What if a government just buys up all the bitcoins - page 2.

Kluge

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1015

Quote from: cp1 on July 18, 2013, 12:53:53 AM

Quote from: Kluge on July 18, 2013, 12:49:20 AM

Quote from: cp1 on July 18, 2013, 12:43:10 AM

What if a government just buys up all our cars? We'd have no way to get to work.

yeah, but cars increase government revenues both in all the permits/regulations and the gas tax. It'd be revenue-stupid for governments to force eco-friendly means of transport. OTOH, Bitcoin threatens to decrease tax revenues by making taxes easier to evade (similar to cash transactions, which are heavily discouraged in most countries, either by criminalizing large cash transactions, forbidding large withdrawals, or even making it semi-criminal to have substantial amounts of cash on-hand).

Maybe they'll buy up all our cash then, and force us to use credit cards.

That sounds more plausible... Wouldn't be bought up, but the governments might devise a plan to ensure all cash gets turned digital, and perhaps set a deadline where physical cash is no longer legal tender.

Cash is so restricted, now, it's been made impossible to (legally) use in a lot of transactions...
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/mar/27/cyprus-emergency-restrictions-cash-withdrawals-banks
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-04-11/spain-to-limit-cash-transactions-to-fight-tax-fraud-correct-.html
http://english.people.com.cn/90777/8149850.html
http://rbth.ru/business/2013/03/25/russia_to_ban_cash_transactions_over_10000_24203.html

etc.

cp1

hero member

Activity: 616

Merit: 500

Stop using branwallets

Quote from: Kluge on July 18, 2013, 12:49:20 AM

Quote from: cp1 on July 18, 2013, 12:43:10 AM

What if a government just buys up all our cars? We'd have no way to get to work.

yeah, but cars increase government revenues both in all the permits/regulations and the gas tax. It'd be revenue-stupid for governments to force eco-friendly means of transport. OTOH, Bitcoin threatens to decrease tax revenues by making taxes easier to evade (similar to cash transactions, which are heavily discouraged in most countries, either by criminalizing large cash transactions, forbidding large withdrawals, or even making it semi-criminal to have substantial amounts of cash on-hand).

Maybe they'll buy up all our cash then, and force us to use credit cards.

Kluge

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1015

Quote from: cp1 on July 18, 2013, 12:43:10 AM

What if a government just buys up all our cars? We'd have no way to get to work.

yeah, but cars increase government revenues both in all the permits/regulations and the gas tax. It'd be revenue-stupid for governments to force eco-friendly means of transport. OTOH, Bitcoin threatens to decrease tax revenues by making taxes easier to evade (similar to cash transactions, which are heavily discouraged in most countries, either by criminalizing large cash transactions, forbidding large withdrawals, or even making it semi-criminal to have substantial amounts of cash on-hand).

cp1

hero member

Activity: 616

Merit: 500

Stop using branwallets

What if a government just buys up all our cars? We'd have no way to get to work.

Kluge

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1015

Quote from: jeannie on July 18, 2013, 12:22:04 AM

They don't even need to do that, they just set a new law to confiscate and ban Bitcoin and we are all gone.

Fwiw, almost every Bitcoin exchange knowingly operates unlawfully right now. It costs tens of millions in bonds and fees (on top of exorbitant annual fees) to get the proper licenses just to operate everywhere in the US. Banks often end up being the enforcers of these state laws because they don't want to touch something illegal (unless it's a drug cartel, I guess). MtGox, for instance, partly because of the CoinLab SNAFU which may've resulted in a totally legal US BTC exchange, is basically a black market waiting for more seizures and cease-and-desist letters.

However, there are plenty of individuals willing to trade cash for BTC, which is important because a broad ban on Bitcoin would be completely unenforceable, which is one of the reasons Bitcoin is so valuable.

jeannie

member

Activity: 98

Merit: 10

They don't even need to do that, they just set a new law to confiscate and ban Bitcoin and we are all gone.

johnyj

legendary

Activity: 1988

Merit: 1012

Beyond Imagination

Governments have huge debts now, their only hope is to buy some bitcoin and sell them at a much higher price to pay back their debt, none other method will work Wink

Kluge

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1015

Quote from: lucasjkr on July 17, 2013, 11:23:29 PM

Why do people throw out the idea of the government attempting to buy up every bitcoin? It's insane. If the government did want to kill Bitcoin, do you think they would spend a billion dollars to do that? Or do you think they'ed spend $10 or $20 million, and have their own ASIC's deployed in order to over run the network? Or would they just locate each of the big mining pools, DOS them and/or block their traffic and leave Bitcoins difficulty so impossibly high that the rest of the network couldn't confirm blocks in any amount of reasonable time?

Buying out bitcoin would only cause people to rush and hop into the next coin, awating an even bigger buyout. Done properly, a decent attack MIGHT have the effect of making most participants wary of even trying to do this again.

Think about it.

They could even bump up the stakes by quietly having an ASIC farm in waiting (wouldn't have to be as big as in your scenario), DDoS all pools so difficulty plummets, then when difficulty changes, bring the farm online and double-spend as much as able to erode confidence and perhaps even convince some merchants to stop accepting BTC. At next difficulty change, halt the DDoS against pools and get everything in order to have all BTC exchanges served at once, while letting everyone mine until next difficulty change. At next difficulty change, shut down and seize funds from all exchanges able, then point their gov ASIC farm back to their old job of bruteforcing encrypted messages, letting the network semi-organically bring itself to a difficulty death spiral due both to the price plummet (due to many successful double-spends and sudden failure of many exchanges) and the huge dropoff in hashpower from the gov ASIC farm being pointed somewhere else.

lucasjkr

hero member

Activity: 644

Merit: 500

Why do people throw out the idea of the government attempting to buy up every bitcoin? It's insane. If the government did want to kill Bitcoin, do you think they would spend a billion dollars to do that? Or do you think they'ed spend $10 or $20 million, and have their own ASIC's deployed in order to over run the network? Or would they just locate each of the big mining pools, DOS them and/or block their traffic and leave Bitcoins difficulty so impossibly high that the rest of the network couldn't confirm blocks in any amount of reasonable time?

Buying out bitcoin would only cause people to rush and hop into the next coin, awating an even bigger buyout. Done properly, a decent attack MIGHT have the effect of making most participants wary of even trying to do this again.

Think about it.

Kluge

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1015

There are a whole bunch of ways government could sabotage Bitcoin. A truly epic $5000-$5 pump and dump would be one way... If the gov't spent enough, they could slowly build up to $5000, then dump to $5 and artificially keep the price down.

There are plenty of alternative ways to really disrupt Bitcoin, though. You can think of plenty of ways to disrupt Bitcoin while sitting on the can - it's just they all require a ton of cash, and a lot of effort to squash something which hasn't yet proven itself a major threat. Hmm... but then there's the CDC creating new strains of infectious diseases to fight... Anyway, I like the "Satosh Capture" route https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/community-blacklisting-establishing-the-infection-to-govern-bitcoin-151367 Grin

Zufox

full member

Activity: 434

Merit: 100

There's no point to the what if ______ buys up all the bitcoins. There are millions of bitcoins currently out there and thousands of people that aren't willing to sell. It'll never happen. If governments forbid businesses from using bitcoins, that's a whole 'nother form of sabotage that they could possibly get away with.

ErisDiscordia

legendary

Activity: 1133

Merit: 1163

Imposition of ORder = Escalation of Chaos

they will prove that governments are even more stupid that anyone could possibly have imagined Grin

escrow.ms

legendary

Activity: 1274

Merit: 1004

We will move to litecoins lol

BitCloud

newbie

Activity: 48

Merit: 0

instead of saying "destroys all the bitcoins" you could have at least said "make them lost/not found"

wachtwoord

legendary

Activity: 2324

Merit: 1125

Quote from: DeathAndTaxes on July 17, 2013, 02:57:09 PM

Awesome I will sell mine for $500K each and use the procedes to fund Bitcoin 2.0 and the other half to retire.

Should we give out prices for being the 10,000th person to ask this question? Oh well, the price is a link to the search function! https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=search;advanced Cheesy

DeathAndTaxes

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1079

Gerald Davis

Awesome I will sell mine for $500K each and use the procedes to fund Bitcoin 2.0 and the other half to retire.

BitcoinIssues

newbie

Activity: 6

Merit: 0

Too bad we're all not selling

ardana123

hero member

Activity: 504

Merit: 500

and destroys them afterwards to sabotage bitcoin? Wouldn't that just fuck everything up?

Topic: What if a government just buys up all the bitcoins - page 2. (Read 3830 times)