Just my two cents:
Pros:Wallet came back with zero viruses. I know most virus flags are false positives, so those are never a minus, but I think being able to remove them also shows good coding.
Very clean and professional looking wallet, and a nice ANN with simple, bold graphics. I don't know that many coins so I can't say for sure it's not a pure clone, but at least it doesn't look like a walletbuilders coin.
Any coin that actually states a purpose is better than one that doesn't and Loyalty Industry is actually a huge market potential. There is need to fill this gap (see
http://www.mytotalretail.com/article/attention-retailers-blockchain-technology-will-disrupt-loyalty-industry-know/). Any coin that can become a premiere rewards program has potential.
Not a newbie account.
Cons:The pre-mine, obviously. 25% is quite high. What are "Development Support" coins and "Marketing Support" coins?
We have a right to know exactly how much dev is keeping for himself and how much is going to be given away/sold to benefit the coin (i.e. not to line dev's pockets). Please clarify this - dev can keep a little bit for himself if he wants, as an incentive, but he should send it to a public cold storage address, and make clear that it is no more than 0.5% for himself.
Title says "NO-ICO" and the ANN then offers a "premise coin buy".
That's pretty much the same as an ICO. You also spelled pre-mine wrong... I hate ANNS with typos. You're submitting v1.0 of your finished product - take the time to do a spell check. You can spell things wrong in the rest of your regular forum posts, thats okay (I do it all the time).
Overall:Good potential here given some promising dev skills (assuming its not all ripped off, but I don't see that it is) and picking a good industry to target. But the pre-mine allocation for dev personally must be made clear, the purpose of the rest of the pre-mine must be elaborated, and the pre-mine amounts must be moved to public addresses (with hashes posted in ANN).
Edit: some language choices.
Edit 2: I want to add as a pro that
the website looks quite good. And I haven't tested it, but
if the webwallet is working, that is a big plus. These are elements (lol) that are missing from most shitcoins. I think we should keep this differentiation in mind. Questions about the pre-mine need to be answered, but if answered well would suggest this is a serious project.
P.S. dev pls get someone to make a pool ASAP. I don't have any X11 ASICs
The large pre-mine is justifiably something to be wary of. It sounds like this coin will be on an exchange before the dev will be disclosing the deals being negotiated and how the pre-mine will be spent to support those deals. It will be worth keeping an eye on the 2 big wallets (which hold almost 100% of coins) when this coin goes live on an exchange. If they don't get touched, then this project will be worth keeping an eye on.