Topic: [resolved] Betcoin.ag Scam: Removed funds from my account for bogus reasons (Read 286 times)

Cool!

Mods, feel free to delete. This is resolved.

Whatever you think is best (Please at least lock and mark resolved )

We are going to contact you privately, as well, because we are considering turning this promotion into a regular event and believe you could assist with the numbers. Thanks again to all parties for your patience while this was resolved.

Awesome work all of you and Betcoin.ag.
Interesting flashflip wallets, I had no idea how it works LOL

You can edit the title and replace it with something like:
"Betcoin.ag Scam [SOLVED]: Removed funds from my account for bogus reasons"

You can not delete a topic unfortunately.

All of you good luck and again good job Betcoin.ag for solving this very quick, in fact the quickest ever I have involved with any accusation topic :-D

Welp, that does it for me. No doubt in my mind that you guys are as legit as it gets. It really just was a misunderstanding after all

Thanks, and I hope you guys do more of these contests - I'll definitely come play

I'll edit the post's title and body. Or would you prefer I delete it entirely?

Thank you for the clarification.  We have to admit our ignorance in the way this bot works. Normally, if you are withdrawing from the service to Betcoin, that is 1 transfer, without hops in between. Very interesting stuff.

We have reopened both other accounts. Majesty, you can continue working on your rollover. Chiefleaks, you have been credited your winnings and can get started. Please let us know if we can assist further.

"Is there a blockchain transaction ID for this loan? Or if the funds are transferred internally, what is the blockchain transaction ID of your withdrawal? Your account was funded by a wallet with 1.2 mBTC. It is possible the fees ate the rest, but there would have to be a transaction where this happened."

Yes, I've edited the post and included the ID of my withdrawal. Me going through the information provided in previous post can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xdUNZzQifzk

I am majesty

I made a withdraw from the discord bot Flashflip you can see the screenshot here:
https://ibb.co/yBvCjxD

You can see the transaction id that was attached to the withdraw.
I was kyced to get the prize as well so this should be clear that im not in the wrong here.

Is there a blockchain transaction ID for this loan? Or if the funds are transferred internally, what is the blockchain transaction ID of your withdrawal? Your account was funded by a wallet with 1.2 mBTC. It is possible the fees ate the rest, but there would have to be a transaction where this happened.

Thank you very much. Can't tell you how much I appreciate it.

I'll go wager, withdraw, and will edit the thread a bit later

<3

"We agree that it could be a misunderstanding, but it doesn't seem like it so far. Chiefleaks, you are a part of this conversation. The funds you received to deposited to Betcoin came directly from whom?"

Sure thing, I'd love to explain it thoroughly.

After seeing what your website and promotion was all about, it obviously sparked major interest and resulted in me opening my own account.

I've had no Bitcoin at the time so I ended up taking a loan worth 2 mBTC (2,000 bits on Flashflip) from unrelated user Frostynut.

As seen in this screenshot: https://i.imgur.com/3dgCgYT.png ; the 2 mBTC (2,000 bits) were tipped to me by said user, Frostynut.

This screenshot: https://i.imgur.com/v4r1uwv.png ; shows me sending a screenshot to Frostynut, the user who loaned me, which shows me sending them back their 2,5 mBTC (2,500 bits), and them confirming recieving said amount.

When it comes to Frostynut and where the money he loaned me came from, it's pretty simple. He deposited his own funds into the casino, won a fair amount and decided to loan it out instead of continuing to play.

This screenshot: https://i.imgur.com/Ib1zQau.png ; shows I withdrew the 2 mBTC (2,000 bits) from Flashflip directly to Betcoin (the amount being lower due to network fees.

I will record a video of all of this as well to avoid any claims that the information provided is false.

We have returned your seized funds and you are eligible to complete the rollover and withdraw.

We still believe that the other 2 members of the group have funded their account from the same private wallet, and we have shown evidence backing this up. If either of them disputes this, we will review.

Yep, I understand the rollover part

I'll get Toni/Frostnut/Majesty to come on and post their deposit addresses. I've also DM'd Jason.

Perhaps our diagrams aren't clear, but we understand where your funds came from. It is our belief that this is not the case with one of the members of your group.

You understand the risk/win part of the rollover now, right?

This may help with the diagram.
The account, Chiefleaks, was funded by this transaction
https://www.blockchain.com/btc/tx/d8381086eef9b95d23bc2e649252e8091ea361f40f06a4389448ed4ce80b06af
The input address on that is bc1qxgvta69hr6hk24wr4qffw0k0pnf3a7a5p5kdjp
The account Majesty was funded by this transaction
https://www.blockchain.com/btc/tx/649c4d45c159ebf913713e6ec31b1c3fcc1d5f852c6994af2fb45a4e255fc7da
The output address is bc1qxgvta69hr6hk24wr4qffw0k0pnf3a7a5p5kdjp

We agree that it could be a misunderstanding, but it doesn't seem like it so far. Chiefleaks, you are a part of this conversation. The funds you received to deposited to Betcoin came directly from whom?

Right - the video does clear it up pretty well imo. I also think it's just a misunderstanding.

This is simply how casinos work. Deposits go to a singular hot wallet, and withdrawals are made using the same inputs. Sure, some advanced casinos (like bustabit) are really good at masking all of this, but flashflip uses zero privacy whatsoever. It's literally just a Bitcoin node. Moreover, every user account only has a single deposit address - you can't even generate new ones.

Thanks StackGambler, pretty convincing however give me time before I give you any more input. I still need to understand other things with Betcoin.AG. This could be a misunderstanding from Betcoin.AG and I do not want to hurry up in anything. There are other members too who will have their views too after their own investigations. So please be patience.

I need to spend much time in this about the private wallet we are talking here (Sorry not much idea about this diagram, old school lol). I will get back to you in the next 24 hours (once I get time to spend enough time to clear my thoughts). Sorry, at first it seemed very straight forward case to me but it seems it's not anymore.

Let's see here.

"It is common policy among Bitcoin casinos that accounts cannot be funded from the same private wallets."
I've been gambling with Bitcoin for several years and this is the first time I hear something like this.

"This rule is in place primarily to prevent multi-accounting. With the prevalence of VPN (many undetectable), it is no longer as easy as "same IP, same guy.""
You forcefully KYC'ed 2 of the 3 people involved, giving them a 60 minute timeframe which is, again, something I've never heard before.

"Each player can create only one personal user account."
None of us have broken this rule.

"There can be no more than 1 account created per household."
Again, none of us broke this rule.

"Creating multiple user accounts will lead to termination of the accounts."
Yet again, none of us broke this rule.

"We understand that a service wallet was involved here."
It's called a hot wallet. Used in most, if not all reputable Bitcoin casinos, and in no way should be used as proof for anything like this.

What does this even mean? lol

Well, I literally just proved that it came from flashflip. We are all three different people from three different households. There is no valid reason whatsoever to steal the bonus balances.

It is common policy among Bitcoin casinos that accounts cannot be funded from the same private wallets. This rule is in place primarily to prevent multi-accounting. With the prevalence of VPN (many undetectable), it is no longer as easy as "same IP, same guy." The blockchain is one fingerprint used in determining the unique identity of someone. Saying that a friend with Bitcoin can help them is great in theory, but it is comparable to saying that the other login from my IP is from my roommate. It doesn't guarantee a multi-accounter, but is one tool that is used in taking steps towards a resolution. We also detailed several other ways that the accounts are related in out initial reply, which have been confirmed by OP.

We will answer both of these here:
https://www.betcoin.ag/support/betcoinag-terms-service
7.1 Each player can create only one personal user account. There can be no more than 1 account created per household. Creating multiple user accounts will lead to termination of the accounts. All betting accounts you try to open may be blocked or closed and any bets may be voided. Depending on the severity of the case Betcoin.ag holds the right to withhold or take any funds deposited to pay for damages and/or the prevention of future misconduct.
The KYC was used as a way of determining the severity of the offense.

We understand that a service wallet was involved here. However, the service wallet funded a private wallet, part of which was used to fund Majesty's Betcoin account, part of which was sent to another private wallet, which was used to fund Chiefleak's Betcoin account.
https://imgur.com/a/RrGwjVR