Topic: Registration Captcha - WTF! (Read 1051 times)
I think the game captcha is kinda nice. Just complete a simple game and pass instead of trying to read the messed up word. Not really sure how good is this against bot though.
It is to avoid bots.
It is, but only captcha doesn't stop them, SMF is using very old captcha and today's spamming software like xrumer are very advanced, they can bypass mail registration and recaptcha easily.
In my opinion theymos should use something like this areyouahuman.com (it's not currently available for SMF)
I had issues with mine also I tried several time before it finally got one I could read...
had to reload page once then then 200% on browser. hardest one ive ever seen or not seen
LOL
actually captcha's do not stop bots at all. in my personal experience, the only thing that works is logic questions such as:
If the sky is blue, does that make an orange green?
the answer would be no, and the bot is confused because there are two questions inside of one question. another good example would be
"I apologize for the length of this question, but how secure is to secure? please type three spaces in the box followed by the very first word on this page. "
these are very easy to setup with SMF forum.
sources: running forums for 3 years now.
total bot signups with captchas: 11,968
total since removing captcha and adding logic questions: 0
If the sky is blue, does that make an orange green?
the answer would be no, and the bot is confused because there are two questions inside of one question. another good example would be
"I apologize for the length of this question, but how secure is to secure? please type three spaces in the box followed by the very first word on this page. "
these are very easy to setup with SMF forum.
sources: running forums for 3 years now.
total bot signups with captchas: 11,968
total since removing captcha and adding logic questions: 0
This is great, thanks.
It is to avoid bots.
Haha the same thing happened to me lol
I have never had a more difficult to read set of captcha images! I must have attempted to answer 8 times, and the "new image" link didn't help at all as it just shifted the image a few pixels to the right.
I understand the need to stop bots but a better captcha is definitely needed. One that is actually somewhat human readable would be nice.
I understand the need to stop bots but a better captcha is definitely needed. One that is actually somewhat human readable would be nice.
I Agree with you, i said this in simplemachine's community before and they also agreed that it sucks.
http://www.simplemachines.org/community/index.php?topic=504537
Especially when people are willing to solve captcha's for a few micro coins at various earn free coins sites.
Yup, fools working for less than minimum wage so the bots have a library of solved captchas.
Yup, fools working for less than minimum wage so the bots have a library of solved captchas.
Minimum wages aren't the same everywhere, and not everyone can land a minimum wage job. (Economics 101: Minimum wages create a price floor, which leads to unemployment. Essentially, it's still better for a human to "waste time" making very little money solving capchas, than doing nothing at all.)
The logic question "capcha" seems like a good idea to me.
Justify it to yourself however you want, but it is taking blatant advantage of them and is wrong.
the harder captcha to read, the better bot protection
not always the case....
the harder captcha to read, the better bot protection
I bet you a dollar that I can flood that forum with spam, the logic questions only work if they change!!
yeah. and they will as soon as the next spam registration occurs. not taking that bet....
-
Especially when people are willing to solve captcha's for a few micro coins at various earn free coins sites.
Yup, fools working for less than minimum wage so the bots have a library of solved captchas.
Yup, fools working for less than minimum wage so the bots have a library of solved captchas.
Minimum wages aren't the same everywhere, and not everyone can land a minimum wage job. (Economics 101: Minimum wages create a price floor, which leads to unemployment. Essentially, it's still better for a human to "waste time" making very little money solving capchas, than doing nothing at all.)
The logic question "capcha" seems like a good idea to me.
Here, to see an example of them in working order
http://www.trollzilla.tk/forum/register/
No matter how bad the spam is I have to agree captchas are fucking awful, I refuse to have them on my site anywhere.
Especially when people are willing to solve captcha's for a few micro coins at various earn free coins sites.
Yup, fools working for less than minimum wage so the bots have a library of solved captchas.
Yup, fools working for less than minimum wage so the bots have a library of solved captchas.
Minimum wages aren't the same everywhere, and not everyone can land a minimum wage job. (Economics 101: Minimum wages create a price floor, which leads to unemployment. Essentially, it's still better for a human to "waste time" making very little money solving capchas, than doing nothing at all.)
The logic question "capcha" seems like a good idea to me.
actually captcha's do not stop bots at all.
Especially when people are willing to solve captcha's for a few micro coins at various earn free coins sites.
Yup, fools working for less than minimum wage so the bots have a library of solved captchas.
I had trouble with the captchas on my PM system also.
actually captcha's do not stop bots at all. in my personal experience, the only thing that works is logic questions such as:
If the sky is blue, does that make an orange green?
the answer would be no, and the bot is confused because there are two questions inside of one question. another good example would be
"I apologize for the length of this question, but how secure is to secure? please type three spaces in the box followed by the very first word on this page. "
these are very easy to setup with SMF forum.
sources: running forums for 3 years now.
total bot signups with captchas: 11,968
total since removing captcha and adding logic questions: 0
If the sky is blue, does that make an orange green?
the answer would be no, and the bot is confused because there are two questions inside of one question. another good example would be
"I apologize for the length of this question, but how secure is to secure? please type three spaces in the box followed by the very first word on this page. "
these are very easy to setup with SMF forum.
sources: running forums for 3 years now.
total bot signups with captchas: 11,968
total since removing captcha and adding logic questions: 0
Jump to: