Topic: RX5700 Vs RX6700 (Read 292 times)
@Cryptomining2003 I don't really get you mate, is your 4x rx5700 pulling 550W from wall or 2x of 550w ? Because it seems like power measurements from mining softwares are all blunt lies, please do reply on this because I really want to know
i saw many 5500xt that can do around 29mh at 50 watts.
Maybe someone have one for me for tests?
It looks like that this is data from HiveOS or RaveOS, it isn`t correct. You need to use a wattmeter to get true values with AMD GPUs.Maybe someone have one for me for tests?
my better 5500xt do 27 mh at 53-55 watts.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
My 5500xt are about 28mh at 75-80watts, only RaveOS configured. My 5600xt are flashed and about 43mh at 100-110watts. Before flashing 5600xt gave me about 39-40mh with the same power consumption.my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
Yeah here goes. all smos
Msi 5600xt 37.93 mh at 79 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.92 mh at 78 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.93 mh at 78 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.77 mh at 77 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.95 mh at 76 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.17 mh at 91 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.17 mh at 86 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.39 mh at 79 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.66 mh at 106 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.60 mh at 103 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.58 mh at 106 watts
powerColor 5700xt 50.88 mh at 113 watts------ an rma replacement card
Xfx 5700xt 50.36 mh at 100 watts
amd 5700xl 49.48 mh at 103 watts
amd 5700 xl 49.54 mh at 104 watts
msi 5700xl 49.45 mh at 109 watts ------- this card has issues
msi 5700xt 50.28 mh at 115 watts ------- this card also has issues
msi 5700xt 40.49 mh at 95 watts -------- this card really is weird
asus 5500xt 26.02 mh at 61 watts
msi. 5500xt 26.02 mh at 56 watts
msi 5500xt 25.44 mh at 56 watts
asrock 5500xt 24.67 mh at 72 watts ------ a mini card runs hot also a replacement rma
his 5500xt 25.19 mh at 56 watts ------ good mini card
his. 5500 xt 25.29 mh at 57 watts------ good mini card
of the 24 above the 5600xt clearly do best
those are the smos software numbers for watts and mh
This Power consumption data is totally useless. YOU NEED TO MEASURE POWER AT WALL
Card does not show the total power needed...only Nvidia cards can show good power data, AMD always shows less.
My 5700 do 55 Mhash at around 60 watts....so that´s the real efficiency king
https://s12.directupload.net/images/210430/29pur7ve.png
At wall this rig makes 550 W....so its 2 times more in total.
my better 5500xt do 27 mh at 53-55 watts.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
Damn I wish I can get six of those, this is the real definition of power efficiency, two rx5500 will draw 106 to 110 watt @54 MH, damn that's cool and I heard those cards works so cool at good temp my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
I pushed getting cards from april 2020 and got all my amd cards in 2020.
so they were cheap.
It is very tempting to sell them all in one shot.
I sold one 5500xt for 400 and have held all the others.
My 5500xt are about 28mh at 75-80watts, only RaveOS configured. My 5600xt are flashed and about 43mh at 100-110watts. Before flashing 5600xt gave me about 39-40mh with the same power consumption.
Yeah here goes. all smos
Msi 5600xt 37.93 mh at 79 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.92 mh at 78 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.93 mh at 78 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.77 mh at 77 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.95 mh at 76 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.17 mh at 91 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.17 mh at 86 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.39 mh at 79 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.66 mh at 106 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.60 mh at 103 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.58 mh at 106 watts
powerColor 5700xt 50.88 mh at 113 watts------ an rma replacement card
Xfx 5700xt 50.36 mh at 100 watts
amd 5700xl 49.48 mh at 103 watts
amd 5700 xl 49.54 mh at 104 watts
msi 5700xl 49.45 mh at 109 watts ------- this card has issues
msi 5700xt 50.28 mh at 115 watts ------- this card also has issues
msi 5700xt 40.49 mh at 95 watts -------- this card really is weird
asus 5500xt 26.02 mh at 61 watts
msi. 5500xt 26.02 mh at 56 watts
msi 5500xt 25.44 mh at 56 watts
asrock 5500xt 24.67 mh at 72 watts ------ a mini card runs hot also a replacement rma
his 5500xt 25.19 mh at 56 watts ------ good mini card
his. 5500 xt 25.29 mh at 57 watts------ good mini card
of the 24 above the 5600xt clearly do best
those are the smos software numbers for watts and mh
Did you tested it with wattmeter? I got from my 5600xt at 37-38 mh with 85 watts when i set the most energy efficient prefencies. It was values from wattmeter.
