Saw the entries and you can say that there are really artists in this forum alone. Maybe most of them are undervalued artists in real life. At least their works have been noticed here. Congratulations to all the winners!
Topic: Top-100 merited-artists in the 10th anniversary art contest (Read 1277 times)
Just want to say that this activity is truly amazing. This is one of the reasons why the forum keeps on soaring. Theymos and the admin are always on top of the game. Always giving reason why we need to stay in this forum.
Saw the entries and you can say that there are really artists in this forum alone. Maybe most of them are undervalued artists in real life. At least their works have been noticed here. Congratulations to all the winners!
Saw the entries and you can say that there are really artists in this forum alone. Maybe most of them are undervalued artists in real life. At least their works have been noticed here. Congratulations to all the winners!
legendary
Activity: 1680
Merit: 6524
Fully-fledged Merit Cycler|Spambuster'23|Pie Baker
That' amazing! And thank you for your reply!
In the 20417 merit are included theymos' 9991? Or the 20417 are only from the forum users (thus, with theymos' 9991, the grand total would be 30408)?
In the 20417 merit are included theymos' 9991? Or the 20417 are only from the forum users (thus, with theymos' 9991, the grand total would be 30408)?
In the end, how many participants were registered in the contest?
I excludes participants who did not get a single merit, so I don't have it for you.For participants who received at least 1 merit, there are 673 artists.
Quote
And how many submissions?
673 artists made 1093 submissions in total.Code:
. tab nsubmissions
(count) |
postnum | Freq. Percent Cum.
------------+-----------------------------------
1 | 456 67.76 67.76
2 | 130 19.32 87.07
3 | 37 5.50 92.57
4 | 27 4.01 96.58
5 | 8 1.19 97.77
6 | 5 0.74 98.51
7 | 4 0.59 99.11
8 | 2 0.30 99.41
10 | 1 0.15 99.55
11 | 2 0.30 99.85
12 | 1 0.15 100.00
------------+-----------------------------------
Total | 673 100.00
. tab totalsubmissions
totalsubmis |
sions | Freq. Percent Cum.
------------+-----------------------------------
1093 | 673 100.00 100.00
------------+-----------------------------------
Total | 673 100.00
(count) |
postnum | Freq. Percent Cum.
------------+-----------------------------------
1 | 456 67.76 67.76
2 | 130 19.32 87.07
3 | 37 5.50 92.57
4 | 27 4.01 96.58
5 | 8 1.19 97.77
6 | 5 0.74 98.51
7 | 4 0.59 99.11
8 | 2 0.30 99.41
10 | 1 0.15 99.55
11 | 2 0.30 99.85
12 | 1 0.15 100.00
------------+-----------------------------------
Total | 673 100.00
. tab totalsubmissions
totalsubmis |
sions | Freq. Percent Cum.
------------+-----------------------------------
1093 | 673 100.00 100.00
------------+-----------------------------------
Total | 673 100.00
Quote
Besides, did anyone count how many merits have been given by forum users to all submissions? I know theymos have 9991, but besides these 9991 merits, how many were awarded by all the other forum members?
20417 for those 673 artists.Code:
. tab totalmerits
totalmerits | Freq. Percent Cum.
------------+-----------------------------------
20417 | 673 100.00 100.00
------------+-----------------------------------
Total | 673 100.00
totalmerits | Freq. Percent Cum.
------------+-----------------------------------
20417 | 673 100.00 100.00
------------+-----------------------------------
Total | 673 100.00
Note:
All figures above took at 2019-11-23_Sat_06.07h (Amsterdam time)
Stats include theymos' sent merits but there are discrepancies between total sent merits in my dataset and the figure given by theymos (due to time lags between two dataset (mine - that I took from LoyceV scrapped data) and theymos').
legendary
Activity: 1680
Merit: 6524
Fully-fledged Merit Cycler|Spambuster'23|Pie Baker
In the end, how many participants were registered in the contest? And how many submissions?
Besides, did anyone count how many merits have been given by forum users to all submissions? I know theymos have 9991, but besides these 9991 merits, how many were awarded by all the other forum members?
Besides, did anyone count how many merits have been given by forum users to all submissions? I know theymos have 9991, but besides these 9991 merits, how many were awarded by all the other forum members?
Finally, theymos made his next step to choose winners. Here is his thread on the top 53 chose-artists to vote for 5 art-contest winners badges.
