Author

Topic: [CLOSED-refunds process]Avalon - Chips group buy order time frame and deliveries (Read 11054 times)

full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
We may disagree about it, but my personal opinion as Avalon offered refund is that Yifu is off the hook.
This thread was created for a reason to show how orders are being late and to measure it, and now when refund is offered it means Avalon contacted us in try to undo their wrongs and we had choice to make. It doesn't mean all disputes are solved, all refunds are received, it means they are listening and reacting. I am sure at the end all refunds will be received, and still it will left bitter taste in our mouth knowing it could be allot better with little more effort.

Those who don't want to be dealing with Avalon, are free to make such a choice, but I see Avalon will fix many of their mistakes in next generation chips.
Did they made all mistakes intentionally or not, we can speculate. Should they compensate at least to people who suffered losses because of their broken promises? If I would have funds I would compensate or donate to those customers of Avalon rig batch #3 and to those who put so much effort to design and produce working boards based on Avalon chips like burnin and  bkkcoins. On other hand Avalon isn't obligated to do so, as they never promised you will be making money.

I am closing this thread now when refunds are granted, this thread have no meaning anymore.
Thanks to all that helped getting wider picture of colossal fail and cluster*ck these Avalon chips deliveries have been.
sr. member
Activity: 449
Merit: 250
hero member
Activity: 924
Merit: 1000
"Off" the hook?

Not until everyone of his customers is properly refunded or compensated.

I would suggest the community to refrain from doing any further business with him and his company until there is clear evidence that he he has addressed the woefully inadequate communication / customer service. He will certainly be on the hook for some time to come given there a still hundreds of thousands of dollars or product to be delivered or refunded.

Some people have been compensated but let us not give praise just yet if at all.
member
Activity: 83
Merit: 10
When refund is offered for chips shipments that were delayed, once we accept refund or carry on with waiting for delivery, Avalon and Yifu did their parts to undo (at least partly) wrongs they did.

I agree on the partly, but not that they've done their part.

I've explained how losing your place in queue is adding one wrong to another, and that by refunding the first batches before the later ones (or if you display it as such), you're letting Avalon off easy, and allowing this mess to be partly swept under the rug. You appear to be disagreeing with me, but offering no real argument to support your point.

Quote from: tiros
Anyway since chips from various buyers and batches are mixed now, batch number have no meaning anymore.

Mixed how?

Quote from: tiros
Yifu is of the hook now, as he did right thing.

I most certainly disagree about the "off the hook" part. He's taken one step in the right direction.

Anyway, if you still disagree with me, perhaps the most neutral way to display things will be to show the refunds separately, and not assign them to individual orders in your OP? Then readers can draw their own conclusions.

Quote from: tiros
Could it been better? It probably could, but we don't have all the info and know stuff that were happening behind closed doors so all we can do is to guess.
Now one thing remains and that is for Yifu to process refund request and give BTC back. He did so for few batches, but zefir didn't got his and right now he is refunding his customers out of his own pocket.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
It would be nice if this list could track refund status.
I think 3 of SebastianJu group buys have been refunded.


I will be adding refunds in OP.
Refunds will be noted in a way - first in, first out - so shipping delay can be calculated fairly.

tiros, thanks for putting this together. I do agree that refund requests and completion should be tracked in the OP.

However, I don't think that FIFO is the fair way to do it. Seems like it's letting Yifu off easy--which appears to be what's he's trying to make happen.

Suppose you had two spots in Avalon's queue (among many other buyers), and Yifu says, "sorry we're delayed, you'll have to give up your first spot (refund), but keep your second," (EDIT: which is behind many other buyers) would you really think that was fair? The buying should remain FIFO (first-come, first served); thus the refunds should be LIFO. This also shows the full extent of the delay, which I think is appropriate.

When refund is offered for chips shipments that were delayed, once we accept refund or carry on with waiting for delivery, Avalon and Yifu did their parts to undo (at least partly) wrongs they did.
Anyway since chips from various buyers and batches are mixed now, batch number have no meaning anymore.

Yifu is of the hook now, as he did right thing.
Could it been better? It probably could, but we don't have all the info and know stuff that were happening behind closed doors so all we can do is to guess.
Now one thing remains and that is for Yifu to process refund request and give BTC back. He did so for few batches, but zefir didn't got his and right now he is refunding his customers out of his own pocket.
member
Activity: 83
Merit: 10
It would be nice if this list could track refund status.
I think 3 of SebastianJu group buys have been refunded.


I will be adding refunds in OP.
Refunds will be noted in a way - first in, first out - so shipping delay can be calculated fairly.

tiros, thanks for putting this together. I do agree that refund requests and completion should be tracked in the OP.

However, I don't think that FIFO is the fair way to do it. Seems like it's letting Yifu off easy--which appears to be what's he's trying to make happen.

Suppose you had two spots in Avalon's queue (among many other buyers), and Yifu says, "sorry we're delayed, you'll have to give up your first spot (refund), but keep your second," (EDIT: which is behind many other buyers) would you really think that was fair? The buying should remain FIFO (first-come, first served); thus the refunds should be LIFO. This also shows the full extent of the delay, which I think is appropriate.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner

*** FYI ***

Quote
Avalon ASIC
Chips Delivery Update, September Edition

Due to events outside of our control, the delivery of chips have been delayed so far. While the situation are improving and chips are shipping, we have ultimately decided to revert our policy on no refunds and offer the option for customers to request a full refund(in bitcoin) if so desired.

The link to the request form is below, please note this only applies to orders made earlier than June 1st.

In other news, for those who decided to wait or wish to know more about delivery schedule will be glad to note we are receiving a batch of 400,000+ chips on Wednesday, with that we expect to be in good shape for meeting the upcoming deadlines of chip deliveries for orders made in June and later.

In addition, we hope to wrap up generation one, finish shipping the chips, construct the modules and build the 2 module Avalon mini, put this pre-order mess behind us in general and switch gear into 55nm production, tape out generation 3, and start work on improving chip design for generation 4. Only sell what we can produce in a day on the assembly line, and only what's in stock.


Best Regards!!! Grin
-anykeywhy-

Thanks, I got it also.


It would be nice if this list could track refund status.
I think 3 of SebastianJu group buys have been refunded.


I will be adding refunds in OP.
Refunds will be noted in a way - first in, first out - so shipping delay can be calculated fairly.
sr. member
Activity: 378
Merit: 250
It would be nice if this list could track refund status.
I think 3 of SebastianJu group buys have been refunded.
sr. member
Activity: 392
Merit: 250

*** FYI ***

Quote
Avalon ASIC
Chips Delivery Update, September Edition

Due to events outside of our control, the delivery of chips have been delayed so far. While the situation are improving and chips are shipping, we have ultimately decided to revert our policy on no refunds and offer the option for customers to request a full refund(in bitcoin) if so desired.

The link to the request form is below, please note this only applies to orders made earlier than June 1st.

In other news, for those who decided to wait or wish to know more about delivery schedule will be glad to note we are receiving a batch of 400,000+ chips on Wednesday, with that we expect to be in good shape for meeting the upcoming deadlines of chip deliveries for orders made in June and later.

In addition, we hope to wrap up generation one, finish shipping the chips, construct the modules and build the 2 module Avalon mini, put this pre-order mess behind us in general and switch gear into 55nm production, tape out generation 3, and start work on improving chip design for generation 4. Only sell what we can produce in a day on the assembly line, and only what's in stock.
[/quote]

Best Regards!!! Grin
-anykeywhy-
member
Activity: 98
Merit: 10
This:

REFUNDS for CHIPS... when?



and this:

If these were really shipping at 40-50k daily more group buys would have received shipping notification by this point... (Zefir batch 3 and batch 4).
sr. member
Activity: 378
Merit: 250
I am afraid you might be right.
Maybe it did not make sense to manufacture the 110 nm chips since the 55 nm chips are so close to delivery.
legendary
Activity: 974
Merit: 1000
As group-buy organizer and large-scale buyer I would like to suggest you several options to compensate chip-buyers for the late delivery:
a) refund: no chips, full refund
b) compensation in BTC: deliver chips, compensate XX% of the initial price
c) compensation in chips: deliver chips, add YY% more chips as compensation
d) compensation by upgrades: no chips, convert orders to next-gen chip orders

I'm glad the group buyer leaders are more understanding.

