From a dollar to a thousand dollars is not a 1000% rise, it is a 1000x rise (more like a 100,000% rise)
The problem with that analogy is that you are ignoring the base effect. In percentage terms, it is very easy to increase by a large percentage when the initial value is small. There will be hundreds of alt coins which would have increased by the same percentage. But as the market capitalization grows, repeating the increase becomes very difficult.
This. Well put. Having a company grow from a $1000 worth to $1,000,000 can happen, but from $1,000,000 to $1,000,000,000 is a whole other story. That's the size of some industries themselves so if you don't have a monopoly (which bitcoin doesn't) you'll have a hard time repeating that 100,000% rise.