Hey guys. So as I'm writing up the specs for the burn (before a final vote on it), I want ask a question about and get feedback.
There are 2 ways we can do this: One is a parallel burn. And the other is a once-off burn.
Once-off burn:So, the idea is the set a block (say 160000), where after any new Cypherfunks that is mined won't be able to be turned into the new token. So that means, any new rewards from the blocks (from 160001) won't be able to be used to burn. However, this is really difficult to determine. Old FUNK (mined before block 160k) can be merged with new FUNK (post block 160k+), meaning *some* of it can be burned, but others can not. And then it becomes impossible to trace which is new FUNK (post 160k) or old FUNK (pre 160k). So, the only way I see this, is to set a "stop" block. Which means ANY (not just mining rewards) FUNK after 160k can't be burned. So, you would have needed to have ALL the FUNK you want to burn before the burning period starts. This is checked simply on the inputs (are the inputs before block 160k?).
However, this means there is a period where everyone needs to accumulate as much FUNK as they want (from exchanges and so forth) before the "burn block". In other words, it's an extra accumulation land-grab before the burn.
Parallel burn:The other option is to set the burn block 2 months into the future (say block 200k). Then, a "soft"-burn block is set upon which the burning period starts (it is only a date really). Then ALL FUNK between now and block 200k can be burned. This means you can still mine new blocks and burn them. And you can get FUNK off from exchanges as well to burn them. All this happens over a 2 month period. The old chain is still "running", but the new one is being burned into slowly. It's a parallel run. Then on block 200k, the burn period ends.
What I like about parallel burn is that 1) it has incentive to keep the chain running while we are burning and 2) it is more gradual, allowing people time to buy FUNK and burn them off from exchanges (if they want to).
A gradual burn with a longer "accumulation" period means that the price of FUNK might not spike too much if you want to buy it from exchanges. Additionally, if people missed the accumulation period, they can burn whenever in the 2 months period.
---
What do you think? I'm for a parallel burn. And what time is best? 2 months? 4 months? Up to 1-year anniversary of FUNK?