Pages:
Author

Topic: {BFL} Here's a LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOK at your Monarch! - page 22. (Read 46654 times)

hero member
Activity: 924
Merit: 1000
Quote
so testing of the engines is taking a little longer than expected.

Longer than expected? Really.

Quote
we should be done testing the chip in the next few days.

Wait a minute wasn't chop dice package test supposed to be done in 2 weeks? What gives? Been what 4+ weeks now or more.


Quote
the packaged chips should be on their way to the testing facility

Should be?

Quote
though I don't yet have tracking numbers or confirmation of this.

Does anyone else see the irony in no tracking numbers?

Quote
I will be working on getting that today or tomorrow hopefully.

What getting tracking numbers? 1 to 2 days to find out where the chips are?


Quote
they will wire it up to the test harness and start conducting the full power tests to see just how far we might be able to push the chips and what their real world power consumption is.

So they have not started testing of the chips in a "test harness"? Oh my and chip production continues? What if there is a problem?

Let us review their original timeline estimates and comments for everyone from the October snapshot:

Quote
Tape out August 2013
November / December    Initial Shipping   (Sold out)
January / February    Bulk Shipping

Q When do the 28nm Monarch cards ship?

A We've been in development for approximately six months.  We're now in the final stage of the process which is wafer start at the foundry.  However, we aren't shipping anytime soon.  This is a Pre-Order product, so if you're uncomfortable waiting an indeterminate length of time for the final phase, do NOT pre-order this product.

With that in mind, our current schedule is on track for shippments shipments to begin towards end of year.  

Here are the timeline milestones:

    Tapeout (Initialization of wafer production)

    Foundry production takes 10 weeks

    Bumping, Slicing & BGA packaging takes approximately 2 weeks

    Initial shipments begin and ramp up to full capacity over the following 3 weeks

Since this is our 2nd generation ASIC chip, we're largely free of risk from the pitfalls normally associated with a new chip design.  Testing systems, Bumping masks, Substrates & under fill engineering are all carryovers from our proven design so they're complete and ready for high volume production once the wafers are ready.  The importance of this can't be overstated.

Let us review.

    August Tape Out was a lie it wasn't completed until December / January? 5 to 6 months late.
    Foundry was 20 weeks not 10 weeks.
    Bumping Slicing & BGA packaging (testing) was estimated 2 weeks. We are at 4 weeks now and still not tested.
    Initial shipments and ramp up to take 3 weeks. Ramp up must include testing of the packaged chips in the Monarch to establish stability. This will take 3 to 4 just on the testing and that is before production can start in earnest.

Ok does anyone see any GLARING omissions in the estimates from the past?

March? April? I suspect Q3 end of summer if you are lucky.


We've been in development for approximately six months. As stated in their October website. So count backwards please with me. October September August July June and May 2013. They have admitted they started development in May 2013. Now let us count forward May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December, January, February.  10 months.

Still no working chips.
Still no working Monarch.
Originally promised to ship in the bulk of orders in 15 weeks from mid October website claim.

November (4 weeks)
December (4 weeks)
January (4 weeks)

Bulk of orders were not shipped on January 16th or abouts... they still do not have working packaged chips.




legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
If memory serves, I believe there was a similarly curious statement made back during their 65nm testing days when they recognized they blew their power consumption numbers by at least a factor of two, that resulted in the need to force a redesign of the housing for their entire product line, and the Minirig being broken up into three separate units.

 Remember with the Jalapeno was supposed to be a flat and thin coffee warmer originally ?

 As for a rating, from 0 - retarded, I rate the statement Potato.

Powered right from your USB port!  Oh the clusterfuck that ensued when someone noticed a barrel jack on one of their  media/press releases.
legendary
Activity: 1652
Merit: 1067
Christian Antkow
The test software was returning unexpected results which turned out to be a bug in the testing software and has been (and is being) rewritten from scratch.
I'm no Software Engineer, but can some one give me a rating on the scale of 0 - retarded for this here statement?

 If memory serves, I believe there was a similarly curious statement made back during their 65nm testing days when they recognized they blew their power consumption numbers by at least a factor of two, that resulted in the need to force a redesign of the housing for their entire product line, and the Minirig being broken up into three separate units.

 Remember with the Jalapeno was supposed to be a flat and thin coffee warmer originally ?

 As for a rating, from 0 - retarded, I rate the statement Potato.
full member
Activity: 191
Merit: 110
Did you guys seriously think you could have counted on BFL for shipping on time? SERIOUSLY?! C'mon.. stop kiddin' ya'selves! Cheesy

When you buy from BFL, you are buying a product that will be out-phased by the time it arrives on your doorstep. (aka: Paper-Weights)
legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
Lets see,600gh @ 350 watts.So,350 x 3=1050 watts  Cheesy  There ya go Josh,I did the math for you !!!!!!!!  Cool  Congrats!!!  Cheesy

Anyone got a bet going yet Huh  Grin

Probably ~1W/GH like everyone else who's got 28nm tech, or they could shit the bed like they did with the 65nm. 
legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
The test software was returning unexpected results which turned out to be a bug in the testing software and has been (and is being) rewritten from scratch.

I'm no Software Engineer, but can some one give me a rating on the scale of 0 - retarded for this here statement?
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 1001
A FREEEEE update from your favorite boy:





05 February 2014 Monarch Update

 Most subsystems (State, IO, frequency control, counters, etc) on the chip have been tested and passed. The engine tests are still ongoing. The test software was returning unexpected results which turned out to be a bug in the testing software and has been (and is being) rewritten from scratch, so testing of the engines is taking a little longer than expected. The current estimation is that we should be done testing the chip in the next few days. In the meantime, the packaged chips should be on their way to the testing facility, though I don't yet have tracking numbers or confirmation of this. I will be working on getting that today or tomorrow hopefully.

 Once the packaged chips arrive at the testing facility, they will wire it up to the test harness and start conducting the full power tests to see just how far we might be able to push the chips and what their real world power consumption is.

Lets see,600gh @ 350 watts.So,350 x 3=1050 watts  Cheesy  There ya go Josh,I did the math for you !!!!!!!!  Cool  Congrats!!!  Cheesy

Anyone got a bet going yet Huh  Grin
hero member
Activity: 560
Merit: 500
StayFocus and LIVE
A FREEEEE update from your favorite boy:





05 February 2014 Monarch Update

 Most subsystems (State, IO, frequency control, counters, etc) on the chip have been tested and passed. The engine tests are still ongoing. The test software was returning unexpected results which turned out to be a bug in the testing software and has been (and is being) rewritten from scratch, so testing of the engines is taking a little longer than expected. The current estimation is that we should be done testing the chip in the next few days. In the meantime, the packaged chips should be on their way to the testing facility, though I don't yet have tracking numbers or confirmation of this. I will be working on getting that today or tomorrow hopefully.

 Once the packaged chips arrive at the testing facility, they will wire it up to the test harness and start conducting the full power tests to see just how far we might be able to push the chips and what their real world power consumption is.
legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000

Sorry Dropt, even the biggest troll i don't ignore....except you, cheers  Kiss

Nice try bubs.  If you had me on ignore you wouldn't have seen that I quoted you and edited out your stupidity.  Good to see you're still out there lying.
hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 500

Sorry Dropt, even the biggest troll i don't ignore....except you, cheers  Kiss
hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 500
Inaba thanks for BLOCKING ME... you CANT handle a little customer feed back Huh You delay customers shipments and then you dont bless them with some money or and extra rig. You should learn from Cointerra, at less they are trying to make it up to the customers.

Sorry people unfortunate I wont be able to update you any more :/  Tongue Embarrassed Lips sealed Undecided Cry Sad Angry Shocked Smiley Wink Cheesy Roll Eyes


Didn't you post this same picture a couple weeks ago with the same complaint?

This weirdo post the same thing over and over...
Truly a psychiatric case.
legendary
Activity: 1512
Merit: 1000
hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 500
The image is loading fine for me.  Bitcointalk blocks the image from loading.

 - image: http://i.imgur.com/JoJXtig.jpg


Thanks for the update

Looks like some old core memory in a cheap Chinese screwdriver set box.



Cheap that is definitely a design goal at BFL.

How your PCB design is Mr Bick ?
Because the WASP is just a PCB in fact...still designing for Bitfury chips While others (marto, barntech, etc,etc ) have done this age ago...
What a joke...
Come back when you are able to design even a 110nm chips.
hero member
Activity: 924
Merit: 1000
The image is loading fine for me.  Bitcointalk blocks the image from loading.

 - image: http://i.imgur.com/JoJXtig.jpg


Thanks for the update

Looks like some old core memory in a cheap Chinese screwdriver set box.



Cheap that is definitely a design goal at BFL.
hero member
Activity: 532
Merit: 500
Inaba thanks for BLOCKING ME... you CANT handle a little customer feed back Huh You delay customers shipments and then you dont bless them with some money or and extra rig. You should learn from Cointerra, at less they are trying to make it up to the customers.

Sorry people unfortunate I wont be able to update you any more :/  Tongue Embarrassed Lips sealed Undecided Cry Sad Angry Shocked Smiley Wink Cheesy Roll Eyes


Didn't you post this same picture a couple weeks ago with the same complaint?
legendary
Activity: 4690
Merit: 1276
The image is loading fine for me.  Bitcointalk blocks the image from loading.

 - image: http://i.imgur.com/JoJXtig.jpg


Thanks for the update

Looks like some old core memory in a cheap Chinese screwdriver set box.

hero member
Activity: 560
Merit: 500
StayFocus and LIVE
Inaba thanks for BLOCKING ME... you CANT handle a little customer feed back Huh You delay customers shipments and then you dont bless them with some money or and extra rig. You should learn from Cointerra, at less they are trying to make it up to the customers.

Sorry people unfortunate I wont be able to update you any more :/  Tongue Embarrassed Lips sealed Undecided Cry Sad Angry Shocked Smiley Wink Cheesy Roll Eyes

hero member
Activity: 560
Merit: 500
StayFocus and LIVE
The image is loading fine for me.  Bitcointalk blocks the image from loading.



[/quote

Thanks for the update
hero member
Activity: 784
Merit: 1004
Glow Stick Dance!
The image is loading fine for me.  Bitcointalk blocks the image from loading.


erk
hero member
Activity: 826
Merit: 500

How strange I wonder why he blocked that? I did test is after posting here, it's been blocked by BFL mod since.

Here is the thread post with it:

https://forums.butterflylabs.com/monarch-discussion/7741-2014-jan-27-monarch-discussion-2.html#post75994

Pages:
Jump to: