Not sure where you get the numbers from or why people would rate something a scam, but let me put my personal experience in between your numbers, obviously eliminating the numbers I have no experience with.
Gold crate = 80 sats
.... sells for 350 sat usually within an hour
Game Token = 2 sats
... I can't get more than just over 1 sat, usually 20 tokens for 30 sat already takes 6 hours or more to sell
Trade Token = 5 sats
.... 2 sat already doesn't sell, I usually put on sale 200 tokens for 400 sat and it fairly often takes a week or longer without a buyer, until I delete the offer and put it back for a lower price
Crystals per 10,000 = 250 sats
.... 20,000 crystals for 350 sat is the borderline and that frequently takes a day or two to find a buyer
2 stars = 2 sats
3 stars = 3 sats
5 stars = 4-5 sats
..... on that one there seems to be a WILD difference in opinion.
I'm putting offers up that consist of 1x 100 gold cards, 1x 100 silver cards, 4-7x 100 bronze cards, by your count worth between 900 and 1200 sat, I'm offering them for 950 sat, I'm getting almost exclusively scam ratings and they sell within a couple of hours anyway.
I'm guessing that's because the ones rating the offers are not the ones in need of cards.
Thomas, i only calculate the offers from the past 1,400 now and the scam_rates i don't count .. only what the members find a good rate.
Ofcourse i also see some rated bad 5 times still someone seems to buy them.
When i put in 135 cards with 125 one star cards and ask 9999 crystals for that, mostly i sell them the same day ... or asking 199 sats for those cards, getting 1 good and 3 bad rates i still sell them the same day.
It's just an indication what members do on average base the past 36 hr or so.
You and me don't need cards and sell most of them, but all newbies want those cards, we both sell them below the average sells.
What i don't anymore is selling cards with only the 5 stars cards e.g. mining pool, firewall, neutrino and destroyd neutrino, i put them in as bonus with what we call rubbish because we don't attack other players.
I think it's a good start this rating system ... honestly , i miss another rate_button ... the *fair* one, when the average price setup by members for a mining boost = 40 sats and someone put them in for 45 or 50 .. i still should say *fair* instead of *good*.