The cooling on the U1 is terrible. The metal "heatsink" does almost nothing, and you're better off cutting it out and applying thermal paste and drilling a hole in for a homemade cutout heatsink.
With prices though buying neither makes sense compared to buying compac. It at least get's you the most for your money. And if you plan to run it ... yes it's a lotto or learning rig. Your better off spending and buying BTC vs these mini rigs. But that is not much fun.
I don't see neither U1 or U2 really making much sense, unless you happen to already have them.
Than you for the advice... yeah you're right, buying bitcoins is not really fun. I already have 1 antminer u1 and 1 block erupted (333khs). I know that's ridiculous and i'm thinking to upgrade it.