I don't think anyone really had the complete package with all of these. I'm sure he can clarify further.
To be fair he didn't really specify much in the OP. If my logo is chosen I'm happy to extend my work further.
It is a complete waste of time to draw out all pieces at once and then have someone give absolutely no feedback other than 'I do not like it'.
Artwork takes a lot of time to not only be creative but to also render items. When I do artwork I make my items extremely large because it is better to have the correct artwork in high quality at various sizes then to have one small sample that has to be completely redone on a larger scale. My coins & buttons etc that I posted are from 20+inch files and the ones I posted on here are maybe 2 inches.
I agree completely with you. However I would suggest using some sort of vector format, it seems a waste of time to make different sizes of the same thing