I dont really think I'm the best person to help you resolve your ongoing issue, since there seems to be a lot of prior back and forth with other moderators/admins/users and each time I make a reply, some new information comes out making my previous best guesses of the situation obsolete.
My best assumption at this point (again I'm sure it will be wrong and new info will come out as soon as I post this) is that this battle that you had previously was before the new Doxing rules were implemented. One of the quotes you have linked is from August 8th, so I'm guessing this has been a much longer ongoing thing. After August 5th, any applicable threads were moved to the Investigations board. If the threads you are talking about are still out there elsewhere, please report them and they will be moved there. As I said, my best guess at this point in time about why some users were allowed to do something and others weren't is because they were in two different times. Before and After the doxing rules came into play.
This sounds promissing, your answers are different then those from your comods/admins. You are very correct in your assumption, it goes since very lnog time and has a lot of factors, but to bring you to the starting point, it was GAW thread where suchmoon and here buddies started verbal harrasment attacks because I asked them to stop harrasing other bitcointalk users, especially newbies. This was starting point, where suchmoon tried to change it to another agenda, saying that I shill and so on. Then she created several threads spreading again lies and agenda (think on the supermarkt test from OP). This is where some trolls, which are on my ignore list, like Phildo, they come and answer somthing without even to think about it. They all knew that I am Boris, suchmoon had even conversation with me over PM, this conversation started with me stating my name. We will get much closer when you ask yourself how and why so many users do support usage of someone's name and stolen data, even when they were pointed to it, they ignored it, as well as staff and theymos which never replied. As next, I think it is alarming if you understand how low level all this is, especially how wrong the reaction from beginn until now was, I mean bitcointalk staff.
theynos replied and came to clean up after suchmoon has been doxxed and his solution was to threat and ban me. I do not understand this solution and nobody of bitcointalk staff is explaining it. Can you?
Phildo is to be banned, together with owlcats and others.