Right now in RaveOS:
5600:
Gigabyte: 43.5/80
MSI: 44/85
ASUS: 43/85
5500:
Sapphire: 28/65
MSI: 27.5/65
ASUS: 27/60
my better 5500xt do 27 mh at 53-55 watts.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
Damn I wish I can get six of those, this is the real definition of power efficiency, two rx5500 will draw 106 to 110 watt @54 MH, damn that's cool and I heard those cards works so cool at good temp my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
I pushed getting cards from april 2020 and got all my amd cards in 2020.
so they were cheap.
It is very tempting to sell them all in one shot.
I sold one 5500xt for 400 and have held all the others.
my better 5500xt do 27 mh at 53-55 watts.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
Damn I wish I can get six of those, this is the real definition of power efficiency, two rx5500 will draw 106 to 110 watt @54 MH, damn that's cool and I heard those cards works so cool at good temp my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
i saw many 5500xt that can do around 29mh at 50 watts.
Maybe someone have one for me for tests?
It looks like that this is data from HiveOS or RaveOS, it isn`t correct. You need to use a wattmeter to get true values with AMD GPUs.Maybe someone have one for me for tests?
my better 5500xt do 27 mh at 53-55 watts.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
My 5500xt are about 28mh at 75-80watts, only RaveOS configured. My 5600xt are flashed and about 43mh at 100-110watts. Before flashing 5600xt gave me about 39-40mh with the same power consumption.my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
Yeah here goes. all smos
Msi 5600xt 37.93 mh at 79 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.92 mh at 78 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.93 mh at 78 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.77 mh at 77 watts
Msi 5600xt 37.95 mh at 76 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.17 mh at 91 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.17 mh at 86 watts
Msi 5600xt 38.39 mh at 79 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.66 mh at 106 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.60 mh at 103 watts
powercolor 5700xt 49.58 mh at 106 watts
powerColor 5700xt 50.88 mh at 113 watts------ an rma replacement card
Xfx 5700xt 50.36 mh at 100 watts
amd 5700xl 49.48 mh at 103 watts
amd 5700 xl 49.54 mh at 104 watts
msi 5700xl 49.45 mh at 109 watts ------- this card has issues
msi 5700xt 50.28 mh at 115 watts ------- this card also has issues
msi 5700xt 40.49 mh at 95 watts -------- this card really is weird
asus 5500xt 26.02 mh at 61 watts
msi. 5500xt 26.02 mh at 56 watts
msi 5500xt 25.44 mh at 56 watts
asrock 5500xt 24.67 mh at 72 watts ------ a mini card runs hot also a replacement rma
his 5500xt 25.19 mh at 56 watts ------ good mini card
his. 5500 xt 25.29 mh at 57 watts------ good mini card
of the 24 above the 5600xt clearly do best
those are the smos software numbers for watts and mh
i saw many 5500xt that can do around 29mh at 50 watts.
Maybe someone have one for me for tests?
It looks like that this is data from HiveOS or RaveOS, it isn`t correct. You need to use a wattmeter to get true values with AMD GPUs.Maybe someone have one for me for tests?
my better 5500xt do 27 mh at 53-55 watts.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
My 5500xt are about 28mh at 75-80watts, only RaveOS configured. My 5600xt are flashed and about 43mh at 100-110watts. Before flashing 5600xt gave me about 39-40mh with the same power consumption.my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
my better 5500xt do 27 mh at 53-55 watts.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
i saw many 5500xt that can do around 29mh at 50 watts.
Maybe someone have one for me for tests?
The most power efficiency out of all your cards should be rx5500, correct me if you think I'm wrong, if 5600 can do 39mh at 76watts I'm wondering what the power consumption of rx5500 will be, can you please share that detail with us @philipma1957
I get such a hash rate and 80 watts of electricity consumption. Such results are obtained with video cards with Samsung memory. For example, the SAPPHIRE PULSE RX 5600 XT 6G GDDR6 video card. With Gigabytes or Asus on another memory, I did not manage to get such results, but these video cards have a higher hashrate out of the box.yeah.
I have like 10-15 5600 cards only one does those really good numbers.
I will review all cards today as I am going to the mine for the whole day.
I will post watts to hash.
The most power efficiency out of all your cards should be rx5500, correct me if you think I'm wrong, if 5600 can do 39mh at 76watts I'm wondering what the power consumption of rx5500 will be, can you please share that detail with us @philipma1957
I get such a hash rate and 80 watts of electricity consumption. Such results are obtained with video cards with Samsung memory. For example, the SAPPHIRE PULSE RX 5600 XT 6G GDDR6 video card. With Gigabytes or Asus on another memory, I did not manage to get such results, but these video cards have a higher hashrate out of the box.
my better 5500xt do 27 mh at 53-55 watts.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
my lessor ones do 25 mh at 51 watts
I only do memory straps
I never flash bios.
i would argue the 5700 needs to be compared to the 6800
and the 5600 needs to be compared to the 6700
or maybe
6900 to 5700
6800 to 5600
6700 to 5500
but do not compare the 5700 to the 6700
I own
5500
5600
5700
6700
6800
have not sourced a 6900
so far i like
5600 a lot.
i can get some to do 39mh at 76 watts
pretty good numbers.
although nothing compares to well to bitmain’s E9. 3200mh at 2800 watts.
i would argue the 5700 needs to be compared to the 6800
and the 5600 needs to be compared to the 6700
or maybe
6900 to 5700
6800 to 5600
6700 to 5500
but do not compare the 5700 to the 6700
I own
5500
5600
5700
6700
6800
have not sourced a 6900
so far i like
5600 a lot.
i can get some to do 39mh at 76 watts
pretty good numbers.
although nothing compares to well to bitmain’s E9. 3200mh at 2800 watts.
I managed to pick up 16 RX5700 XT's back in November/December before prices went all crazy. I managed to pick up all of them for between $300 and $400. Definitely took some tweaking to get them close to 57MH/s and low power (BIOS mod/memory strap). They are not quite as efficient as my 3000 series, but way better than my 1000 series that have all been sold at this point.
The AMD 6000 series I don't think will ever be really good for ETH given the Infinity Cache memory design...
The AMD 6000 series I don't think will ever be really good for ETH given the Infinity Cache memory design...
I have 10 regular 5700's that I pulled from Dell systems. After selling off the systems, have about $700/each in them, which I can live with. They are just generic reference cards. I can only seem to get 54MH out of them stable but only using 100 watts, so pretty pleased with them myself. I didn't do a BIOS mod though, just the memory straps.
I managed to pick up 16 RX5700 XT's back in November/December before prices went all crazy. I managed to pick up all of them for between $300 and $400. Definitely took some tweaking to get them close to 57MH/s and low power (BIOS mod/memory strap). They are not quite as efficient as my 3000 series, but way better than my 1000 series that have all been sold at this point.
The AMD 6000 series I don't think will ever be really good for ETH given the Infinity Cache memory design...
Same here, RX5700XT is just better but the NVIDIA RTX all did great job when it comes to power efficiency, they draw less watt if you can tweak them but yea as we know AMD is always more power hungry, I expected RX6700 to get 65MH before launch but after seeing the result I gave up The AMD 6000 series I don't think will ever be really good for ETH given the Infinity Cache memory design...
I managed to pick up 16 RX5700 XT's back in November/December before prices went all crazy. I managed to pick up all of them for between $300 and $400. Definitely took some tweaking to get them close to 57MH/s and low power (BIOS mod/memory strap). They are not quite as efficient as my 3000 series, but way better than my 1000 series that have all been sold at this point.
The AMD 6000 series I don't think will ever be really good for ETH given the Infinity Cache memory design...
The AMD 6000 series I don't think will ever be really good for ETH given the Infinity Cache memory design...
The RX5700 did not mine well in the beginning. I remember that after its appearance, the hash rate was less than 5 megahash 
After a while, good drivers and BIOS firmware appeared.
For the RX6700, the same situation may happen again. Traditionally AMD mining products rarely work well out of the box.
After a while, good drivers and BIOS firmware appeared.
For the RX6700, the same situation may happen again. Traditionally AMD mining products rarely work well out of the box.
Sad but true, RX5700XT just performs better, newer doesn't mean better performance for all algorithm, I'm sure RX6700 have it's best side of performance for some algorithms as well
Thanks for post.
@ TheMimic1
Learn more about mining and understand what specifi algos need and how to tune your cards. The RX6700 can give you over 60mh
Zotak337 is right, newer cards doesn´t always perform better!
Sad but true, RX5700XT just performs better, newer doesn't mean better performance for all algorithm, I'm sure RX6700 have it's best side of performance for some algorithms as well
Thanks for post.
@ TheMimic1
Learn more about mining and understand what specifi algos need and how to tune your cards. The RX6700 can give you over 60mh
Zotak337 is right, newer cards doesn´t always perform better!
Jump to: