Topic: Why are people still using gox when there is no way to withdraw (Read 4134 times)

We use Gox for a few reasons:

- Easy BTC in/out
- Generally highest volumes
- Generally largest 'swings' when trading goes crazy

We have not and will not withdraw from Gox, rather we trade based on BTC and withdraw BTC to Coinbase where we sell for the 'real' value (read: Not Gox prices).  So from a trading mindset, sell high, re-buy low, extract BTC profit, try to remain stable at a BTC level.  This has generally worked pretty well over the long term, but like any trading has its risk (since holding BTC you can have a value of $1000 one minute and $600 the next), but this has worked flawlessly.  

Gox just did over 50K volume!

If everyone know then no body would use. mtgox is trying to hide it

Feeling like hell will freeze over before then. It's been too long already.

I'm biased - but confused about this as well. Has anyone gotten USD out of Gox in the last month?

if anybody has any brains at all, they will abandon gox. it is just a matter of time until they die.

they are single handedly responsible for the crash in april

their customer service is utterly pathetic

they continue to rip people off everyday with inflated prices


READ THE HANDWRITING ON THE WALL. it is just a matter of time until they die.

I'm also waiting my gox withdrawal for August 11, 2013. What happen to gox?

The SWIFT withdraw issues didn't start until mid june.

No, I made a SWIFT transfer to Europe. Back in June after 4  or 5 days it was completed.

Are you within the states? I can't believe there is still issues going on with mtgox withdrawals this is just insane.

i am waiting for a gox withdraw for since 6 august 2013 ...

Any Idea when the arbitrage will cease? Will it just fizzle out or go on forever? Also who uses gox and for what lol it seems that its becoming antiquated quickly. It is IMO the 1st gen, still waiting to see who will take their place and do a much better job

if someone was doing the arbitrage.... then the price difference wouldn't be there anymore.

because its got the highest volume so if you are regularly trading btc/us$ its the best place to be, or at least until another exchange has higher volume and then its easy to shift

Gox reps told me that it is impossible to withdraw JPY to another country.
So another reason to believe Gox is on track to steal people's BTC and $$.
Who knows when Gox would announce JPY withdraw within japan is suspended??

   You can, but it's by SWIFT transfer, which takes forever @ gox. Its only the japanese domestic transfers that are going quickly.
     

But what I don't understand is, why can't they withdraw JPY internationally? That makes no sense.

https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/mtgox-btc-withdraw-nonsense-286255

you withdraw bitcoin, then go for bitstamp, gg?

They probably like to live their lives dangerously.

gox is probably making a killing buying coins on bitstamp or btc-e and selling them at their inflated prices.

Because if you are in Japan you can still withdraw. It's just international wires that doesn't work.

Ahh that big evil company that gox is !
Yes good question why don't we use some other exhanges ?

I don't know about you but here are my reasons :

- on some other exchange i can't get money in as easily as i can with gox (i am not living in the USA for people living there you might have heard that there are other continents and countries in the world , we do have internet too!  and we are also quite a lot to buy bitcoin. for most of us gox is pretty fine)

- on some other exchange the volume is too low for what i trade (i am not againdt btc-e for example they are fine especially if you want to buy some LTC  and why not NMC . I never had any problems with them but if you begin to accumulate more than 150 btc to trade then you certainly won't do it on btc-e !

- Some other exchange might have nice website and good marketing but for some reasons i trust gox better ( i might be such  fool yep but i don't thing i am the only one)
- Their will always be people angry or is it jealousy because the success of some company (look there's always those good old "micr0s$ft haters" who are proudly displaying on their hacked windows 7 ultimate;  wallpapers picturing a penguin breaking a windows (you know your classic ? ) but hey that's life it is wasn't gox it would be an other one.

- Mtgox has been and is still a great "help" for bitcoin !



- I don't consider myself being particularly lucky , but when i see all those people "who have problems to withdraw" it makes me feel kind of lucky for once because i haven't had any problems to withdraw with gox. (ok i am not saying gox never had troubles regarding the withdrawals, but i withdraw in EUROS so maybe i am not concerned and apparently they have been working hard on it so there shouldn't be much bad cases left). I agree it can be pretty slow thought but the maximum for me had been something like 2 weeks, which is for me acceptable.


PS : i Don't work for GOX , I am not related in away to them, I am not against new echanges taking their part of the market but let's be honest , even though gox isn't perfect for everybody (and it isn't for me either. I'd love some improvments) they are still the biggest exchange and I believe they are the one of the most reliable. Now you could have a look at some shaddy exchange but thrn don't come and cry later if you lost all your money.

xx

You mean working as in you can withdraw JPY into a country besides Japan? Or it only works with withdrawals inside Japan?
My bank an accept JPY currency, but Gox says they don't send any JPY outside of the country.

Why would they have said No? I know people who withdraw JPY last week without issue, and the JPY volume is way higher than normal right now, so I think people are indeed getting JPY transfers out.

And BTW, you cannot withdraw USD via a JPY domestic transfer...

this^

I asked them to withdraw via JPY, and they said NO. So my impression is they have no money at all.

And some withdraws are coming through, its really just USD withdraws that are having issues. The SEPA EUR transfers queue seems to be getting shorter and shorter.

because the 15-20 dollar gap is luring ppl to gox.

The real question is:
Why are people still using gox?

I'm selling BTC on a very low rate, because SEPA needs about 3-4 weeks for me. I tried a lower amount now, 399 EUR, but it also lasts 2 weeks now.

As soon as price differences are more equal, I say goodbye.

Some lucky people got SEPA transfer recently

I'm able to withdraw my money.

Per topic, why are people still using mtgox when there is no way to withdraw your money?