a) I am very open to this, this is what I suggest.
b) I am not a fan of this, on a principle level I rather do a full refund. plus, I rather sell the chips once we have them in hand at a discount, instead of letting people wait.( which is about the same as doing a partial refund in my opinion.)
c) this will not be good, as you know the chips isn't going to get here any faster, and ordering more would run into more delays ( this is the worst option, do not offer.)
d) while in theory this option sounds the best for us right? we keep the money, tout our gen2/3/4 chips and etc etc, but reality is we want to stay away from all pre-orders in the future. as you can imagine, all the problems, rumors and just about everything is caused by the fact we took pre-orders, and we will no longer be doing this.

you are welcome to post this in your thread.
sr. member
Activity: 378
Merit: 250
If these were really shipping at 40-50k daily more group buys would have received shipping notification by this point... (Zefir batch 3 and batch 4).
I am thinking the same thing.
It would be nice to get a realistic update on when to expect batch arrivals.
member
Activity: 61
Merit: 10
If these were really shipping at 40-50k daily more group buys would have received shipping notification by this point... (Zefir batch 3 and batch 4).
legendary
Activity: 1470
Merit: 1000
Want privacy? Use Monero!
an idea for the spreadsheet:

Maybe also add a colum 'Asked for refund' and 'Refund received' ?

So we can track the orders that need delivery Smiley
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Looks like group buy organizers will get their chance to get refund on delayed deliveries as per Yifu's say or chance to choose what to do.

FYI

Dear BitSyncom,

I organized one of the first group-buys for Avalon ASICs with a total of 80k chips during the second half of April. I already received the first two orders, and while they arrived later than agreed, I understand the difficulties you faced with delivery and am happy to have enabled some DIY projects to produce boards with an expected break-even potential.

With the further delays and the recent development in the mining market, we already passed the point where your chips will ever see a ROI. While the accelerated development of next-gen ASICs and the resulting increase in difficulty is every miners' risk issue, the delay is not. Decision to order the chips was based on your ToS giving a 9-10 weeks delivery time, and with the remaining orders being late for at least 8 weeks you for sure are aware that the chips lost their chance to make back their investment.

As you can imagine, all users desperately waiting for their chips are becoming more and more impatient. I personally have ~200 very sad and upset people in my group-buy and I feel very desperate and helpless not being able to do anything about it.

Yifu, it is only some months ago where you have been one of the most respected and honored person in Bitcoinland. I strongly believe that all this mess is a result of issues out of your control. Nevertheless with power comes responsibility, and now it is on you to take responsibility for the masses of folks out there who put serious amount of coins into your chips. If you really care about Bitcoin and its community, you can't just stand there and watch how disappointed users leave the scene.

As group-buy organizer and large-scale buyer I would like to suggest you several options to compensate chip-buyers for the late delivery:
a) refund: no chips, full refund
b) compensation in BTC: deliver chips, compensate XX% of the initial price
c) compensation in chips: deliver chips, add YY% more chips as compensation
d) compensation by upgrades: no chips, convert orders to next-gen chip orders

Would you be willing and capable to consider those suggestions? If so, I'd be glad to negotiate between my group-buyers and you to reach some agreement acceptable for both sides. Also, I would include other group-buy organizers to come to a generic agreement. For the sake of Bitcoin, please come back to me and let's bring this, that poisoned the community already enough, to an end.


Best Regards
zefir

I'm glad the group buyer leaders are more understanding.

a) I am very open to this, this is what I suggest.
b) I am not a fan of this, on a principle level I rather do a full refund. plus, I rather sell the chips once we have them in hand at a discount, instead of letting people wait.( which is about the same as doing a partial refund in my opinion.)
c) this will not be good, as you know the chips isn't going to get here any faster, and ordering more would run into more delays ( this is the worst option, do not offer.)
d) while in theory this option sounds the best for us right? we keep the money, tout our gen2/3/4 chips and etc etc, but reality is we want to stay away from all pre-orders in the future. as you can imagine, all the problems, rumors and just about everything is caused by the fact we took pre-orders, and we will no longer be doing this.

you are welcome to post this in your thread.

How fast those refund will be processed is another question having in mind that not many (I know for only one) refund for Avalon batch #3 miner was processed. Today also it came to Yifu's knowledge (as he says) that those Avalon batch #3 miners refunds has not been processed and he will be working hard to accelerate that process.

ok. this is pretty stupid of me, and completely my fault.

the system is designed to move cold storage to hot wallet -> then send out refunds.

but apparently the move failed and the script tried to send a bunch of refunds while the input contained no coins...