The odds is 5/53 (not 52 - theymos likely made a typo). Sorry, I am incorrect. You can choose 52 options to vote in maximum.
Now, let's compare the odds of match between my list (according to Criteria 4 - rankid4) and theymos' list (for the top 53 - of course):
50/53 cases match. It seems my criteria 4 almost matches with theymos' criteria. That is great!
Details:
Match cases:
Unmatched cases:
3 cases in my list excluded in the theymos' list
Payments sent, guys. Congratulations for winners!
Now, let's compare the odds of match between my list (according to Criteria 4 - rankid4) and theymos' list (for the top 53 - of course):
50/53 cases match. It seems my criteria 4 almost matches with theymos' criteria. That is great!
Code:
. tab _merge
_merge | Freq. Percent Cum.
------------------------+-----------------------------------
master only (1) | 3 5.36 5.36
using only (2) | 3 5.36 10.71
matched (3) | 50 89.29 100.00
------------------------+-----------------------------------
Total | 56 100.00
_merge | Freq. Percent Cum.
------------------------+-----------------------------------
master only (1) | 3 5.36 5.36
using only (2) | 3 5.36 10.71
matched (3) | 50 89.29 100.00
------------------------+-----------------------------------
Total | 56 100.00
Details:
Match cases:
Code:
. list theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge if _merge == 3, abb(30)
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
1. | 6 6 1Dq intricate cityscape 236 2 48 matched (3) |
2. | 23 31 ADAMA_NOW educational video 122 1 14 matched (3) |
3. | 45 44 Altcoinlog paintings 107 2 22 matched (3) |
4. | 11 20 Basorexia pokemon cards 158 5 53 matched (3) |
5. | 1 3 Corrosive corrosion art 278 2 55 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
6. | 32 30 Darker45 bubbles & sketches 123 4 37 matched (3) |
7. | 43 39 Debonaire217 arduino house 113 3 29 matched (3) |
8. | 44 40 DireWolfM14 coin design 110 3 26 matched (3) |
9. | 16 17 Foxpup NSFW fox 166 6 41 matched (3) |
10. | 35 48 GreatArkansas printout collage 105 1 24 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
11. | 4 4 Kalemder interactive gallery & videos 257 10 87 matched (3) |
12. | 26 25 Karmakid satoshi with leaf hand 140 2 21 matched (3) |
13. | 48 42 Laskoo last supper caption 108 2 28 matched (3) |
14. | 14 12 LoyceV avatar collage & daughter's art 180 4 65 matched (3) |
15. | 17 15 Mamaecrypto watercolor at conference 167 4 42 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
16. | 37 35 Maus0728 Dorian portrait 118 4 39 matched (3) |
17. | 36 33 Netto lighter 120 1 23 matched (3) |
18. | 29 26 Oasisman bull sketch 132 2 33 matched (3) |
19. | 20 18 Rikafip pizza 160 3 53 matched (3) |
20. | 22 22 Twentyonepaylots god satoshi 152 4 26 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
21. | 53 46 Yabes sand drawing 106 1 33 matched (3) |
22. | 3 2 Yatsan oil paintings 290 4 83 matched (3) |
23. | 10 11 ZipReg dash game 180 2 43 matched (3) |
24. | 46 45 axicron night cityscape 107 2 18 matched (3) |
25. | 47 43 creep_o bowling 108 2 26 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
26. | 40 36 crossabdd string art 116 1 29 matched (3) |
27. | 28 27 cryptoaddictchie intricate sketch 131 4 35 matched (3) |
28. | 2 1 dannybrown bitcointalk flash game 354 1 45 matched (3) |
29. | 24 23 ecnalubma bull/bear & various 142 5 34 matched (3) |
30. | 12 13 geophphreigh folded bolivar design 176 1 27 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
31. | 41 38 goaldigger doodles 114 2 29 matched (3) |
32. | 33 29 ibminer trophy & ship 124 2 19 matched (3) |
33. | 7 7 likehiro moon block chain 231 1 48 matched (3) |
34. | 30 28 mosdesign carved trophy 129 2 29 matched (3) |
36. | 31 37 nomteck1 3D bitcointalk room 116 1 16 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
37. | 19 19 noorman0 carvings 160 5 56 matched (3) |
38. | 42 49 otto_diesel cake 104 1 35 matched (3) |
39. | 21 21 rare_designer blockchain eden 154 2 18 matched (3) |
40. | 49 50 rhomelmabini superhero shadow 104 1 19 matched (3) |
41. | 52 47 saiga31 bull & pizza drawings 106 3 31 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
42. | 25 24 sashapan dress 140 2 33 matched (3) |
43. | 18 16 sedactoo+04 BTC logo on canvas 166 3 49 matched (3) |
44. | 38 41 sheenshane cake in hand drawing 108 2 34 matched (3) |
45. | 5 5 sirazimuth commemorative round 254 11 92 matched (3) |
47. | 39 34 start the art abstract art & song 118 2 19 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
48. | 13 10 sujonali1819 dot art 183 12 58 matched (3) |
49. | 15 14 summonerrk watercolors 175 3 42 matched (3) |
50. | 8 8 taufik123 madura carving 221 4 56 matched (3) |
51. | 9 9 terizla [squidward's art] & doodles 208 11 53 matched (3) |
53. | 34 32 webtricks bitcointalk card creator 122 4 36 matched (3) |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
1. | 6 6 1Dq intricate cityscape 236 2 48 matched (3) |
2. | 23 31 ADAMA_NOW educational video 122 1 14 matched (3) |
3. | 45 44 Altcoinlog paintings 107 2 22 matched (3) |
4. | 11 20 Basorexia pokemon cards 158 5 53 matched (3) |
5. | 1 3 Corrosive corrosion art 278 2 55 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
6. | 32 30 Darker45 bubbles & sketches 123 4 37 matched (3) |
7. | 43 39 Debonaire217 arduino house 113 3 29 matched (3) |
8. | 44 40 DireWolfM14 coin design 110 3 26 matched (3) |
9. | 16 17 Foxpup NSFW fox 166 6 41 matched (3) |
10. | 35 48 GreatArkansas printout collage 105 1 24 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
11. | 4 4 Kalemder interactive gallery & videos 257 10 87 matched (3) |
12. | 26 25 Karmakid satoshi with leaf hand 140 2 21 matched (3) |
13. | 48 42 Laskoo last supper caption 108 2 28 matched (3) |
14. | 14 12 LoyceV avatar collage & daughter's art 180 4 65 matched (3) |
15. | 17 15 Mamaecrypto watercolor at conference 167 4 42 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
16. | 37 35 Maus0728 Dorian portrait 118 4 39 matched (3) |
17. | 36 33 Netto lighter 120 1 23 matched (3) |
18. | 29 26 Oasisman bull sketch 132 2 33 matched (3) |
19. | 20 18 Rikafip pizza 160 3 53 matched (3) |
20. | 22 22 Twentyonepaylots god satoshi 152 4 26 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
21. | 53 46 Yabes sand drawing 106 1 33 matched (3) |
22. | 3 2 Yatsan oil paintings 290 4 83 matched (3) |
23. | 10 11 ZipReg dash game 180 2 43 matched (3) |
24. | 46 45 axicron night cityscape 107 2 18 matched (3) |
25. | 47 43 creep_o bowling 108 2 26 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
26. | 40 36 crossabdd string art 116 1 29 matched (3) |
27. | 28 27 cryptoaddictchie intricate sketch 131 4 35 matched (3) |
28. | 2 1 dannybrown bitcointalk flash game 354 1 45 matched (3) |
29. | 24 23 ecnalubma bull/bear & various 142 5 34 matched (3) |
30. | 12 13 geophphreigh folded bolivar design 176 1 27 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
31. | 41 38 goaldigger doodles 114 2 29 matched (3) |
32. | 33 29 ibminer trophy & ship 124 2 19 matched (3) |
33. | 7 7 likehiro moon block chain 231 1 48 matched (3) |
34. | 30 28 mosdesign carved trophy 129 2 29 matched (3) |
36. | 31 37 nomteck1 3D bitcointalk room 116 1 16 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
37. | 19 19 noorman0 carvings 160 5 56 matched (3) |
38. | 42 49 otto_diesel cake 104 1 35 matched (3) |
39. | 21 21 rare_designer blockchain eden 154 2 18 matched (3) |
40. | 49 50 rhomelmabini superhero shadow 104 1 19 matched (3) |
41. | 52 47 saiga31 bull & pizza drawings 106 3 31 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
42. | 25 24 sashapan dress 140 2 33 matched (3) |
43. | 18 16 sedactoo+04 BTC logo on canvas 166 3 49 matched (3) |
44. | 38 41 sheenshane cake in hand drawing 108 2 34 matched (3) |
45. | 5 5 sirazimuth commemorative round 254 11 92 matched (3) |
47. | 39 34 start the art abstract art & song 118 2 19 matched (3) |
|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
48. | 13 10 sujonali1819 dot art 183 12 58 matched (3) |
49. | 15 14 summonerrk watercolors 175 3 42 matched (3) |
50. | 8 8 taufik123 madura carving 221 4 56 matched (3) |
51. | 9 9 terizla [squidward's art] & doodles 208 11 53 matched (3) |
53. | 34 32 webtricks bitcointalk card creator 122 4 36 matched (3) |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Unmatched cases:
3 cases in my list excluded in the theymos' list
Code:
. list theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge if theymosid == ., abb(30)
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge |
|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
35. | . 53 nc50lc 98 1 10 master only (1) |
46. | . 52 sompitonov 100 2 23 master only (1) |
52. | . 51 tobyyola 103 4 23 master only (1) |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
3 cases added in the theymos' list+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge |
|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
35. | . 53 nc50lc 98 1 10 master only (1) |
46. | . 52 sompitonov 100 2 23 master only (1) |
52. | . 51 tobyyola 103 4 23 master only (1) |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Code:
. list theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge if rankid4 == ., abb(30)
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
54. | 51 . Cryptocables rocket ticker . . . using only (2) |
55. | 27 . Michail1 nixie tubes . . . using only (2) |
56. | 50 . cabalism13 bitcointalk city model . . . using only (2) |
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| theymosid rankid4 username details summerits nsubmissions nsenders _merge |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
54. | 51 . Cryptocables rocket ticker . . . using only (2) |
55. | 27 . Michail1 nixie tubes . . . using only (2) |
56. | 50 . cabalism13 bitcointalk city model . . . using only (2) |
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Payments sent, guys. Congratulations for winners!
I would say that not all or the top 100 merited submissions will receive a reward.
He is looking at 300 submissions and picking from them.
This of course is my opinion
He is looking at 300 submissions and picking from them.
This of course is my opinion
I think an interesting analysis would be one which shows actually a list of top merited users by theymos. Or, a complete list of people (but also submissions - that means two statistics) merited only by theymos. Without taking into count the rest of the merits received by each participant.
In the end, it's only his decision, I don't think he'll be influenced by how many merits received a particular user from all the other forum members.
I think he will have his own schedule. The fact that theymos did not announce the result now is a very good sign for worthy participants of the competition, which means that he studies all the work more carefully In the end, it's only his decision, I don't think he'll be influenced by how many merits received a particular user from all the other forum members.
legendary
Activity: 1680
Merit: 6524
Fully-fledged Merit Cycler|Spambuster'23|Pie Baker
I think an interesting analysis would be one which shows actually a list of top merited users by theymos. Or, a complete list of people (but also submissions - that means two statistics) merited only by theymos. Without taking into count the rest of the merits received by each participant.
In the end, it's only his decision, I don't think he'll be influenced by how many merits received a particular user from all the other forum members.
In the end, it's only his decision, I don't think he'll be influenced by how many merits received a particular user from all the other forum members.
Update with plots:
You can see in the first plot, a box plot, there is a red circle that represents an outlier. Who is presented by that red circle? Dannybrown.
There is only one outlier and in my opinion, I am sure dannybrown will be one of winners.
As far as I understand, there will be a 100 winners who will received BTC at any amount and considering the merit that Dannybrown received, he might be one of those winners.You can see in the first plot, a box plot, there is a red circle that represents an outlier. Who is presented by that red circle? Dannybrown.
There is only one outlier and in my opinion, I am sure dannybrown will be one of winners.
When it comes to the badge, the Top 50 merited arts will be listed out and the poll will decide on who will be the winner on this. Things are getting more exciting because of this analysis.
do we have an estimated date for announcement of next steps and winners?
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
This is only the last message posted by Theymos - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.53152306
According to that, he needs days to determine the winners, so probably IMO, let's assume the results will be within a week after the competition has concluded.
yes, was thinking exactly that.
probably one week or a bit more, depending on how busy he is lately
do we have an estimated date for announcement of next steps and winners?
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
I can imagine that it might take Theymos a while to sort through all the submissions.
Update with plots:
You can see in the first plot, a box plot, there is a red circle that represents an outlier. Who is presented by that red circle? Dannybrown.
