Wire transfers? | Bitcointalksearch.org

cbeast

donator

Activity: 1736

Merit: 1014

Let's talk governance, lipstick, and pigs.

Quote from: boonies4u on December 01, 2011, 02:59:48 AM

Quote from: Stephen Gornick on December 01, 2011, 02:50:36 AM

Quote from: Elwar on November 28, 2011, 09:06:00 AM

I was driving down the road and I saw a "Western Union" sign and thought...why do we still have those places around?

Bitcoin could easily replace Western Union all over the world

$350 billion this year ... just to developing countries.

http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/NEWS/0,,contentMDK:23058070~pagePK:64257043~piPK:437376~theSitePK:4607,00.html

It's all about the BRICS.

OFWs and mail-order brides. I still think pawn shops around the world should network with bitcoin. Pawn a stereo to send cash to a family member.

boonies4u

hero member

Activity: 826

Merit: 1000

Quote from: Stephen Gornick on December 01, 2011, 02:50:36 AM

Quote from: Elwar on November 28, 2011, 09:06:00 AM

I was driving down the road and I saw a "Western Union" sign and thought...why do we still have those places around?

Bitcoin could easily replace Western Union all over the world

$350 billion this year ... just to developing countries.

http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/NEWS/0,,contentMDK:23058070~pagePK:64257043~piPK:437376~theSitePK:4607,00.html

It's all about the BRICS.

Stephen Gornick

legendary

Activity: 2506

Merit: 1010

Quote from: Elwar on November 28, 2011, 09:06:00 AM

I was driving down the road and I saw a "Western Union" sign and thought...why do we still have those places around?

Bitcoin could easily replace Western Union all over the world

$350 billion this year ... just to developing countries.

http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/NEWS/0,,contentMDK:23058070~pagePK:64257043~piPK:437376~theSitePK:4607,00.html

byronbb

legendary

Activity: 1414

Merit: 1000

HODL OR DIE

I think focusing on a single country would be a good start for such an idea. USA <-> Philippines or Mexico are the obvious to me.

ovidiusoft

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: MatthewLM on November 30, 2011, 03:09:51 PM

I don't know what the VAT is like in Japan is either but VAT on fees is much different than VAT on the whole thing.

Of course, it's the difference between selling the coins and being an intermediary for two parties who want to exchange coins. See my post #24.

MatthewLM

legendary

Activity: 1190

Merit: 1004

I don't know what the VAT is like in Japan is either but VAT on fees is much different than VAT on the whole thing.

ovidiusoft

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: MatthewLM on November 30, 2011, 02:33:41 PM

Mt. Gox doesn't sell bitcoin, it sells the service of exchange. They don't have to charge VAT.

I don't know what is the procedure for VAT in Japan, but as the general case says, they should charge VAT on their exchange fees.

Quote

Question is: If an individual bitcoin seller trades above the VAT threshold in their country do they legally have to include this?

I believe they would have to, yes.

MatthewLM

legendary

Activity: 1190

Merit: 1004

Mt. Gox doesn't sell bitcoin, it sells the service of exchange. They don't have to charge VAT.

Question is: If an individual bitcoin seller trades above the VAT threshold in their country do they legally have to include this? I don't know, if bitcoin exchanges come into legal problems I just hope they can work OK underground.

ovidiusoft

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: phillipsjk on November 29, 2011, 09:04:26 PM

If you buy coins low, and sell them high, you would also pay 20% tax on the profit (if your coin supplier also paid the VAT, 20% on the face value otherwise).

Yes, that is the real problem with VAT vs bitcoins. In probably 90% of the cases, bitcoins will be purchased from people, and will not carry VAT, so there's nothing to deduct Sad

.

ovidiusoft

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: iamzill on November 30, 2011, 12:33:25 AM

Only if your business is trading bitcoins (good luck convincing the tax man).

Well, that's not really a problem, the taxman won't care, as long as he can put a price on that. It will be like selling services, or SSL certificates, or selling the same copy of an MP3 over and over.

The sale of bitcoins for fiat is actually easier for the accounting dept., since it has an evident value attached. It's more complicated to sell products for bitcoins, as this will be a barter (which must have a fiat value attached, too). But I digress.

ovidiusoft

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: ?? on ??

For those of us who live somewhere without a VAT tax, could you explain what it is, and how it could apply to bitcoins?

Much better explained than I could do: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VAT

Quote

Do all these legal requirements apply if you are exchanging local currency for foreign currency?

No. Currency exchange is VAT-exempt.

iamzill

sr. member

Activity: 677

Merit: 250

Quote from: phillipsjk on November 29, 2011, 09:04:26 PM

My understanding of a VAT, is that the product is taxed whenever "value" is added in the chain. According to the Wikipedia Article, suppliers are able to deduct the tax they pay on inputs, such that they only pay the government tax on the "value" they add.

This is awkward for bitcoin if it is considered a commodity. That implies that in a country with a 20% VAT, 10 BTC of any 50 BTC coin creation transactions should go to the government as tax. If you buy coins low, and sell them high, you would also pay 20% tax on the profit (if your coin supplier also paid the VAT, 20% on the face value otherwise).

This brings up an awkward situation where it may be considered beneficial to consider bitcoin a currency (and all the expensive regulation that entails) in some countries (like where VAT is a concern), and a commodity in others. If it is a commodity, you you need to secure export and import permits to move Bitcoins across borders?

Edit: I also did not mention that informal transactions totalling less than ~$35 thousand a year are often exempt. As BTC prices rise, more and more miners (and informal traders) may flirt with the threshold.

Only if your business is trading bitcoins (good luck convincing the tax man). Your scenario is describing a capital gain, so the capital gains tax applies, which is usually much higher than the VAT.

phillipsjk

legendary

Activity: 1008

Merit: 1001

Let the chips fall where they may.

My understanding of a VAT, is that the product is taxed whenever "value" is added in the chain. According to the Wikipedia Article, suppliers are able to deduct the tax they pay on inputs, such that they only pay the government tax on the "value" they add.

This is awkward for bitcoin if it is considered a commodity. That implies that in a country with a 20% VAT, 10 BTC of any 50 BTC coin creation transactions should go to the government as tax. If you buy coins low, and sell them high, you would also pay 20% tax on the profit (if your coin supplier also paid the VAT, 20% on the face value otherwise).

This brings up an awkward situation where it may be considered beneficial to consider bitcoin a currency (and all the expensive regulation that entails) in some countries (like where VAT is a concern), and a commodity in others. If it is a commodity, you you need to secure export and import permits to move Bitcoins across borders?

Edit: I also did not mention that informal transactions totalling less than ~$35 thousand a year are often exempt. As BTC prices rise, more and more miners (and informal traders) may flirt with the threshold.

Dan The Man

hero member

Activity: 672

Merit: 500

VAT stands for Value Added Tax. It means that the government is adding value to everything you buy, but not in the way you would think, by encrusting it with diamonds or something. They add value by making you pay more for it, and since you get what you pay for, you are getting more value for the same product. Pretty ingenious way to make everything more valuable.

repentance

hero member

Activity: 868

Merit: 1000

Quote from: Dan The Man on November 29, 2011, 07:05:19 PM

Quote from: MatthewLM on November 29, 2011, 07:02:46 PM

But they can't advertise to the government inspectors "bitcoins bought and sold here VAT free" can they?

Mt Gox does it.

Nobody's ever suggested that MtGox even tries to comply with financial services laws in the countries in which it operates. They're operating unlicenced and unregulated and France probably won't be the only country where that bites them on the ass.

Quote

The key though is that nobody know what the client is doing with their Bitcoins or where they got them from. The store just exchanges them for dollars.

