Most times, life doesn't go straight as planned. Things happen that can adversely change the direction of our plans. I don't want to say shit happens but then that's what it's. I've seen businesses go down and run owners into great debts instead of providing them financial liberation. I dare say there's no guarantee a business will bring anyone fortunes. However, business pays if it goes well.
I agree with you that the success of every investment is based on planning, and to some religionists, this is also applicable. Buying a house isn't a bad idea; in fact, I see every land-owned property as the right choice of investment to some point because the more development gets to those areas, the more value the property is adding over time. We all have different views when it comes to loans and how they could be perfectly utilized in other ways to be productive. Buying a house with a salary loan is not part of my successful story. Just like you have said, things happen. Not every time that we can expect things to happen in our favor, at some point we also face difficult times.
Before any company could successfully give out such a loan to an employee, I know there are certain criteria that must be met, such as his or her position in the company, their chances of lasting so long in the company until the loan is fully repaid, etc., which looks like a perfect business plan mapped out for the company. At the end of the day, they will get their money back. But do you also not wonder what happens if things happen like you said? If the employee gets some demotion based on underperformance, we never know what will happen. Or what if the company runs a little low in demand and, as a result, income is reduced? This will require them to reduce staff in order to fit in their expenses (this kind of situation is only possible in private enterprise).
What do you think will be the faith of those who own the company? Let's not forget that after the loan, their salary will be reduced by some percentage, which they will be deducting from their salary monthly, and the family's way of life will also reduce. And if they fall victim to demotion, I don't think it will affect their agreed monthly payable amount. What do you think will be left with the debtor to go back home with at the end of the day? What if they are being dropped from work? What will be the faith of that loan? Where will they be paying it back from? Or what if something happens in the future and the person who took the loan is no longer able to work because of a health issue or has passed away? What will happen to the loan or the property acquired through the loan?
These are all the things that I always calculate and reason about before thinking of any form of salary loan, which is why I could only possibly use part of it to set up a business that could be used as backup income for me in case things go sideways.