Topic: bitcoin unconfirmed 6 days - can't do CPFP says mempool too large. (Read 293 times)

As I said above, the combined effective fee rate for these three transactions was 82.8 sats/vbyte, which is now far above the required fee of 50 sats/vbyte which is being processed, as it seems the hashrate had picked up again in the last day or two and the backlog is starting to clear. Indeed, OP's transaction and its two unconfirmed parents all confirmed in the same block around 18 hours ago.

I can try to help, but first you need to send me your transaction ID to find out what fee is set on the previous two transactions on which your transaction actually depends. If it is not less than 10 sat/byte it will take time, but it is feasible.

Yes, that's exactly what would happen. The default_mempool_expiry time is set to 336 hours, which is 14 days. This means that most nodes will drop transactions which remain unconfirmed after 14 days from their mempool. If the transaction is dropped from the mempool, then the bitcoin are effectively returned to the sender's address and they can do what they like with them. The way to avoid this from happening is to keep rebroadcasting the transaction (and its unconfirmed parents) until they are all confirmed.

ok just make sure my btc wont just drop off and get returned if it doesnt confirm too long would it?

Those are just rebroadcasting services, they do nothing to confirm your transaction, they are not mining blocks, and don't have a deal with mining pools. In short, they are useless.
As for the waiting period, it's not going to be that long.


There are chances it's going to be sooner than that, all signs point to mining having resumed in china, 143 blocks in the last 24h hours yesterday at around the same hour, and 140 now, the fee required for confirmation has also dropped a lot, we were in the 200+ area and now we even dropped to 100sat/b last night, the weekend is coming so if the overall fee is indeed 82sat/b assuming nothing major happens there are some chances it will get included late Sunday/early Monday.
The distance from the top went down for an 80sat/b from 23M to just 9M in 24hours, the mempool is getting cleaned.

so i guess 7 days not enough i need to wait 1-2 weeks?
is there any other ones besides viabtc to confirm it
i tried btcnitro and bitaccelerate daily still doesnt get confirmed

You have to accelerate all the transactions your transaction depends on.

So if your tx is "third in chain" then it means that your tx parent's unconfirmed parent needs to be accelerated first.
Then wait unil that one is confirmed.
Then accelerate your tx unconfirmed parent. Then wait until it's confirmed.
Then accelerate your tx.

If you enter your tx at https://mempool.space you'll find easily which are the unconfirmed parents (go backwards via the red arrows from the left side)

ok i tracked it down theres 2 tx i found his wallet has unconfirmed
sent to me my tx unconfirmed

so theres 2 unconfirmed TX

i need to accerlate his first one then mine?

The deal is that your transaction is third in a chain of three unconfirmed transactions, meaning your transaction cannot confirm until the other two also confirm. With an effective fee rate of 82.8 sats/vbyte, it is unlikely to confirm any time soon.

None of the transactions are flagged as RBF so you cannot use that. Since your transaction has an unconfirmed parent, you will not be able to use ViaBTC's free accelerator. Your options are then as follows:

• Be patient and wait for the mempool to empty down to the required level, which will likely take a week or two.
• Accelerator the first transaction in the chain using ViaBTC's accelerator. Once it has been confirmed, accelerate the second one. Once it has been confirmed, accelerate your one (or more likely your one will have a high enough fee to confirm on its own at that point). This will be a difficult task.
• Perform a CPFP with the output. The output to your transaction has over 0.011 BTC in it. Whoever owns that output (be it you or someone you were paying) can perform a CPFP with it. However, since you will now be paying a fee for 4 transactions, the fee will be significant. (Assuming a 1-input-1-output legacy child transaction of 192 bytes, to reach a total fee rate of 200 sats/vbyte your CPFP transaction would need to pay a fee of 102,960 sats, which would work out to ~537 sats/vbyte.)

7 days unconfirmed
whats the deal could i pm someone my transaction id get this confirmed?

You are doing something wrong, or you are just out of luck - take a look at this post, and you will see that the thing works - and you can check that every transaction is confirmed by Via pool and has a very low fee.

I have offered a free service for those who have problems, for now I am waiting for the first customer

A transaction with a fee of 180 sats/vbyte made 6 days ago should have confirmed by now. The mempool has been well below this level multiple times in the last week, processing some transactions below 100 sats/vbyte. I suspect there is something else going on here that OP is unaware of, most likely an unconfirmed parent.

OP, if you want more accurate advice, then you need to share your transaction ID.

---

Edit: Actually, I have located the only transaction in the mempool which fits the size (191 bytes), fee (180.1 sats/vbyte), and time frame (6-7 days ago) which OP has given. It has an unconfirmed parent paying a fee of 31 sats/vbyte, which in turn has an unconfirmed parent also paying a fee of 31 sats/vbyte. In total, these three transactions have a size of 551 vbytes, and pay a fee of 45,640 sats, which works out to only 82.8 sats/vbyte, which is why OP's transaction is not confirming.

None of the three transations are flagged as RBF.

 I've successfully used the free service many times but if you're unlucky you can always pay ViaBTC using BCH to accelerate your BTC transaction.  You would have to sign up in order to do that which might not be desirable to some.

The bitcoin hashrate is now back to the level it was at a few weeks ago and fees are starting to go down a little bit. We are also getting close to the weekend and fees will go down even more. Your transaction has a high enough fee to be confirmed later today.

Position in mempool: 1.95 MB from tip

no luck tried twice on viabtc to accelerate submission beyond limit

It depends, the normal days are 14 days for bitcoin core, but this can be so confusing as some nodes may still pass the transactions to other nodes even when you think the transaction is no more in mempool, and also are cases of transactions that can be confirmed in 30 days or more (I even had 1 that took 40 days recently before it confirmed without leaving the mempool). So, I can say there is no specific day for transaction to finally leave a mempool. Even, if wallet synchronized with the blockchain, they do automatically rebroadcaste transactions in the process.

For people to deal with stuck transactions, there are easy ways now, using segwit wallet is very important for low fee, but the most important is to use a wallet that support replace-by-fee for transactions, electrum wallet has all these. Also, taking advantage of when the mempool is not congested.

Expecting transaction to leave the mempool so that you can rebroadcaste it can be annoying, even if you do not sychronize the wallet with the blockchain for many days so that it will not automatically rebroadcaste the transaction again.

It is very possible, it is luck, there are some people that have acceleratated their transaction freely today, but The Pharmacist is also very right, the free acceleratation using ViaBTC only accept 100 transactions per hour, and compare it with plenty people that will be making use of it every hour in the world, that is why many transactions will not be acceleratated. But, it truly do work, especially if someone continuously trying, but it can be annoying.

 I just used it a couple of days back.  I had attached ~50 sat/byte fee (which was within 2 Megs from the top) but when I checked later on, that fee had increased to over 80 and my tx was still waiting in the pool.  I went to ViaBTC just before the hour and had my tx entered and ready to send on the hour.  No problems getting it through.  I only had to do one puzzle which was a single piece on the left which I had to slide to the right.  Then with my hands on my hips, I brought my knees in tight but it was the pelvic thrust that really drove me insane...

Awesome suggestions if you feel like looking at bunny rabbit puzzle captchas for hours on end--I've been trying to get a transaction accelerated on ViaBTC for two days and have had no luck whatsoever.  And believe me, I've tried more times than I could keep track of.

I've heard people say that doesn't happen anymore, but IIRC I've had it happen to me once or twice a few years ago.  In any case, I don't have the answer to that; I'm just hoping the network takes a big dose of a decongestant and starts moving again.  It's such a pain in the ass to use bitcoin at times like this.

Position in mempool: 1.48 MB from tip

this number changes time to time.

You can't spammed it providing the current traffic and request it receives.

Try to make it to the point that you are now ready seconds before the hour. My first one is about 3 seconds passed and my second is just around 10 seconds but it didn't goes through. That's how quick the request is filled.


Not technical about it but how long before the mempool gaves up a transaction, like it was a failed one. Or it does?