That's probably one of the most entertaining threads I've read in a long time.
I am reading it since 2 hours should do a lot other things but it's really glueing.
What's very clear is that the XMR 'devs' haven't got a clue, obviously don't understand the code, and are basically helpless.
From what I have read and understand - YOU are exactly - CORRECT!!!
edit: such a shame
From what I can tell, this issue is a cryptonote issue. I wouldn't label anyone clueless until after the results are known - there are still some doubts over the attacks.
What would be interesting to see is if there is a successful attack and one of the CN projects has protection that they are not prepared to share.
I'm not a fan of monero by _any_ means - I have very strong doubts about many aspects of it, but I'm also impartial on these matters, and it's pretty obvious BCX is trolling.