Pages:
Author

Topic: Bitcoin Foundation Final Debate - page 2. (Read 2786 times)

legendary
Activity: 1764
Merit: 1002
September 15, 2013, 03:41:00 AM
#6
way to go Andreas.  the whole thing was well done.

great moderating.
donator
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1015
September 15, 2013, 02:06:35 AM
#5
Wow. Ironically, the replies in this thread have finally convinced me to pay up and join out of worry there may be one big international blob heavily influencing Bitcoin development. Congrats, theymos. Huh

Will listen to debate and determine if fear is justified. ETA: Writing up a transcript, too - because why the fuck don't these people do transcripts? Seriously. Wtf.

ETA: The message exceeds the maximum allowed length (64000 characters). Yikes!
donator
Activity: 213
Merit: 100
September 15, 2013, 01:37:37 AM
#4
My personal take on the final debate, as posted to the Foundation forum:

Just finished listening to the recording. Good stuff. In my view, Joerg and Trace gave the strongest impressions, just about tied, but Ben also did a good job (all the more so given the raspy throat, which can't have been pleasant, as Adam noted).

The debate formed clearly around a big divide (to a first approximation coincident with the Atlantic?) regarding the necessity to internationalize the Foundation, and I suspect the votes next week may fall not dissimilarly—with Joerg and Trace on the one side, and largely Ms. Ploshay on the other.

As Joerg pointed out in the debate, what's at stake here is whether, going forward, this Foundation is to become the global umbrella organization for the Bitcoin universe, or merely remain a perceptibly U.S.-centered "Big Bitcoin" business club. If the Foundation's ~40% U.S.-based electorate should fail to look outward in this election, another organization will soon enough fill that void and the international relevancy of this Foundation will diminish accordingly and appropriately.

I know that a bunch of people over here in the Old World are just itching to make that happen, but I'd personally rather see this Foundation salvaged and repurposed towards better ends, as Jon Matonis is as ideal an appointment for an outwards-looking Executive Director as anyone could hope for. In any case, the electorate's decisions next week will be revelatory and significant.

Kudos to Adam, Andreas, and everyone else involved in producing the debate. Tips sent for both production & moderation.
administrator
Activity: 5222
Merit: 13032
September 15, 2013, 12:49:22 AM
#3
Wow, that was a really good debate! All of the candidates did very well. Much better than any debate I've seen.

Joerg and Trace seem to want the Foundation to be in charge of development at some level, which I find very dangerous for any legally-defined organization to do.  I'd prefer the Foundation to be totally uninvolved in Bitcoin-Qt development and focus more on legal stuff, behaving more like the NRA or EFF. It'd also dangerous for one US-based Foundation to act as some sort of oversight organization for many Bitcoin Foundations worldwide; the Foundation should help international organizations, but each organization should be separate in order to maximize decentralization. Elizabeth said some nice things in these areas.

I wish someone would have corrected Trace when he was complaining about the Foundation taking money from people and then removing them from bitcoin.org: The Foundation has nothing to do with bitcoin.org, so this is a ridiculous complaint.

I liked most of what Elizabeth, Ben, and Luke said here. I'd be satisfied if any of them won, though I think that Elizabeth is the best candidate.
legendary
Activity: 2786
Merit: 1031
September 14, 2013, 09:16:47 PM
#2
Thanks for sharing.
sr. member
Activity: 434
Merit: 254
Editor-in-Chief of Let's Talk Bitcoin!
September 14, 2013, 09:09:43 PM
#1
On Saturday, September 14th at 11am California time the Bitcoin Foundation Individual Seat Finalist Debate was recorded live on the Let’s Talk Bitcoin voice server.

The five remaining candidates answered a series of questions about the future of the foundation offered by both the moderator and the other candidates, who were allowed to converse and question each other.

Sponsored By:
The Bitcoin Foundation

Moderator:
Andreas M. Antonopoulos

Participating Candidates:
Elizabeth Ploshay
Trace Mayer
Ben Davenport
Joerg Platzer
Luke Dashjr


Official Timekeeper:
David Perry

Music Provided By:
Jared Rubens (@jaredarubens)

Producer:
Adam B. Levine

Tips for the Moderator
1andreas3batLhQa2FawWjeyjCqyBzypd

Tips for the Production
1QJ7xL3aYoVpVKLPnWzj1VByuyzsawBSjh
Pages:
Jump to: