to announce that starting today, PayPal supports the native transfer of cryptocurrencies between PayPal and other wallets and exchanges

But I think this is still valid only for US based users.

I think PayPal users are now allowed to withdraw their crypto to their personal wallets.

Somebody could please confirm this, but I think the announcement mentioned above was about PayPal already adding the feature that allows users to withdraw their cryptocurrency to other wallets. So that must be on-chain transactions that are allowed.

In their site's FAQ, it is also indicated that the option to transfer cryptocurrency out of PayPal is available.

Stalker22

legendary

Activity: 1526

Merit: 1359

Quote from: RapTarX on February 11, 2023, 01:04:26 PM

Quote from: tbct_mt2 on February 11, 2023, 07:07:45 AM

Risk to see the contract broken by that third-party custodian company is real. You can use Paypal to buy cryptocurrency if you don't want to use other platforms but withdraw your cryptocurrency to your non custodial wallets instantly after your deal on Paypal is done.

Did you mean Paypal allow its user to withdraw their fund? IIRC, their platform wasn't allowing any such on-chain transaction. They didn't allow their users to withdraw the fund in form of cryptocurrency.

Yes, that's correct. Currently, PayPal does not allow all their users to withdraw their crypto holdings in the form of an on-chain transaction to a personal wallet. Instead, they allow users to buy and sell cryptocurrency within the PayPal platform, but the actual funds are held by PayPal and not under the control of the user.

The last news I read about this:

Quote

08/12/2022 Update: We are pleased to announce that all eligible PayPal account holders in the U.S. can now transfer, send and receive cryptocurrency with PayPal. Download the PayPal app or log in to your account to learn more.

We are thrilled to announce that starting today, PayPal supports the native transfer of cryptocurrencies between PayPal and other wallets and exchanges

But I think this is still valid only for US based users.

dkbit98

legendary

Activity: 2212

Merit: 7064

I am not surprised they are holding so much Bitcoins, and nobody knows how much fiat money they confiscated for all this years Roll Eyes

Maybe someone heard that PayPay was working on creating their own stable ccoin cryptocurrency for some time, but after recent regulations changes they decided to temporary stop with that activity.
They worked with Paxos to create this new ''stable'' Paypal coin, but Paxos is currently under investigation by NY financial regulators, maybe because Binance is involved in alll this.
I wouldn't connect any Bitcoin with PayPal account, and I wouldn't use any potential stable coin they may release in future.
More info about this:
https://archive.ph/oZP0B

RapTarX

hero member

Activity: 1358

Merit: 851

Quote from: FatFork on February 11, 2023, 05:55:17 AM

An article on Cointelegraph ^[2] reports that PayPal keeps its customers' cryptocurrencies through the use of a third-party custodian.

How come such a big institution can't operate its own Cold wallet? Such a bad move. They, in fact, are still in the same boat they used to be in despite the fact that their platform enabled crypto exchange/deposit. I can't imagine what new excuses may come in the coming future from their custodian party.

Quote from: tbct_mt2 on February 11, 2023, 07:07:45 AM

Risk to see the contract broken by that third-party custodian company is real. You can use Paypal to buy cryptocurrency if you don't want to use other platforms but withdraw your cryptocurrency to your non custodial wallets instantly after your deal on Paypal is done.

Did you mean Paypal allow its user to withdraw their fund? IIRC, their platform wasn't allowing any such on-chain transaction. They didn't allow their users to withdraw the fund in form of cryptocurrency.

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18771

So if you buy bitcoin via PayPal, then you don't even have an IOU like you do at a centralized exchange, but you have an IOU of an IOU. Some unknown third party promises to pay PayPal x amount of bitcoin, and PayPal promise to then pay you that amount of bitcoin. Somehow, they have made buying bitcoin involve even more third parties than using a bank, rather than the zero third parties bitcoin was designed for. That's so awful it's almost impressive.

The SEC document is very clear, though - coins are not yours, PayPal have absolutely no idea how secure or not the coins are or what the unnamed third party is doing with the coins, and in the event of bankruptcy/scams/hacks/whatever you will almost certainly get nothing back (just like the users of FTX, Celsius, Voyager, etc.). No doubt when it all comes crashing down then just like every other centralized exchange in the past few months there will be plenty of angry users who did not bother to read any of this and realize what they were signing up to.

PX-Z

hero member

Activity: 1554

Merit: 880

Notify wallet transaction @txnNotifierBot

Quote from: FatFork on February 11, 2023, 05:55:17 AM

I'm not sure whether PayPal has enabled the withdrawal of cryptocurrency funds to personal wallets for all users. However, it appears that many still don't fully grasp the significance of the adage "not your keys, not your coins."

Actually many people or crypto users knows about this line but still prefer to rely to these financial institutions ^{(kyc required)} because of so many reasons including laziness, no sense of responsibility, victims of false security and many more. That's why institutions like this still running and lots of users than non-custodial users. Well, with the previous shutting down of different institutions lots of these users lost their funds which is one of the risks of using them and the ideal reasons why "not your keys, not your coins" line exists.

Topic: PayPal Crypto Holdings Report (Read 258 times)