Relying on folk to not be stupid doesn't sound like a great formula for success. Forces in war have continued fighting long after it was obvious to everyone they had lost - and they were staking not merely their money but their lives.
I don't mind your "elitist logic" because I think that is a fair point about the stupidity of warriors, sometimes.
Of course, I am stating a belief about the dynamics of this situation that is somewhat different from the dynamics that cause people to fight to the death in wars... but yeah, there may be some parallels between war and this big block stance? I am not putting all my eggs in any one basket, but I am considering that it is more possible for seg wit to get activated than not.
Sure, frequently in wars there can be some kind of self identity and even commitment to your fellow troops. Sure there could be some similar dynamics going on with miners and pools getting these kinds of feelings about wanting to win in spite of logic, but I do think that the economics are likely going to continue to be more dominant forces that are going to cause folks (miners) to peel off.... and sure I am exercising a kind of faith that economics is likely going to prevail to cause folks to not align with ideological stupidity.
And maybe it is just a kind of question regarding who blinks first.. and my inclination is to think that there is not really enough there, there to be keep arguing over nonsensical big blocks, big blocks, big blocks... when that lost a long time ago,.... . And, it's just dumb to be persisting with ongoing dumbness and tried and true failed logic.. Sure we got folks like Roger Ver and Gavin Andresen spouting off some of the nonsense about big blocks, but even between those two there is not really unity because Gavin seems to recognize the practicality of seg wit. Sure, Roger talks nonsense, seems to have some pride in this battle and has a lot of BTC to throw around, but in the end, he is talking politics and not technicalities when he is spouting off about the supposed better direction of big blocks, big blocks, big blocks.