question about china / i feel, strange rulings

taltamir

full member

Activity: 196

Merit: 100

Quote from: hilariousandco on December 19, 2013, 04:08:28 PM

Quote from: Ford on December 17, 2013, 02:05:49 PM

Given that it is within the power of the Chinese Gov, to ban or at least ban all Chinese companies from dealing in Bitcoin, why have they not simply banned it?

How could they ban it and under what grounds? Even if they did 'ban' it, it's not going to stop people from using it.

When countries have severe hyperinflation they always ban the use of foreign currency and everyone keeps on doing it. At some point people are pushed far enough that they perform civil disobedience.

luqash3

newbie

Activity: 42

Merit: 0

You are a critical thinker Ford I must say. I guess china is not trying to over react to a newly popularized digital currency but it might gradually take measures against bitcoin to make it crash slowly. It can’t ban it outright because many Chinese civilians have their stake in bitcoins currently so it shall kill bitcoin slowly.

hilariousandco

global moderator

Activity: 4018

Merit: 2728

Join the world-leading crypto sportsbook NOW!

Quote from: Ford on December 17, 2013, 02:05:49 PM

Given that it is within the power of the Chinese Gov, to ban or at least ban all Chinese companies from dealing in Bitcoin, why have they not simply banned it?

How could they ban it and under what grounds? Even if they did 'ban' it, it's not going to stop people from using it.

viajero

member

Activity: 110

Merit: 10

Quote from: Siegfried on December 17, 2013, 07:53:43 PM

Maybe the government itself wants some time to stealthily acquire a hoard of bitcoin. In the meantime, they will observe how it plays out in the rest of the world and then relax restrictions once they better understand how it will effect they economy.

this is exactly what i thought. they are afraid of the destructive threat, but they also see the advantages. so they just cripple it for the moment, taking away the threat and just wait and see how it will end up in the rest of the world. if they want, they can easily loosen the restrictions if needed. that would be very complicated after a official ban. further more they have probably already realized, that there is no way to enforce a total ban bcs bitcoiners would just go off the grid and therefore out of governmental controll.

so actually this chinese move is kind of smart (as often) though probably kills any chinese bitcoin inovation for the moment. let the others take the risk and adapt later if necessary.

i for my part would be much more happy with a full ban! would take a lot of uncertainty off the BTC prize and it would be even more interessting to see if and how bitcoin could survive a full blown ban.

viajero

member

Activity: 110

Merit: 10

Quote from: Siegfried on December 17, 2013, 07:53:43 PM

Maybe the government itself wants some time to stealthily acquire a hoard of bitcoin. In the meantime, they will observe how it plays out in the rest of the world and then relax restrictions once they better understand how it will effect they economy.

this is exactly what i thought. they are afraid of the destructive threat, but they also see the advantages. so they just cripple it for the moment, taking away the threat and just wait and see how it will end up in the rest of the world. if they want, they can easily loosen the restrictions if needed. that would be very complicated after a official ban. further more they have probably already realized, that there is no way to enforce a total ban bcs bitcoiners would just go off the grid and therefore out of governmental controll.

so actually this chinese move is kind of smart (as often) though probably kills any chinese bitcoin inovation for the moment. let the others take the risk and adapt later if necessary.

i for my part would be much more happy with a full ban! would take a lot of uncertainty off the BTC prize and it would be even more interessting to see how the chinese bitcoin comunity would adapt.

mvalley

full member

Activity: 129

Merit: 100

Can people purchase BTC using USD within China using any exchange? A lot of folks have USD over there and/or can buy USD on the black market.

jixin55

newbie

Activity: 39

Merit: 0

i am in china.

basically they dont allow banks and processors to send money TO exchanges, however the reverse is allowed.

so nobody can buy BTC with chinese RMB, creating a sell BTC only situation.

tacoman71

sr. member

Activity: 320

Merit: 250

Have you read my post about the supposed "ban"? https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=375228.0sp

Siegfried

sr. member

Activity: 266

Merit: 250

Maybe the government itself wants some time to stealthily acquire a hoard of bitcoin. In the meantime, they will observe how it plays out in the rest of the world and then relax restrictions once they better understand how it will effect they economy.

taltamir

full member

Activity: 196

Merit: 100

Quote from: pening on December 17, 2013, 02:52:40 PM

I see the current situation is tactical. By restricting payment processing you restrict everyday man-in-the-street use, without harming those who want to use it as a value store or involved in international trade (in particular chip fabs). They don't need to ban it if its no threat, if mainstream access is limited its not much of a threat.

This makes perfect sense, its not even just the chip fabs, any positive you can come up with can be enjoyed by the government and cronies, while every "negative" (for the government) scenario is stopped by denying it to the serfs

kwoody

sr. member

Activity: 454

Merit: 250

Technology and Women. Amazing.

chip fabs likely have something to do with it.
could also be testing the resilience of bitcoin itself.
chances are the bankers are just afraid.
any number of plausible scenarios, really.

qualia8

full member

Activity: 237

Merit: 100

Quote from: taltamir on December 17, 2013, 03:02:03 PM

Quote from: EvilPanda on December 17, 2013, 02:55:00 PM

So what may the government be concerned about (random order):
1) Foreign money transfers and money laundering
2) Tax avoidance
3) Pressure from the banks losing profits
4) Losing control over the people who gain more financial independence.
5) Black market trade

Some of these problems (like nr 2) may be easy to deal with, some are IMO impossible (nr 3, 4). Banks are the losing side here, some of them will adapt and others will fight.

what governments are REALLY afraid of is the inability to print money. This would massive reduce their effective tax revenue since inflation is a nothing but a stealth tax

All of these are true, but easily foreseeable. The question is why were those state television / newspaper articles run in the first place?

laowai80

member

Activity: 98

Merit: 10

Quote from: pening on December 17, 2013, 02:52:40 PM

I see the current situation is tactical. By restricting payment processing you restrict everyday man-in-the-street use, without harming those who want to use it as a value store or involved in international trade (in particular chip fabs). They don't need to ban it if its no threat, if mainstream access is limited its not much of a threat.

Good point.

taltamir

full member

Activity: 196

Merit: 100

Quote from: EvilPanda on December 17, 2013, 02:55:00 PM

So what may the government be concerned about (random order):
1) Foreign money transfers and money laundering
2) Tax avoidance
3) Pressure from the banks losing profits
4) Losing control over the people who gain more financial independence.
5) Black market trade

Some of these problems (like nr 2) may be easy to deal with, some are IMO impossible (nr 3, 4). Banks are the losing side here, some of them will adapt and others will fight.

what governments are REALLY afraid of is the inability to print money. This would massive reduce their effective tax revenue since inflation is a nothing but a stealth tax

EvilPanda

hero member

Activity: 658

Merit: 500

Small Red and Bad

So what may the government be concerned about (random order):
1) Foreign money transfers and money laundering
2) Tax avoidance
3) Pressure from the banks losing profits
4) Losing control over the people who gain more financial independence.
5) Black market trade

Some of these problems (like nr 2) may be easy to deal with, some are IMO impossible (nr 3, 4). Banks are the losing side here, some of them will adapt and others will fight.

pening

sr. member

Activity: 245

Merit: 250

Quote from: FandangledGizmo on December 17, 2013, 02:39:54 PM

Yes it's very unusual for China, they usually make very logical, considered and tactical decisions.

I see the current situation is tactical. By restricting payment processing you restrict everyday man-in-the-street use, without harming those who want to use it as a value store or involved in international trade (in particular chip fabs). They don't need to ban it if its no threat, if mainstream access is limited its not much of a threat.

t1000

full member

Activity: 182

Merit: 100

Quote from: FandangledGizmo on December 17, 2013, 02:39:54 PM

This Chinese proverb I found on Wikiquote seems apt.

风向转变时,有人筑墙,有人造风车

When the wind of change blows, some build walls, while others build windmills.

Nice.

FandangledGizmo

legendary

Activity: 1138

Merit: 1001

Yes it's very unusual for China, they usually make very logical, considered and tactical decisions.

But to seemingly both, close the door on Crypto-Currencies & do it in such a haphazard way, you have to question if they are ready for the future.
I guess we will have to see how this plays out.

This Chinese proverb I found on Wikiquote seems apt.

风向转变时,有人筑墙,有人造风车

When the wind of change blows, some build walls, while others build windmills.

Ford

full member

Activity: 120

Merit: 100

Quote from: t1000 on December 17, 2013, 02:21:45 PM

I think it is very strange too.

First of all why would China let bitcoin get so far before waving the ban hammer around. It's not like any of the bitcoin companies are independent of government elements anyway.

Secondly, why do it in two goes. First they banned banks and financial institutes from dealing in bitcoins, then they banned 3rd party payment processors from dealing with exchanges, two weeks after the first ban.

Thirdly, it's sounds to me like these decisions are all made by the PBOC, haphazardly, It just feels to me like the central bank and the state are not taking the same stance on bitcoin. It feels like the bankers are trying to protect their interests while the people want bitcoin.

My points exactly + from other earlier "actions" china have been actively encouraging bitcoin use, although i dont see how bitcoin will harm the investments of PBOC (i know may people think it will harm banks, but i am yet to see any good arguments as to why and how (it will have an effect, but not a devastating one). i feel banks can still have their place in a more bitcoin friendly economy )

I am wondering if PBOC want to slow the increase in value of bitcoin, to a more stable and steady increase...... why they would want to do this though, is for speculation

t1000

full member

Activity: 182

Merit: 100

I think it is very strange too.

First of all why would China let bitcoin get so far before waving the ban hammer around. It's not like any of the bitcoin companies are independent of government elements anyway.

Secondly, why do it in two goes. First they banned banks and financial institutes from dealing in bitcoins, then they banned 3rd party payment processors from dealing with exchanges, two weeks after the first ban.

Thirdly, it's sounds to me like these decisions are all made by the PBOC, haphazardly, It just feels to me like the central bank and the state are not taking the same stance on bitcoin. It feels like the bankers are trying to protect their interests while the people want bitcoin.

Topic: question about china / i feel, strange rulings (Read 1982 times)