And how is the merchant going to deal with this from an accounting point of view? What's he going to explain the outgoing dollar payments as in the books? If he keeps the transactions totally off the books then he's in for a world of grief if his activity gets discovered. Plus he needs a legitimate way of converting the Bitcoins transferred to him back to hard currency because there's only so much you can buy with Bitcoins at this point in time. He doesn't want to be stuck with Bitcoins he exchanged for $2.50 each when they're now only worth $1.50.

Dan The Man

hero member

Activity: 672

Merit: 500

Quote from: MatthewLM on November 29, 2011, 07:02:46 PM

But they can't advertise to the government inspectors "bitcoins bought and sold here VAT free" can they?

Mt Gox does it.

MatthewLM

legendary

Activity: 1190

Merit: 1004

But they can't advertise to the government inspectors "bitcoins bought and sold here VAT free" can they?

Dan The Man

hero member

Activity: 672

Merit: 500

Quote from: repentance on November 29, 2011, 06:52:06 PM

Quote from: ?? on ??

So what we need is for corner stores to hang a sign out front saying "bitcoin bought and sold here". Person A goes into the store with Country A cash, buys bitcoins from merchant. Person A then sends those bitcoins to person B. Person B walks into corner store near them, transfers bitcoins to merchant, and then walks out with Country B cash.

This is exactly how a lot of the smaller money transmission companies here operate. Merchants whose core business is something else entirely offer money transmission services. They are still required to be licensed in order to do this though, so they operate as agents of a parent company. They're also required to sight the same ID as larger services like Western Union.

As long as you're taking someone's money in order to transmit it to someone else - even if the means by which the actual transmission happens is through Bitcoins - you're going to need licensing as a deposit-taker/money transmitter/payment processor/whatever. Being a small corner store offering the service as a sideline isn't going to exempt you from the legal requirements for operating such a service.

And service based taxes are also going to be an issue in some countries.

The key though is that nobody know what the client is doing with their Bitcoins or where they got them from. The store just exchanges them for dollars.

repentance

hero member

Activity: 868

Merit: 1000

Quote from: ?? on ??

So what we need is for corner stores to hang a sign out front saying "bitcoin bought and sold here". Person A goes into the store with Country A cash, buys bitcoins from merchant. Person A then sends those bitcoins to person B. Person B walks into corner store near them, transfers bitcoins to merchant, and then walks out with Country B cash.

This is exactly how a lot of the smaller money transmission companies here operate. Merchants whose core business is something else entirely offer money transmission services. They are still required to be licensed in order to do this though, so they operate as agents of a parent company. They're also required to sight the same ID as larger services like Western Union.

As long as you're taking someone's money in order to transmit it to someone else - even if the means by which the actual transmission happens is through Bitcoins - you're going to need licensing as a deposit-taker/money transmitter/payment processor/whatever. Being a small corner store offering the service as a sideline isn't going to exempt you from the legal requirements for operating such a service.

And service based taxes are also going to be an issue in some countries.

ovidiusoft

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: ?? on ??

So what we need is for corner stores to hang a sign out front saying "bitcoin bought and sold here". Person A goes into the store with Country A cash, buys bitcoins from merchant. Person A then sends those bitcoins to person B. Person B walks into corner store near them, transfers bitcoins to merchant, and then walks out with Country B cash.

This will not work in countries with VAT. If you want to be legal, you'll have a huge spread between buy and sell price (your markup and the VAT). Minimum 20%, much more in some countries. In order to avoid the VAT issue, you'd have to be registered as an exchange office (but Bitcoin is not a recognized currency...), or as a money transfer/non-banking financial institution, which has its own many issues, costs and regulations.

The only way I could find that might work is as a "commercial intermediary" (sorry if I didn't translate correcly) - a company that introduces two parties who will engage in a commercial exchange. Think auction sites. User A has bitcoins, user B has USD, company C provides the way for them to engage in the exchange, for a small fee. It does have the issue that company C can't be a party of the exchange, both A and B are needed...

It's complicated Sad

Topic: Wire transfers? (Read 3746 times)