And first draft is done: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/btc-mining-pools-list-104664
I pm'd John to get it stickied.
Any comments or changes?
Topic: Top 10 Pools stickied? (Read 3305 times)
Yeah, Organofcorti gets my vote as well!
An explanation of the payment methods (DGM / PPS / PPLNS / Proportional) would be useful for new miners as well. Not a huge paper like Meni's, but just a brief description of how it works and if its subject to variance or hoppable.
Well there's https://bitcoil.co.il/pool_summary.pdf.I was going to ask you about that ...
An explanation of the payment methods (DGM / PPS / PPLNS / Proportional) would be useful for new miners as well. Not a huge paper like Meni's, but just a brief description of how it works and if its subject to variance or hoppable.
Well there's https://bitcoil.co.il/pool_summary.pdf. I'm not sure who removed the stickies. It's better if someone would PM the local moderators(DiabloD3, gmaxwell, MiningBuddy), and ask why. I could sticky a post containing the Top Ten Pools though.
If he's willing to do it, I'd love to see a pool sticky thread managed by organofcorti, since he is already preparing charts for the top pools on a weekly basis. The first post could be a basic listing of pools with only the minor details (Fee + Payment Method(s)), sorted by speed, or alphabetically with clickable links to their threads, and the second post updated for the current week speed charts?
I'd be happy to do this - it's not much extra work, and I like eleuthria's idea of having clickable links. Any other ideas about how best to present the information in the first post, or what information miners and pool ops would like to have presented there?
I think the a basic listing (Payment Method + Fee) is the "best" way to handle it in a neutral manner. Every pool has it's own unique flavor, so keeping the list "clean" and making it easy for them to find the main pool posts (which have far more detail) keeps it simple and unbiased. An explanation of the payment methods (DGM / PPS / PPLNS / Proportional) would be useful for new miners as well. Not a huge paper like Meni's, but just a brief description of how it works and if its subject to variance or hoppable.
Good oh. I'll get started.
I'm not sure who removed the stickies. It's better if someone would PM the local moderators(DiabloD3, gmaxwell, MiningBuddy), and ask why. I could sticky a post containing the Top Ten Pools though.
If he's willing to do it, I'd love to see a pool sticky thread managed by organofcorti, since he is already preparing charts for the top pools on a weekly basis. The first post could be a basic listing of pools with only the minor details (Fee + Payment Method(s)), sorted by speed, or alphabetically with clickable links to their threads, and the second post updated for the current week speed charts?
I'd be happy to do this - it's not much extra work, and I like eleuthria's idea of having clickable links. Any other ideas about how best to present the information in the first post, or what information miners and pool ops would like to have presented there?
I think the a basic listing (Payment Method + Fee) is the "best" way to handle it in a neutral manner. Every pool has it's own unique flavor, so keeping the list "clean" and making it easy for them to find the main pool posts (which have far more detail) keeps it simple and unbiased. An explanation of the payment methods (DGM / PPS / PPLNS / Proportional) would be useful for new miners as well. Not a huge paper like Meni's, but just a brief description of how it works and if its subject to variance or hoppable.
I'm not sure who removed the stickies. It's better if someone would PM the local moderators(DiabloD3, gmaxwell, MiningBuddy), and ask why. I could sticky a post containing the Top Ten Pools though.
If he's willing to do it, I'd love to see a pool sticky thread managed by organofcorti, since he is already preparing charts for the top pools on a weekly basis. The first post could be a basic listing of pools with only the minor details (Fee + Payment Method(s)), sorted by speed, or alphabetically with clickable links to their threads, and the second post updated for the current week speed charts?
I'd be happy to do this - it's not much extra work, and I like eleuthria's idea of having clickable links. Any other ideas about how best to present the information in the first post, or what information miners and pool ops would like to have presented there?
I think the a basic listing (Payment Method + Fee) is the "best" way to handle it in a neutral manner. Every pool has it's own unique flavor, so keeping the list "clean" and making it easy for them to find the main pool posts (which have far more detail) keeps it simple and unbiased. An explanation of the payment methods (DGM / PPS / PPLNS / Proportional) would be useful for new miners as well. Not a huge paper like Meni's, but just a brief description of how it works and if its subject to variance or hoppable.
I'm not sure who removed the stickies. It's better if someone would PM the local moderators(DiabloD3, gmaxwell, MiningBuddy), and ask why. I could sticky a post containing the Top Ten Pools though.
If he's willing to do it, I'd love to see a pool sticky thread managed by organofcorti, since he is already preparing charts for the top pools on a weekly basis. The first post could be a basic listing of pools with only the minor details (Fee + Payment Method(s)), sorted by speed, or alphabetically with clickable links to their threads, and the second post updated for the current week speed charts?
I'd be happy to do this - it's not much extra work, and I like eleuthria's idea of having clickable links. Any other ideas about how best to present the information in the first post, or what information miners and pool ops would like to have presented there?
I'm not sure who removed the stickies. It's better if someone would PM the local moderators(DiabloD3, gmaxwell, MiningBuddy), and ask why. I could sticky a post containing the Top Ten Pools though.
If he's willing to do it, I'd love to see a pool sticky thread managed by organofcorti, since he is already preparing charts for the top pools on a weekly basis. The first post could be a basic listing of pools with only the minor details (Fee + Payment Method(s)), sorted by speed, or alphabetically with clickable links to their threads, and the second post updated for the current week speed charts?
I'm not sure who removed the stickies. It's better if someone would PM the local moderators(DiabloD3, gmaxwell, MiningBuddy), and ask why. I could sticky a post containing the Top Ten Pools though.
If he's willing to do it, I'd love to see a pool sticky thread managed by organofcorti, since he is already preparing charts for the top pools on a weekly basis. The first post could be a basic listing of pools with only the minor details (Fee + Payment Method(s)), sorted by speed, or alphabetically with clickable links to their threads, and the second post updated for the current week speed charts?
I'm not sure who removed the stickies. It's better if someone would PM the local moderators(DiabloD3, gmaxwell, MiningBuddy), and ask why. I could sticky a post containing the Top Ten Pools though.
Graet,
How about putting a forum link on the web page? That way we don't need to search through the pools forum at all.
Just a thought,
Sam
How about putting a forum link on the web page? That way we don't need to search through the pools forum at all.
Just a thought,
Sam
mods haven't responded to this thread so I
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/mining-and-pools-subforums-103904
in the Meta forum
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/mining-and-pools-subforums-103904
in the Meta forum
I would like to see a forum thread with ONLY pools in it. These extraneous topic's are very distracting and should be separate from pools since the pool forums are mainly for pool information and support. Then being stickied wouldn't be necessary.
Sam
Sam
You'd prefer one board for pools and one board for pool related subjects?
Yep, or a Pool only board with a child board for general pool discussion/subjects.
Sam
Great for smaller pools, but generally it means the pools at the top are the ones that are having technical issues. Stable pools really don't get many posts, so can end up off the first page entirely.
This is also my thoughtSo we need to do a daily "everything is running fine , no known issues" post to bump the thread
A top 10 sticky or a child board with all pools stickied are both great options. I liked the original stickies because pools really don't advertise, so new members coming in basically just see the top few posts here. Great for smaller pools, but generally it means the pools at the top are the ones that are having technical issues. Stable pools really don't get many posts, so can end up off the first page entirely.
I would like to see a forum thread with ONLY pools in it. These extraneous topic's are very distracting and should be separate from pools since the pool forums are mainly for pool information and support. Then being stickied wouldn't be necessary.
Sam
Sam
You'd prefer one board for pools and one board for pool related subjects?
Yep, or a Pool only board with a child board for general pool discussion/subjects.
Sam
I would like to see a forum thread with ONLY pools in it. These extraneous topic's are very distracting and should be separate from pools since the pool forums are mainly for pool information and support. Then being stickied wouldn't be necessary.
Sam
Sam
You'd prefer one board for pools and one board for pool related subjects?
Yep, or a Pool only board with a child board for general pool discussion/subjects.
Sam
Along with organofcorti I update the Top Ten Pools on http://www.btcmu.info every week. Organofcorti has the most in depth look at Pool performance each week.
If the Top 10 pools aren't going to be stickied, then we need a Top 10 pools post stickied.
If an admin would sticky it, I'd vote for a post with your weekly statistics. But without all the discussion and new post every week - just one post edited for each update. Could still have graphs. Short and informational.
I'm only posting the table in the weekly pool stats here now - the full posts are at http://organofcorti.blogspot.com. I can put much higher res graphs there, and wknight has them on http://www.btcmu.info as well.
A locked sticky with an introduction and the hashrate table might be useful, and might also encourage some pools to publish better stats too.
Along with organofcorti I update the Top Ten Pools on http://www.btcmu.info every week. Organofcorti has the most in depth look at Pool performance each week.
Jump to: