Your statements are contradictory. On one side, you are saying that a coin has utility. On the other side, you saying someone else make identical coin!
Now if Apple makes Mac Book, it doesn't mean anyone else can make computer with same specifications and can sell at same price as of Apple. Apple has brand name and userbase which is not easy to take up.
Similarly just creating a copy of coin (which is however possible), it is not possible to take up its operation and userbase. However, it is possible in case of speculative coin.