I've just been catching up on last night's AMA, and one unanswered question towards the end of the thread really stood out for me. From fpvhawk:
"How about we fund our own vertcoin P2P exchange opensource software, you download the software and place your buy/sell order. Each order has has a small fee that continues to fund the development of the exchange."
As we all know, the exchanges are the weak link for all cryptos. They are the BIG reason for recent price declines because MT Gox and other smaller exchanges have very publicly demonstrated that the exchange model is flawed.
It seems to me there are two distinct groups of people that use exchanges:
1. People who are converting from FIAT>>>BTC (or if they're savvy FIAT>>>BTC>>>VTC) to buy and hold.
2. Traders who are looking to profit by successfully trading the volatility between different Crypto pairs. This group also includes miners who may send their coins to an exchange. This group has no real need to deal in FIAT on a day-to-day basis.
In the short term, it's difficult to see a solution to this problem, because the conversion from FIAT>>>Crypto is a weak link. People looking to convert to Crypto from FIAT will always be vulnerable. It's also in the interest of governments to make this conversion seem as risky as possible (by sabotaging/hacking exchanges???), to keep people in FIAT. So the first group of people will be vulnerable for the foreseeable future (or for as long as FIAT continues to exist
), but the good news is that they can mitigate these risks by not leaving money in an exchange wallet, because they have no desire to trade.
The 2nd group of people are truly at the mercy of the exchanges currently, because they must leave their coins in an exchange wallet in order to have orders open on the exchange. It is clear that this is the group of people that would stand to benefit massively from the security of a p2p exchange.
It seems to me that the Vertcoin community has embraced p2p for mining more than any other coin. P2pool is consistently >10% of total network. Surely the next logical step for this coin is to explore the idea of p2p exchange?
BTC currently holds a huge advantage because it's the yardstick by which every other coin is measured, AND, most people still use it as a gateway to trading in/out of other Cryptos. All currency pairs are XXX/BTC, or to a lesser extent XXX/LTC.
Imagine if VTC became the first coin to offer the security of a widely adopted p2p exchange, offering XXX/VTC markets for all the other Cryptos, and in the process capturing a huge chunk of business from the 2nd group of people I describe above?
I know I'd be willing to throw quite a few VTC in the pot to make such a thing happen.