There is only one outlier and in my opinion, I am sure dannybrown will be one of winners.
As far as I understand, there will be a 100 winners who will received BTC at any amount and considering the merit that Dannybrown received, he might be one of those winners.You can see in the first plot, a box plot, there is a red circle that represents an outlier. Who is presented by that red circle? Dannybrown.
There is only one outlier and in my opinion, I am sure dannybrown will be one of winners.
When it comes to the badge, the Top 50 merited arts will be listed out and the poll will decide on who will be the winner on this. Things are getting more exciting because of this analysis.
Update with plots:
You can see in the first plot, a box plot, there is a red circle that represents an outlier. Who is presented by that red circle? Dannybrown.
There is only one outlier and in my opinion, I am sure dannybrown will be one of winners.
You can see in the first plot, a box plot, there is a red circle that represents an outlier. Who is presented by that red circle? Dannybrown.
There is only one outlier and in my opinion, I am sure dannybrown will be one of winners.
do we have an estimated date for announcement of next steps and winners?
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
This is only the last message posted by Theymos - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.53152306
According to that, he needs days to determine the winners, so probably IMO, let's assume the results will be within a week after the competition has concluded.
do we have an estimated date for announcement of next steps and winners?
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
This is only the last message posted by Theymos - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.53152306
According to that, he needs days to determine the winners, so probably IMO, let's assume the results will be within a week after the competition has concluded.
do we have an estimated date for announcement of next steps and winners?
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
probably this week, right?
any comments on that are highly appreciated.
~
2. Members who received the most merit by Theymos: Theymos usually gave more merits on the first art, so if someone submits better art after the 1st one but theymos did not give more merits on the second time [ theymos said this here ]. But it is true that what is subsequently submitted is a really good quality art. And I think it may be already marked by theymos. So only it can't be the winner which art received the 50 merits from theymos , even one less merited art also can be a winner.
2. Members who received the most merit by Theymos: Theymos usually gave more merits on the first art, so if someone submits better art after the 1st one but theymos did not give more merits on the second time [ theymos said this here ]. But it is true that what is subsequently submitted is a really good quality art. And I think it may be already marked by theymos. So only it can't be the winner which art received the 50 merits from theymos , even one less merited art also can be a winner.
Interesting information, thanks.
My second art received 39 times more than the first: 1 vs. 39
I wonder how many art works Theymos put to the vote, as I understand it, he did not decide on this issue to the end.
legendary
Activity: 2436
Merit: 1189
Need Campaign Manager?PM on telegram @sujonali1819
Many valuable calculations are presented here by some valuable members of this forum. But I don't know how much it will granted by theymos. Because he says it will only depend on his own or something like that. here.
Anyway, I want to mention some points here.
1. Not all of those who received the most merit at the Contest submitted an equal art [ some are submitted only one and some are 1-13]. So the one who received more merit by submitting less art would be the first in my opinion.
2. Members who received the most merit by Theymos: Theymos usually gave more merits on the first art, so if someone submits better art after the 1st one but theymos did not give more merits on the second time [ theymos said this here ]. But it is true that what is subsequently submitted is a really good quality art. And I think it may be already marked by theymos. So only it can't be the winner which art received the 50 merits from theymos , even one less merited art also can be a winner.
Anyway, I want to mention some points here.
1. Not all of those who received the most merit at the Contest submitted an equal art [ some are submitted only one and some are 1-13]. So the one who received more merit by submitting less art would be the first in my opinion.
2. Members who received the most merit by Theymos: Theymos usually gave more merits on the first art, so if someone submits better art after the 1st one but theymos did not give more merits on the second time [ theymos said this here ]. But it is true that what is subsequently submitted is a really good quality art. And I think it may be already marked by theymos. So only it can't be the winner which art received the 50 merits from theymos , even one less merited art also can be a winner.
wow this is really good statistic
but i think i got more than 100 merit from contest art not 97
The data used in the thread is at 2019-11-23_Sat_06.07h (Amsterdam time), so your total earned merits presents in my thread is not your current ones. A little bit inconsistency.but i think i got more than 100 merit from contest art not 97
So, gathering the top 50 posts according to theymos' merit, and his only. We could get a better idea of who's in the running for badges before theymos posts in a few days time.
Posts or users?
Here is the post list:
# User Post Merits from theymos
Jump to: