Pages:
Author

Topic: please delete - page 8. (Read 18351 times)

donator
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1079
Gerald Davis
February 06, 2012, 06:02:45 PM
#4
However, the bids are simple as far as I can see. Before placing a bid the software will check to see if the amount you are trading exists in your wallet before allowing it to go through.

These are difficult to solve problem which will likely require some kind of distributed escrow, multi-signature solution, or fiat based crypto-currency.  To say it is "easy" would indicate you haven't thought this out.

So the checking is done in the client?  
The client which will be open source?  
The source code anyone can modify to include the "checking portion"?

So my modified version will let me spam the network with bogus bids and asks?

A 3rd party exchange serves two major functions:
a) to ensure the trader has the asset being traded.
b) to ensure the trader can't avoid trading when his trade is matched.

The entire decentralized p2p exchange boils down to solving those two problems.

newbie
Activity: 34
Merit: 0
February 06, 2012, 06:00:07 PM
#3
Couple issues:
You haven't explained how the trade happens without 3rd party.  This is a non-trivial problem.
Buyer has USD.  Seller has BTC.  They agree on an exchange.  How EXACTLY do you intend to faciltate the transfer so that Seller's BTC go  to Buyer's wallet and Buyer's USD get transfered to seller's Dwolla account without one party just taking both and leaving.

You haven't explained how you will enforce bids without a 3rd party.  This is a non-trivial problem.
I offer for sale 1,000,000 BTC @ $1 ea.  How do you ensure that I have 1,000,000 BTC and that I can't remove the order once matched and executed. 

There likely are solutions but you seem to have glossed away the entire problem which isn't reassuring.

I haven't glossed away anything. I said that I want people to give their ideas. I'm aware (and even said so) that the trade system is not full-proof. However, the bids are simple as far as I can see. Before placing a bid the software will check to see if the amount you are trading exists in your wallet before allowing it to go through.

All Best,

Michael
donator
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1079
Gerald Davis
February 06, 2012, 05:52:00 PM
#2
Couple issues:
You haven't explained how the trade happens without 3rd party.  This is a non-trivial problem.
Buyer has USD.  Seller has BTC.  They agree on an exchange.  How EXACTLY do you intend to faciltate the transfer so that Seller's BTC go  to Buyer's wallet and Buyer's USD get transfered to seller's Dwolla account without one party just taking both and leaving.

You haven't explained how you will enforce bids without a 3rd party.  This is a non-trivial problem.
I offer for sale 1,000,000 BTC @ $1 ea.  How do you ensure that I have 1,000,000 BTC and that I can't remove the order once matched and executed. 

There likely are solutions but you seem to have glossed away the entire problem which isn't reassuring.
newbie
Activity: 34
Merit: 0
February 06, 2012, 05:43:55 PM
#1
please delete

project abandoned long time ago
Pages:
Jump to: