if i grow the worlds biggest apple by accident on my tree,on my property its 100% mine
if i eat it myself and shit it out i pay no taxes
if someone swapped me a lambo for the apple whats the differnce ,i still acquired value from nothing so i pay no taxes
if i sell it to my neighbour who makes apple jam with it and we sell the jam for $500k i guess we owe taxes
the part im not sure about is when exactly does the government own 30% of my apple ?
is it when its still on the tree ? and the value is as yet unknown ?
is it when its converted to jam ?
does it go by yearly tax dates ?
i cant declare an apple that hasnt fully grown yet as its value is still appreciating etc
that's why we live in a world of very flawed tax laws that are prone to corruption and injustice.
Only taxes that can be reliably enforced and could not be evaded should exist. Instead of taking money by force, governments should ask for donations and people should be able to choose in which government projects they donate. For example, I would not donate to the budget of DEA but I would donate to the public education budget. Free market bitch.
If they did that whole donation route, Id doubt anyone would donate lol.
If you ask people on the street would they donate to a homeless person you`ll have mixed reactions about donation and it`ll turn out the same way with donating to the government.
Also what you described should be more towards a private company that has some government contract.