It's important to avoid the penny wise pounds foolish situations, so it's ok to spend a small amount to protect a bigger amount of money, by spending a lower amount on Ethereum, gass fees, the OP has averted any likely hack on his main wallet, a very smart move. I hope that newbies will take note of this advice Incase they're faced with a similar situation where they need to connect to a website to swap their tokens, because ignorance is not an excuse when their wallet is compromised and all their token are stolen. There are so many scams and hacks in the crypto space, so everybody in it must aquint themselves with the correct knowledge to protect themselves, don't trust and always follow due process to avoid being a victim.