Pages:
Author

Topic: Tx fees going up. What is zero fee mining? What is fair pay? (Read 3653 times)

vip
Activity: 980
Merit: 1001
Yeah, but did you include the other 2000 blocks that have a fee in your calculations? Smiley


sorry, what 2000 blocks?
what calculation?
legendary
Activity: 1260
Merit: 1000
Yeah, but did you include the other 2000 blocks that have a fee in your calculations? Smiley

legendary
Activity: 2730
Merit: 1034
Needs more jiggawatts
so anyway
http://blockchain.info/block-index/311449/0000000000000412cb93f5cceceebdd6bec88d5db691a17a823287c47713d2cf
Dunno what broke, but for occasions like these....
worth mining on a pool paying txn fees out?

Wow, 154.68299211 BTC is pretty decent income for a block.

If it had been on a pool that keeps transaction fees that would be almost a 68% fee. Yes, avoiding such steep fees is probably wise.  Cheesy
vip
Activity: 980
Merit: 1001
so anyway
http://blockchain.info/block-index/311449/0000000000000412cb93f5cceceebdd6bec88d5db691a17a823287c47713d2cf
Dunno what broke, but for occasions like these....
worth mining on a pool paying txn fees out?
legendary
Activity: 2940
Merit: 1090
The more chains get added onto the typical miner's list of chains all merged-mined at once the more resilient this all should become, as more chains reaching high levels of difficulty should result in more confidence in all of them, more money coming in to miners as even if money moves out of one chain it might well merely move to another instead of out of the cryptochain world completely, and the prospect of co-ordinating attacks on all chains at once might look more complex too. Maybe also depending on the niches various types of chain end up addressing the perception of what kinds of people you would be going up against by attacking might change. (For example if some nuclear labs use a blockchain for some weird reason or something suddenly you are looking at hmm do we want all the powers behind such a chain also coming after us not just the weirdo libertarians who use bitcoin?)

-MarkM-

legendary
Activity: 1284
Merit: 1001
Yeah and unless you know of any fixed BTC cost mining hardware or flat rate BTC power companies the attackers cost are also in USD/EUR.  So the net gain has to be measured against the cost to the attacker which is primarily in fiat currencies.
The gain will be in bitcoins, so if the bitcoins are worth more in fiat to the miners they will be worth just as much more in fiat to the attackers. Duplicating a 1000 BTC transaction will be much cheaper compared to the gain if the miners only get 1.5 BTC from a block.

If it cost an attacker $200M to attack the network then the reward has to be more than $200M.
And if the value of the BTC has increased tenfold it's because bitcoins have become more popular. With popularity comes more valuable transactions, more opportunities to take advantage of a double spend attack for those who want to scam, and more incentives for companies and organizations which don't want Bitcoin to succeed.
donator
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1079
Gerald Davis
Miner's costs are in USD (or EUR,etc).  For protection what matters is the real cost to attack the network.
No, what matters is cost vs benefit/profit for the attacker.

Yeah and unless you know of any fixed BTC cost mining hardware or flat rate BTC power companies the attackers cost are also in USD/EUR.  So the net gain has to be measured against the cost to the attacker which is primarily in fiat currencies.   If it cost an attacker $200M to attack the network then the reward has to be more than $200M.


legendary
Activity: 1284
Merit: 1001
Miner's costs are in USD (or EUR,etc).  For protection what matters is the real cost to attack the network. 
No, what matters is cost vs benefit/profit for the attacker.
donator
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1079
Gerald Davis
Miner's costs are in USD (or EUR,etc).  For protection what matters is the real cost to attack the network.  IF miners are compensated 10x as much then more hashing power will be added and the cost to attack the network will increase.
legendary
Activity: 1284
Merit: 1001
https://en.bitcoin.it/w/images/en/e/e3/Total_bitcoins_over_time_graph.png
So by 2029 when each block only rewards ~1.5 BTC, TX fees will make up most of the incentive to continue mining?
Maybe. Or perhaps the exchange rate will be $100/BTC!
The exchange rate isn't very relevant for this. If the miners get paid fewer coins for each block and transactions stay the same or higher in bitcoins then they will have less protection compared to today.
hero member
Activity: 628
Merit: 504
I though more than 5 pools paid out txns to miners
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Comparison_of_mining_pools


Hmm, no abc pool in the list, I wonder what could that mean  Grin
vip
Activity: 980
Merit: 1001
Only the finest pools pay tx fees. It's an exclusive club.  Grin
++  Grin
legendary
Activity: 2730
Merit: 1034
Needs more jiggawatts
Only the finest pools pay tx fees. It's an exclusive club.  Grin
donator
Activity: 2058
Merit: 1007
Poor impulse control.
Bitlc.net pays tx fees as well, although it's not listed on that page as doing so.
vip
Activity: 980
Merit: 1001
I though more than 5 pools paid out txns to miners
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Comparison_of_mining_pools
rjk
sr. member
Activity: 448
Merit: 250
1ngldh
https://en.bitcoin.it/w/images/en/e/e3/Total_bitcoins_over_time_graph.png

So by 2029 when each block only rewards ~1.5 BTC, TX fees will make up most of the incentive to continue mining?
Maybe. Or perhaps the exchange rate will be $100/BTC!
legendary
Activity: 952
Merit: 1000


So by 2029 when each block only rewards ~1.5 BTC, TX fees will make up most of the incentive to continue mining?
legendary
Activity: 2730
Merit: 1034
Needs more jiggawatts
Ozcoin is now paying txn fees to DGM miners Cheesy

Good stuff Smiley
vip
Activity: 980
Merit: 1001
Ozcoin is now paying txn fees to DGM miners Cheesy
sr. member
Activity: 252
Merit: 250
Inactive
Of course not every block has 5 BTC in fees. But the transaction fees are steadily rising: http://blockchain.info/charts/transaction-fees

Something to consider when you think about mining fees.



All the more significant when block reward halves.  This is a good selling point.
Pages:
Jump to: