Topic: Bitcointalk.org collectible coin? - page 4. (Read 4674 times)
Come to think of it maybe a contest would be good idea too.
50-300 is fine.
If we do not state a definite upper limit then we run into a Sorites paradox, where n+1 is as good as n and hence we arbitrarily increase.
Wouldn't it make those 50-300 limited run coins more costly? If they are rare, these coins will surely be auctioned in future which shouldn't happen, since theymos has said that he offers these anniversary coins to only to few specific members based on certain criteria. Also, it would be good if those members were selected who has really contributed to the forum such as MODS, devs of epochtalk (probably just an idea), donators and other reputed guys roaming here. This shouldn't be handed over based on so called merit criteria since not all top merit receivers know about collectibles and their uniqueness actually.If we do not state a definite upper limit then we run into a Sorites paradox, where n+1 is as good as n and hence we arbitrarily increase.
I like the sound of this. We could have a design and print done rather quickly, and be ready to ship before the anniversary.
Your notes were always of the best quality right from the newly made 10 year Bitcoin note and the community would love to see how you bring out the note if it was for the forum anniversary. 
Until now I haven't even joined any of the many giveaways because I don't want to dox myself, but I might have to reconsider for this anniversary edition.
You could trust collectors like MJ, they are a lot more trustworthy than any one here and would help in even reshipping them to your address. I guess MJ has a separate warehouse (The Mantis warehouse) for his collections. 
We all know of some really experienced collectors and some amazing designers here, by pointing out who should design vs who should not is just not fair among designers.
My suggestion:
1. Create a small group of 10-15 EXPERIENCED and KNOWLEDGEABLE collectors as judges
2. All designers submit their designs to them.
3. After review they can choose whatever number of designs(maybe around 3-5) they choose and create the polls along with/without the prices for the community to choose the final design.
4. For distribution - that's little bit tricky and don't have any idea how to do that, i am sure one of the senior members can chime in new creative idea or probably some way that was used in one of the earlier auctions or sales.
After all this is a community anniversary coin that we are talking about and we should let community choose.
My suggestion:
1. Create a small group of 10-15 EXPERIENCED and KNOWLEDGEABLE collectors as judges
2. All designers submit their designs to them.
3. After review they can choose whatever number of designs(maybe around 3-5) they choose and create the polls along with/without the prices for the community to choose the final design.
4. For distribution - that's little bit tricky and don't have any idea how to do that, i am sure one of the senior members can chime in new creative idea or probably some way that was used in one of the earlier auctions or sales.
After all this is a community anniversary coin that we are talking about and we should let community choose.
I like this idea, a contest will be nice for this one.
I'd definitely like one!
Never mind Silver.
It seems only proper that any limited offering be minted on, at least 99%+ Au.
Bitcoin is ultimately looking to supplant Au.
It's poetic.
... personally, I would wish for Platinum, but recognize reality being what it is.
It seems only proper that any limited offering be minted on, at least 99%+ Au.
Bitcoin is ultimately looking to supplant Au.
It's poetic.
... personally, I would wish for Platinum, but recognize reality being what it is.
How about we make it from jade instead? And instead of the shape of the coin, we will make it the shape of your favorite green object.
4. For distribution - that's little bit tricky and don't have any idea how to do that, i am sure one of the senior members can chime in new creative idea or probably some way that was used in one of the earlier auctions or sales.
Im sure a lot of coin manufacturers know how to ship their coins to multiple people. For example Krogothmanhattan jhas given away hundreds of coins so far, by now I'd bet he has a lot of experience on the how of it.
We all know of some really experienced collectors and some amazing designers here, by pointing out who should design vs who should not is just not fair among designers.
My suggestion:
1. Create a small group of 10-15 EXPERIENCED and KNOWLEDGEABLE collectors as judges
2. All designers submit their designs to them.
3. After review they can choose whatever number of designs(maybe around 3-5) they choose and create the polls along with/without the prices for the community to choose the final design.
4. For distribution - that's little bit tricky and don't have any idea how to do that, i am sure one of the senior members can chime in new creative idea or probably some way that was used in one of the earlier auctions or sales.
After all this is a community anniversary coin that we are talking about and we should let community choose.
My suggestion:
1. Create a small group of 10-15 EXPERIENCED and KNOWLEDGEABLE collectors as judges
2. All designers submit their designs to them.
3. After review they can choose whatever number of designs(maybe around 3-5) they choose and create the polls along with/without the prices for the community to choose the final design.
4. For distribution - that's little bit tricky and don't have any idea how to do that, i am sure one of the senior members can chime in new creative idea or probably some way that was used in one of the earlier auctions or sales.
After all this is a community anniversary coin that we are talking about and we should let community choose.
Very interesting idea, following!
im in for several.
1 oz .999 silver is my preference.
1 oz .999 silver is my preference.
I'm not a collector, but a Bitcointalk coin somehow sounds very attractive. Until now I haven't even joined any of the many giveaways because I don't want to dox myself, but I might have to reconsider for this anniversary edition.
Getting a PO Box is a good way to prevent this.
Or sending it to a friend, which is what I plan to do. It's not like I need perfect opsec anyways.
legendary
Activity: 2520
Merit: 3238
The Stone the masons rejected was the cornerstone.
I'm not a collector, but a Bitcointalk coin somehow sounds very attractive. Until now I haven't even joined any of the many giveaways because I don't want to dox myself, but I might have to reconsider for this anniversary edition.
Getting a PO Box is a good way to prevent this.
I'm not a collector, but a Bitcointalk coin somehow sounds very attractive. Until now I haven't even joined any of the many giveaways because I don't want to dox myself, but I might have to reconsider for this anniversary edition.
I’d also be willing to offer my engraving services, but am not sure that private keys known by an individual would be a great idea.
BIP38 can limit the risk, if only the receiver knows the password and the encrypted key gets engraved. 
just curious what's gonna come out of this
Will be watching this thread closely. I'd throw my hat in the ring, sounds like an awesome project. Competition could be a great way to go about choosing a design.
I agree on the competition, great idea.
Damn I first thought it is a normal user initiative, that would be great to see, and i would rather pay a bit and have it silver .
Edit: Perhaps a bitcoin chart ? I mean for one side of the coin.
.Edit: Perhaps a bitcoin chart ? I mean for one side of the coin.
Will be watching this thread closely. I'd throw my hat in the ring, sounds like an awesome project. Competition could be a great way to go about choosing a design.
A small run of a coin is obviously more costly than a larger one. It seems part of the idea of Theymos is to give the coin for free to some members that deserve it according to a not-yet-specified criteria. Probably a small group, more so if the coin features/quality make it costly.
Also that would leave many people interested "out of the deal".
Maybe the solution is to make a larger run, thus reducing the premium, and some people get it for free and the rest can buy it at cost? Also it is unknown where and how much the money going to cover the cost of the free coins is coming from. Another possibility is that there is a small surcharge on the paid coins to cover the cost of the free ones.
That would probably make a better coin be produced than if the budget was more restricted (ie. only free run).
Win-Win for everyone?
Also I would think a cool feature for a coin like this would be to have engraved (no holo) the nickname and or a user supplied public key (not a private one - not your keys, not your bitcoins you know). That would raise the sentimental value and meaning of the coin for forum members, and also substantially reduce the resell market of it.
Just some random ideas...
Also that would leave many people interested "out of the deal".
Maybe the solution is to make a larger run, thus reducing the premium, and some people get it for free and the rest can buy it at cost? Also it is unknown where and how much the money going to cover the cost of the free coins is coming from. Another possibility is that there is a small surcharge on the paid coins to cover the cost of the free ones.
That would probably make a better coin be produced than if the budget was more restricted (ie. only free run).
Win-Win for everyone?
Also I would think a cool feature for a coin like this would be to have engraved (no holo) the nickname and or a user supplied public key (not a private one - not your keys, not your bitcoins you know). That would raise the sentimental value and meaning of the coin for forum members, and also substantially reduce the resell market of it.
Just some random ideas...
In my opinion Mike should do the coin. Cas coins are nr. 1, great design, flawless mint.
Perhaps do a combination of 1000 gold and 0.1 silver
☞ 0.1 BTC gold coin!
https://en.bitcoin.it/w/images/en/0/0b/Casascius_1000_BTC_gold_round.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/wabco7x.jpg?1
Perhaps do a combination of 1000 gold and 0.1 silver
☞ 0.1 BTC gold coin!
https://en.bitcoin.it/w/images/en/0/0b/Casascius_1000_BTC_gold_round.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/wabco7x.jpg?1
This sounds like an awesome idea! Really hope it works out.
With regards to the design, I personally find the simpler but distinct ones to be a lot more appealing. It would be pretty cool if the coin design was linked to bitcointalk not just explicitly, but also contained some sort of hidden/secret message. Just a thought.
With regards to the design, I personally find the simpler but distinct ones to be a lot more appealing. It would be pretty cool if the coin design was linked to bitcointalk not just explicitly, but also contained some sort of hidden/secret message. Just a thought.
- Does this sound like a good idea?
Im been waiting for that idea. for commemorating bitcointalk.org's 10th anniversary. - What features would make the coin especially interesting?
- Gets the value on the coin.- Unique Number (#Limited).
- Certificate, maybe.
- What's the best way to get a coin like this made?
That is definitely a rare collection coin. But let's be fair, I suggest the lottery or raffle mode.Let's do some vote
Jump to: