So after doing some research, I decided to entrust some BTC with HaoBTC!
I do have a couple of concerns I'd like to voice, though, publicly so others can see the answers as well:
1) If the mining business goes down or otherwise becomes unprofitable (such is the case with this largely unknown variable), would you just drop the APY to 0%? Are there any other ways you're earning money off deposits right now?
2) Are the funds somehow guaranteed? I find this hard to fathom when depositors can withdraw at any minute (meaning that the funds can't all be tied up, otherwise people couldn't all withdraw). So can you please give a bit more information on how all of this works out in terms of risk involved?
Hi,
Our pleasure to have you!
I feel that I don't have all the answers ready but will try to address your concerns as much as I can:
While at the moment we make money mostly through mining, we are exploring alternatives that can potentially generate non-mining revenue. For example, we recently launched a service allowing users (right now only Chinese banks supported) to trade bitcoins and we charge a 0.1% commission. This has generated a small but growing income.
If the mining profitability diminishes but we manage to find replacements, we will continue to operate our Banking service and pay out interest.
The interest rate is pretty much dependent on market competition and that we drop it to 0 is extremely low.
If the company fails, the plan - not sure how official it is, but the CEO suggested at one point that all partners should take jobs and pay back the debt using their future income - I personally have no objections and think all the big name investment banks should do the same.
HaoBTC pretty much operates like a fractional-reserve bank (FRB) at the moment, and like all FRBs, it works on the assumption that all depositors won't withdraw at the same time. If we run out of reserve in a bank run scenario, one alternative is to borrow from the big exchanges, which have been giving loans for about 30 percent p.a.
Are the funds somehow guaranteed? Yes and no. It is not guaranteed by the law or state institutions, because there is little to no legislation in the space - not in China and not that I am aware of. It is guaranteed by our reputation and the scrutiny of users, esp. the Chinese ones. We make the commitment to our users that as long as the company exist, we will honor our obligations - this is true for the Chinese users and foreigners alike. If some unforeseeable events struck and the worst happened, in principle we will try to pay back the debt to the best of our ability - we don't have a specific plan but will publicize it once we do.
We have been considering bringing a third-party insurer onboard, but to be honest, it is hard to find one willing to provide such service and I don't think this is likely to happen soon.