If James McCarthy (nefario) would provide information and say the FSA are asking for identification or exactly what the problem is because he has said nothing.
But until then to send in your photo ID is stupidity, your photo has nothing to do with linking your account it wasnt part of the signup process.
Topic: Verifing account of GLBSE discussion - page 6. (Read 13424 times)
damnit. i must have just missed the processing period.
i got the login screen but after putting in my email and payout address i got a 404.
now the front page says:
i got the login screen but after putting in my email and payout address i got a 404.
now the front page says:
Quote
Update:we are currently unable to process account closures, and will inform our users when this service resumes.
OK, you've got my attention. I'll gladly take any brainstorming from people on what can be done with my electric bill, my ID and a picture of me with the date, my login & e-mail...
#1) Seriously, what could happen?
#2) And what can I do about it now?
I'm pretty sure the answer to #1 is not too much (fingers crossed).
but I'm even more sure the answer to #2 is nothing...
gah, I guess this had to happen sooner or later. Perhaps I should cancel or put a hold on my credit lines? Any other ideas?
Nefario has enough to open an online bank account in your name. Plus hand your pic over to the grand jury.
I hope all germans here do know, that copying or even scanning the german photo id ("Personalausweis") is illegal by law. (Source: http://www.steadynews.de/allgemein/personalausweis-kopieren-und-verleihen-verboten). I can't believe these scammers are even trying this. There is no involvement of governmental money (like on an exchange). It would be the same to ask for AML, because of trading gold or items in an mmo. Totally ridcoulous.
I'm already compliant, I believe. 
"ColdHardMetal
Aug 18 14:30 (HKT)
Humor aside, and I honestly did have a pretty good laugh when I opened this, why do I have this picture? ... It's just sitting here in the support queue, and I'm not sure what to do with it."
"ColdHardMetal
Aug 18 14:30 (HKT)
Humor aside, and I honestly did have a pretty good laugh when I opened this, why do I have this picture? ... It's just sitting here in the support queue, and I'm not sure what to do with it."
The identities that GLBSE is asking can easily be faked! Anyone can send fake IDs/photos. I don't see the point why they are asking for such info. Assets should be connected to accounts and in return to emails. As an issuer all you would need is a list of accounts including emails and number of shares owned by the account/email. But it seems that there would be problems in handling things in such simple manner.
Unless you are in fact running GLBSE (then I just submitted this to you), please post a picture of me with my username & the date. Also, feel free to post my license here which apparently is very easy to fake.
None of this crap is needed to get our BTC back.
Just cripple the trading function, leave the BTC withdrawal function, and open the old site back up until all the BTC are gone.
Once we get our BTC back then worry about the asset transfers.
It seems to me that the asset issuers just need: email, username, hash of the password, the hashing algorithm used, the number of shares owned.
None of this other stuff is necessary unless the amount of BTC and/or value in the shares is very large.
But then it can be argued that the value of all the shares is pretty much now zero.
Just cripple the trading function, leave the BTC withdrawal function, and open the old site back up until all the BTC are gone.
Once we get our BTC back then worry about the asset transfers.
It seems to me that the asset issuers just need: email, username, hash of the password, the hashing algorithm used, the number of shares owned.
None of this other stuff is necessary unless the amount of BTC and/or value in the shares is very large.
But then it can be argued that the value of all the shares is pretty much now zero.
Quote
Please provide a clear picture of you, holding a piece of paper with your GLBSE username and the date written on it.
This is humiliating, to say the least. I will not sink to this level for a thousand coins.
Well, I was paying someone to act as a witness for the things I own. His attestation wasn't absolutely essential but he tricked me into believing that proper measures are in place, so I trusted him. Now, he decided to withhold the testimony and is forcing me to do something for reasons that are unknown to me and will keep this information hostage until I comply. How is this not humiliating? I don't think it would add much to the humiliation if he asked for a naked picture, would only make it official.
Its not fair what GLBSE is doing! I don't think anyone would trust GLBSE with their info, especially after such sudden closing!
The identities that GLBSE is asking can easily be faked! Anyone can send fake IDs/photos. I don't see the point why they are asking for such info. Assets should be connected to accounts and in return to emails. As an issuer all you would need is a list of accounts including emails and number of shares owned by the account/email. But it seems that there would be problems in handling things in such simple manner.
damnit. i must have just missed the processing period.
i got the login screen but after putting in my email and payout address i got a 404.
now the front page says:
i got the login screen but after putting in my email and payout address i got a 404.
now the front page says:
Quote
Update:we are currently unable to process account closures, and will inform our users when this service resumes.
OK, you've got my attention. I'll gladly take any brainstorming from people on what can be done with my electric bill, my ID and a picture of me with the date, my login & e-mail...
#1) Seriously, what could happen?
#2) And what can I do about it now?
I'm pretty sure the answer to #1 is not too much (fingers crossed).
but I'm even more sure the answer to #2 is nothing...
gah, I guess this had to happen sooner or later. Perhaps I should cancel or put a hold on my credit lines? Any other ideas?
So, GLBSE will just get to keep all of these BTC/assets that go unclaimed - which will probably be a fair amount.
This sounds more like a scam than an AML requirement.
This sounds more like a scam than an AML requirement.
I agree. Oh, you want to give us money?. No rules, just give it all to me
You want to withdraw?. Give me a picture of your asshole with your username
So, GLBSE will just get to keep all of these BTC/assets that go unclaimed - which will probably be a fair amount.
This sounds more like a scam than an AML requirement.
This sounds more like a scam than an AML requirement.
I really fail to see how a picture of me with a piece of paper with my username on it will amount to anything.
I have logged into a certain account with a certain username with a password, google factor2 authentication.... uploaded my passport (photo ID) and god knows whatever else
What good will a mugshot of me do
I have logged into a certain account with a certain username with a password, google factor2 authentication.... uploaded my passport (photo ID) and god knows whatever else
What good will a mugshot of me do
Quote
Please provide a clear picture of you, holding a piece of paper with your GLBSE username and the date written on it.
This is humiliating, to say the least. I will not sink to this level for a thousand coins.
It's not humiliating if you do it correctly. I am going to be fully clothed in my picture.
I don't even HAVE a utility bill to my name + home to begin with, also I'm now really worried that someone could just claim to have owned my account instead. Why the hell can't we at least use our EXISTING login data on a demo site in the mean time just to see our balance etc.?!
Because he doesn't want you to prove your ownership of the account, he wants your info so you could be prosecuted.Its probably not good to own shares of IBB. Just sayin...
I don't even HAVE a utility bill to my name + home to begin with, also I'm now really worried that someone could just claim to have owned my account instead. Why the hell can't we at least use our EXISTING login data on a demo site in the mean time just to see our balance etc.?!
Because he doesn't want you to prove your ownership of the account, he wants your info so you could be prosecuted.
I don't even HAVE a utility bill to my name + home to begin with, also I'm now really worried that someone could just claim to have owned my account instead. Why the hell can't we at least use our EXISTING login data on a demo site in the mean time just to see our balance etc.?!
I still have 7 BTC on GLBSE (luckily I pulled out at least most of the accumulated cash before) and quite some GIPPT shares that are still being wound up, so there's not much of an option for me than to comply to whatever crazy regulations GLBSE's lawyer thinks are necessary... I'm definitely not going to be happy about them though.
I still have 7 BTC on GLBSE (luckily I pulled out at least most of the accumulated cash before) and quite some GIPPT shares that are still being wound up, so there's not much of an option for me than to comply to whatever crazy regulations GLBSE's lawyer thinks are necessary... I'm definitely not going to be happy about them though.
I don't mind providing a bitcoin address and email address to be passed on to the asset holders, but what is the photo ID and utility bill needed for?
I already had to provide these months ago due to account complications, now I hope they wouldn't be passed on to asset holders.
I already had to provide these months ago due to account complications, now I hope they wouldn't be passed on to asset holders.
This situation is so deplorable and absurd that it's hard to tell what happens next. I can imagine these humiliating mugshots being accidentally "leaked".
It's as if some resourceful agency is playing games with the Bitcoin community since the beginning of 2011.
Okay, I am 15y/o, how can I even have my proof of address. I dont pay tax, my parent pays utility bills. Hey seriously, didnt you say you have multinational server back up and blah blah blah?
It's either that some of these maintainers are cooperating with Nefario, or he was blatantly lying in the conference.
What we have experienced thus far is a lack of professionalism handling the situation. Nefario, who used to be the contact person for GLBSE matters, is nowhere to be seen. GLBSE rules and requirements change constantly, moreover some of them are illegal in some countries (asking for identification documents without a clearance to handle it for example). Because of these facts, I wouldn't want to provide GLBSE with any kind of document, as this could possibly cause more damage than some lost assets or bitcoins.
I don't mind providing a bitcoin address and email address to be passed on to the asset holders, but what is the photo ID and utility bill needed for?
I already had to provide these months ago due to account complications, now I hope they wouldn't be passed on to asset holders.
I already had to provide these months ago due to account complications, now I hope they wouldn't be passed on to asset holders.
Jump to: