#2 Suppose Bitcoin was backed by Coca-Cola Stock. $6 billion of stock, would generate $187 million in dividends alone annually. Imagine if some blind entity to bitcoin was buying $187 million of bitcoin and destroying them, every year as long as coca-cola exists. Suppose this was another group and a blackbox not tied to the Bitcoin foundation. As a bitcoin owner which would you rather own:
Bitcoin #1 backed by nothing zero inflation.
Bitcoin #2 with the blackbox destroying $187 million, presently about 0.4 million coins a year.
That's what a capital or business coin offers. Now transaction fees might have to be higher to offer protection as there would be no money printing. One thing I notice about AZO stock above, it has yet to have a losing year this century.
Bitcoin
2013 $757
2012 $14
2011 $4.7
2010 $.30
I think I get what you're saying. It's an interesting idea!
To answer your question, ideally I would rather own the Capital Coin, but...
What happens to the value of the coin when the underlying asset drops in value? For example, Coca Cola goes bankrupt? In that case I would rather own the "unbacked" Bitcoin.
As others pointed out it would introducing centralization again in the form of managers, which is also risky.
I think it would be cool to have additional layers on top of BTC where you could take a portion of BTC and create the Cap Coin. If you could figure out a way to do this and address the management/trust concerns it would be great.
You don't have to have just one stock, but if bitcoin owned $6 billion of KO stock, they could probably offer a can of soda with the bitcoin B symbol on it.
What happens to the value of the coin when the underlying asset drops in value? just use the dividends for deletion.
For example, Coca Cola goes bankrupt? you could hold multiple stocks and decentralized. The stock could be helds across the world, the only requirment is bitcoin is deleted.
As others pointed out it would introducing centralization again in the form of managers, which is also risky. The capital might be in no way owned by bitcoin, only a foundation like the Gates Foundation. The gates foundation lists their holding and we could actually mirror their holdings. We all know bitcoin is just as important as the Gates foundation. We could even start sending letters to non-profit foundations if they would support deleting bitcoin for us. We could also write letters to hedge fund managers to see if they would donate to the Bitcoin Deletion Foundation. Thus you have deletion and growth working together to allow the working class keep their money.