I got my Delta AFB1212SH fans (0.8amp) 15 minutes ago and it seems they are the right ones for underclocked mining in winter time?!
only speaking of PWM fans, because fan control is a MUST in my opinion.
best fans before I tested were the 1amp fans from Antminer S3. they are very okay at 50% and below.
I did a lot of measurements in the past 1-2 weeks I try to sum up:
PWMs tested:
- sp20 original 2amp: very noisy, high CFM
- bitmain s1 1amp: lot quieter at low pwm%
- bitmain s3 1amp: even quieter but only at low pwm%
- noctua 3000 0.3amp: very quiet at low pwm% but not enough CFM for >1200 GH or summer time.
- some case fans like artic F12 0.3 amp and below claimed 80 CFM never ever, only okay for below 1000 GH
- Delta AFB1212SH fans (0.8amp): best up to now
I did db testings roughly 2 meters distance
my server PSU is not the quitest, it adds at least 44 db, I think PC PSUs with 12mm fans are better.
highest rating was sp20 stock fan at 68
all tests in room at 22c ambient
db pwm fan
----------------------------
68 100 org fan (2amp) full power taifun mode, still hear it through 2 closed doors and rooms
56 10 org
44 0 org (only my PSU)
50 10 s1 fan
58 100 s1 fan
50 6 s1 fan reverse
51,5 40 s3 fan rev
48 20 s3 fan rev
46 6 s3 fan rev low 900 gh
48,3 20 s3 fan rev
45,5 40 noctua 3000
47,2 61 auto mode
48 80 auto getting hot
46,2 64 PSU covered
52 100 reboot
53 100 Noctua reversed
44,8 40 Delta 1212SH 0,8A
45,5 50 Delta 1212SH 0,8A okay for 1100 GH
47,8 90 max auto mode, I think only good for below 1300 GH at 22c ambient
I doubt that air cooling will be less noisy...keep in mind that for extreme conditions you need fan cooling power, probably that 2amp, and this is noisy.
may be stacking 2 Deltas may be an option to try for some more cfm???! there is room as they are only 25mm compare to 38mm depth like stock and bitmains