I really like it the merit system. It could be fair to everybody to make a good and very quality post even I personally doubt that everybody can do it. Merit can improve everyone's constructive post. But I really don't like people who always in bias system. I believe the new merit solution is the new merit problem too.
Say you like this new system with merit? I would like to see for how many years you will collect 100 necessary merits to the full member and for how many decades to a senior member, even if you write quality messages. The very idea of merit is not bad. However, it is implemented in such a way as to exclude new participants from participation in the ICO and prevent them from moving along the existing system of ranks. Over time, this will be quite clearly manifested. 
Topic: Thoughts on the new merit system? - page 7. (Read 984 times)
I think this system needs some improvements, having merit is now a little diffcult, it's not very good for the newbies
As long as they post quality replies, they shouldn't worried about it though, no?
Just focus on making decent posts - quality over quantity.
It's interesting, but the bitcointalk accounts will be sold in connection with the innovations?))) I hope the innovations will be useful if the leaders of the forum will approach the issue of spam correctly.
I do not think that the new system of merits will help significantly remove substandard messages from this forum. But this innovation has virtually destroyed the established rules of transition from rank to rank, because it will already be impossible to do for years. The senior members, the heroes and the legendary became sharply recruited in terms of distribution of merit. Go from rank to rank below the senior member is almost impossible and in the future everyone will be able to make sure of this. I am also surprised that the participant has the opportunity to send just one unit of merit, a full member from four to six depending on the activity, and the senior member and above have the ability to already send tens and hundreds of merit units. This distribution of opportunities is clearly discriminatory. It is aimed at preventing new members from participating in the ICO and positively affecting only the ranks, beginning with the senior member and higher. I take this innovation dramatically negatively.
The merit system looks good, but needs some small imrovement.
I would like to have some Smerits to send for quality posting
I would like to have some Smerits to send for quality posting
Not sure what to make just yet but I will make a few observations. It is good in the way it went about it but I think in execution it was kind of poor. I would amend the fact that you only get half an sMerit when given a Merit because then there would be more merits in the system meaning more people being generous. Another thing is that I kind of forget I have a few so I haven't used it yet, and lastly it seems like the power is all in the legendary hands and when you centralize power we all know what happens next and its not a good outcome..
I think this system needs some improvements, having merit is now a little diffcult, it's not very good for the newbies
Well the new merit system for me is absolutely fine. Though this could be more challenging for the members to rank up, this will surely help the whole bitcointalk community even more as the members also post more quality posts and not just spam posts all around. Exchanging of thoughts and idea will become more beneficial for everybody.
I am still working out what the merit system is for and how it works.....
Although this system is annoying, it was extremely effective and beautiful for the rank-and-file event. It is no longer easy for everyone to rank, and there will be no rubbish memberships at certain ranks. Those who trade accounts with illegal means are in a state of being evaluated.
I really like it the merit system. It could be fair to everybody to make a good and very quality post even I personally doubt that everybody can do it. Merit can improve everyone's constructive post. But I really don't like people who always in bias system. I believe the new merit solution is the new merit problem too.
I'm not too sure about this new merit system. Although these boards have been getting a lot more spam, it will be much more difficult to level up your bitcointalk account. Most people are not even going to bother and give out merit to quality posts.
What are your thoughts, do you like the new merit system?
What are your thoughts, do you like the new merit system?
I think the new idea of assessing posts is uniquely good, but it needs improvement because it has weak points.
For example .. because of the shortage of holders.
There are very few sources now, how can they be earned .. which can cause additional speculation
This in a way simply removes spammers and those who have multiple accounts and therefore will now have more useful information and comments on the topic.
That is true new Merit system not only reduce spamming posts but it getting harder for ranks upgrade because there is specific measures required for that in the new system , lets do the best to make this forum as first learning resources for newbies and answering questions about bitcoin\Altcoins .
This in a way simply removes spammers and those who have multiple accounts and therefore will now have more useful information and comments on the topic.
Always, when something new appears, it follows a storm of reviews, comments. Some have discontent, some have delight! Now it's really hard to get a new title. Maybe in the future this system will show all its advantages, but for now it is necessary to try to bring to the community the benefits of its informative messages. 
The merit point system is just introduced. Most persons have not fully grab the working. It is intended to solve a problem. Over time all workings will be understood and the forum will be better for it.
Go check this thread by theymos. https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/merit-new-rank-requirements-2818350
Also, maybe you might want to move this thread to Meta.
Also, maybe you might want to move this thread to Meta.
This is an Altcoin Discussion board so topics here shouldn't be about the forum.
Can we just stop creating new threads about merits?
Main discussion about merit here Merit & new rank requirements.
Can we just stop creating new threads about merits?
Main discussion about merit here Merit & new rank requirements.
I was surprise when I saw this. I was like, this thing in not there before, I remember it was only two, the number of post and the activity 
. Then come this merit system. I'm sure it will be helpful in order for people to be constructive in their post and not just putting anything under the son. Let see, for sure this will be part of the qualification in the future.
. Then come this merit system. I'm sure it will be helpful in order for people to be constructive in their post and not just putting anything under the son. Let see, for sure this will be part of the qualification in the future. I'm not too sure about this new merit system. Although these boards have been getting a lot more spam, it will be much more difficult to level up your bitcointalk account. Most people are not even going to bother and give out merit to quality posts.
What are your thoughts, do you like the new merit system?
What are your thoughts, do you like the new merit system?
What's the problem for you, guys, to use search instead of creating the same threads on every board? That was discussed already about a thousands of times.
Jump to: