Well it cant be just stated that it comes under money transmitter ,there are several regulations for that not just one 'money circulation'.
even a newbie can differentiate between trading and tipping.
Topic: Why Not Add A ' TIP BUTTON ' ? (Read 1235 times)
thats a great ideea ...im in! 
It doesn't matter. Read the thread. Theymos answered this question last year. We won't see any tipping extension implementations in this forum.
I've thought about that before, but I think that there might be legal problems with that. It might make the forum a "money transmitter".
However you are free to use your signature space for collecting Bitcoin donations.
thats a great ideea ...im in!
This suggestion was written before.
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/changetip-for-bitcointalk-849071
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/internal-changetip-mechanism-858848
The forum pay taxes from income, internal tip system would be a problematic. Theymos doesn't want to implement any tip system to the forum.
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/changetip-for-bitcointalk-849071
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/internal-changetip-mechanism-858848
The forum pay taxes from income, internal tip system would be a problematic. Theymos doesn't want to implement any tip system to the forum.
The forum has a lot of operating money from all the donator tips when Bitcoin was still cheap but your right about theymos being concerned about implementing it due to the risk of being considered a money transfer service.
That said this is a pretty old idea so good call looking back in meta.
I've thought about that before, but I think that there might be legal problems with that. It might make the forum a "money transmitter".
It sounds like a good idea, but I suspect theymos wouldn't be interested in implementing it mostly because it requires the forum to hold money on behalf of others. If he somehow lost control of the funds, would he be liable to pay back all lost funds? I don't think he'd want to get mixed up in something like that. Also, if the website started to hold bitcoin (although it would probably be a small amount per user, but there are well over 500k users on the site) it would become a bigger target for hackers if there is a monetary incentive.
Tips don't seem to be sent very much (once and awhile on /r/Bitcoin, but not very often from what I've seen), and for the amount of work it would be to implement something like that and try to secure it all I don't think it would be worth it. The current situation of sending a tip to the address listed on a user's profile seems easy enough for me.
What are you talking about? Why even forum need to hold money from tips in the first place? I will be p2p tip service. Tips don't seem to be sent very much (once and awhile on /r/Bitcoin, but not very often from what I've seen), and for the amount of work it would be to implement something like that and try to secure it all I don't think it would be worth it. The current situation of sending a tip to the address listed on a user's profile seems easy enough for me.
If you state your BTC address in the options, you will gain tip button, and then all tips will be send to you directly.
There is no need for forum moderation over this feature.
The difference would be instead of having to manually create the link and put it in the profile, the forum could simply make the thing automatically for users that set the address in their profile.
Tip button is a nice idea tho first this forum needs to be secured. Plus the idea of tip can be done if you want to, just send it to the address in their profile or better yet ask them their address and send some btcs.
This suggestion was written before.
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/changetip-for-bitcointalk-849071
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/internal-changetip-mechanism-858848
The forum pay taxes from income, internal tip system would be a problematic. Theymos doesn't want to implement any tip system to the forum.
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/changetip-for-bitcointalk-849071
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/internal-changetip-mechanism-858848
The forum pay taxes from income, internal tip system would be a problematic. Theymos doesn't want to implement any tip system to the forum.
It sounds like a good idea, but I suspect theymos wouldn't be interested in implementing it mostly because it requires the forum to hold money on behalf of others. If he somehow lost control of the funds, would he be liable to pay back all lost funds? I don't think he'd want to get mixed up in something like that. Also, if the website started to hold bitcoin (although it would probably be a small amount per user, but there are well over 500k users on the site) it would become a bigger target for hackers if there is a monetary incentive.
Tips don't seem to be sent very much (once and awhile on /r/Bitcoin, but not very often from what I've seen), and for the amount of work it would be to implement something like that and try to secure it all I don't think it would be worth it. The current situation of sending a tip to the address listed on a user's profile seems easy enough for me.
What are you talking about? Why even forum need to hold money from tips in the first place? I will be p2p tip service. Tips don't seem to be sent very much (once and awhile on /r/Bitcoin, but not very often from what I've seen), and for the amount of work it would be to implement something like that and try to secure it all I don't think it would be worth it. The current situation of sending a tip to the address listed on a user's profile seems easy enough for me.
If you state your BTC address in the options, you will gain tip button, and then all tips will be send to you directly.
There is no need for forum moderation over this feature.
It sounds like a good idea, but I suspect theymos wouldn't be interested in implementing it mostly because it requires the forum to hold money on behalf of others. If he somehow lost control of the funds, would he be liable to pay back all lost funds? I don't think he'd want to get mixed up in something like that. Also, if the website started to hold bitcoin (although it would probably be a small amount per user, but there are well over 500k users on the site) it would become a bigger target for hackers if there is a monetary incentive.
Tips don't seem to be sent very much (once and awhile on /r/Bitcoin, but not very often from what I've seen), and for the amount of work it would be to implement something like that and try to secure it all I don't think it would be worth it. The current situation of sending a tip to the address listed on a user's profile seems easy enough for me.
What are you talking about? Why even forum need to hold money from tips in the first place? I will be p2p tip service. Tips don't seem to be sent very much (once and awhile on /r/Bitcoin, but not very often from what I've seen), and for the amount of work it would be to implement something like that and try to secure it all I don't think it would be worth it. The current situation of sending a tip to the address listed on a user's profile seems easy enough for me.
If you state your BTC address in the options, you will gain tip button, and then all tips will be send to you directly.
There is no need for forum moderation over this feature.
It sounds like a good idea, but I suspect theymos wouldn't be interested in implementing it mostly because it requires the forum to hold money on behalf of others. If he somehow lost control of the funds, would he be liable to pay back all lost funds? I don't think he'd want to get mixed up in something like that. Also, if the website started to hold bitcoin (although it would probably be a small amount per user, but there are well over 500k users on the site) it would become a bigger target for hackers if there is a monetary incentive.
Yeah that is some good point from you but he can think of something different to add that option ,like what if you can reward points instead of coins and you have to buy/sell points from theymos ,so what if hackers stole all the points ...it is pointless lolll.People dont tip because they it want plain and simple ,think of an extra option beside reply button,that is very simple and also more convincing than any other tip options.
It sounds like a good idea, but I suspect theymos wouldn't be interested in implementing it mostly because it requires the forum to hold money on behalf of others. If he somehow lost control of the funds, would he be liable to pay back all lost funds? I don't think he'd want to get mixed up in something like that. Also, if the website started to hold bitcoin (although it would probably be a small amount per user, but there are well over 500k users on the site) it would become a bigger target for hackers if there is a monetary incentive.
Tips don't seem to be sent very much (once and awhile on /r/Bitcoin, but not very often from what I've seen), and for the amount of work it would be to implement something like that and try to secure it all I don't think it would be worth it. The current situation of sending a tip to the address listed on a user's profile seems easy enough for me.
Tips don't seem to be sent very much (once and awhile on /r/Bitcoin, but not very often from what I've seen), and for the amount of work it would be to implement something like that and try to secure it all I don't think it would be worth it. The current situation of sending a tip to the address listed on a user's profile seems easy enough for me.
Hey guys i was wondering why isint there any tip option on the forum ?
I mean if you like someone's service ,post, opinions or any other actions then you can tip him and which is public.
share your opinions.
I mean if you like someone's service ,post, opinions or any other actions then you can tip him and which is public.
share your opinions.
It does sound like a good idea but I have spoke to escrows and have dealt with myself always giving tips, turns out that the other party does not usualy do the same and they tell me very rarely do they give tips. Saying that I believe it is highly doubtful that much tips would be given.
It can also be for Moderators ,if they are good at their service.
Hey guys i was wondering why isint there any tip option on the forum ?
I mean if you like someone's service ,post, opinions or any other actions then you can tip him and which is public.
share your opinions.
I mean if you like someone's service ,post, opinions or any other actions then you can tip him and which is public.
share your opinions.
It does sound like a good idea but I have spoke to escrows and have dealt with myself always giving tips, turns out that the other party does not usualy do the same and they tell me very rarely do they give tips. Saying that I believe it is highly doubtful that much tips would be given.
Extra tip button looks like it is a good idea, but how do we send bitcoin in of this forum 
This should not be that hard to implement. I envision this to work like this: Tips will be linked with user BTC address, you will need to manually set this.
Every user who wish to receive TIPS will have TIP button, preferably under their avatar, this option will be available only for Full Members and above.
because these people can also have some good service or knowledge or opinions..anything ...etc.. so they should be tipped if deserved.
Extra tip button looks like it is a good idea, but how do we send bitcoin in of this forum
This should not be that hard to implement. I envision this to work like this: Tips will be linked with user BTC address, you will need to manually set this.
Every user who wish to receive TIPS will have TIP button, preferably under their avatar, this option will be available only for Full Members and above.
I think it could be a nice addition too. But it is likely a lot of work and, in the end, most people would not likely tip...
Maybe we should move this topic in META here -https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=167.0, so that ADMIN might look at it and express his opinions or think of a way to do it .
Extra tip button looks like it is a good idea, but how do we send bitcoin in of this forum
I just wanted to know your opinions guys ,i mean there is no harm in tipping 0.005 to someone who has some good qualities or has some beneficial service etc..
' so why not VOTE for it '.
' so why not VOTE for it '.
maybe in the next forum...
what do you mean by next forum ? do you mean update ?
new forum using new forum software (no longer smf).
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=167.0
I doubt they will add any new features now when the new forum is on the works.
Jump to: