I feel that seeing as yochdog is a trusted member, there shouldn't be much problem shipping the card back in order to get the refund. Even if he wasn't the best trusted member, what would you have to lose shipping back a broken card?
My interpretation on this is, the buyer had buyer's remorse, and decided they wanted their BTC back + any profits they would have made had they sold high and bought back in low.
Edit*
I'm not the one calling names, so I'm not the one who looks foolish. He has not fully refunded me, if you want to believe him there's nothing I can do about that. If you choose to believe someone based on their post count that's fine too. But I have a right to say what went down and let you know.
A guy has the right to get pissed when you call him a scammer if it is wrongful, so you actually do seem a bit foolish until some sort of proof is given. We aren't believing Yoch based on his post count, we are believing him based on his previous track record, as well as the fact that his defense sounds reasonable.