1000 coins have been moved and script resumed, I'm sure people should see refunds instantly and can vouch. and once I get back on location I can enable more coins to be moved and thus refund resumed.

again, I apologize for the long delay.

Not sure but if refunds get stuck in customsTM it's going to be a problem. Tongue

so all the refunds went out, aside from 2 orders which bugged out for whatever reason, and is looking into it now, those are 6997 and 6817.

To be honest I was surprised to see people logging in and saying they got their refund. Well, I didn't doubt that refund would be processed but also didn't expect such a speed. Looks at Yifu being so responsive is so nice to see.

Ok, now its time to decide what to do!
I would take the chips if exact shipping date (1-3 days precise) is near or few days from now, otherwise refund. You can all imagine that Yifu could answer that question if he wold take a look at his orders backlog but I don't think he will because of the noise.

Confirmed by block chain.   Refund already has one confirmation.  Phew... That is a relief..

completely my fault there. I would visit forum more to see problems, but the noise...

Ok guys you know it now! All of us should blame the noise and keep quiet. Yifu's prerequisite for conducting healthy business is that you can't complain and make noise.
One would say he could ignore nasty comments that were out of line and answer to customers that placed few orders of Avalon chips, but noise was preventing him for doing so.

One who don't want to do something will find thousand of excuses not to do it, and one who want to do something will find thousand of ways to do it.
I look at such an issue as a matter of your own will to make an effort, and once if all resorts fail you, you can always reply on email or bloody support ticket.

Right now I guess we should all be thankful Yifu decided to reply to zefir and give us chance to decide are we going to wait for chips or grab our BTC back.
So to conclude this, thank you Yifu for finally doing the right thing and ask as for our opinion.


just wandering how come terrahash is not on this list

see here  https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=198489.3720

regards

He isn't on the list for a reason I don't know when he ordered chips. If you know just link to such post I will be happy to add it to OP.
I believe his order could be found in google spreed-sheet posted by paul3, but I have no way to identify it.
Thank you for your effort and time to post this info.

Regards,

tiros
member
Activity: 364
Merit: 10
Is this just for group buys?

with all due resect buddy, the title suggests just that...

Thanks, and I sincerely deserved that. Was just wondering if there was anyway to make the list incorporate the other 75 percent of the total order list. Without hijacking this thread of course. At this point in time the onus is no longer on group buy folks anymore is it?
hero member
Activity: 532
Merit: 500
Is this just for group buys?

with all due resect buddy, the title suggests just that...
member
Activity: 364
Merit: 10
Is this just for group buys?
member
Activity: 97
Merit: 10
just wandering how come terrahash is not on this list

see here  https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=198489.3720

regards
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Tread updated. Let me know if anything new appears.

I dont see any updates am i right ?

I am updating how many days passed from scheduled delivery of chips, status of shipment and adding any new group buys found with help of this community.
In that one last update only days passed has been updated.


Thanks once again Xialla!
legendary
Activity: 1470
Merit: 1000
Want privacy? Use Monero!
^Glad to see Big Time Coin receive his chips, if they're following chronological order that means Zefir's batch 3 is coming up and then raginazn's order is around the corner.

[sarcasm]WOOHOO!!!!   Grin Grin Grin Grin  PARTY !!!![/sarcasm]

I'm waiting for the chips in marto74's batch1...
full member
Activity: 177
Merit: 100
^Glad to see Big Time Coin receive his chips, if they're following chronological order that means Zefir's batch 3 is coming up and then raginazn's order is around the corner.

Big Time Coin's chips have a date code of 1332.  Thought it might have been 2013, work week #32.  In the unboxing thread, JimRome suggests "Assuming ISO8601 format, week 32 would translate to the week of August 5-11" which sounds much more accurate.  (rack him)

It appears the chips were sent out on Aug 21 from HKG, cleared customs on Aug 22, and could've been delivered as early as Aug 23, but they were delivered earlier today.
legendary
Activity: 1036
Merit: 1001
/dev/null
legendary
Activity: 1470
Merit: 1000
Want privacy? Use Monero!
I am in the process of contacting a chinese suplier at alibaba who is offering chips for 30 USD.
I also asked him about how it's possible he can deliver. If I have any info (I doubt it) I'll post it here!
sr. member
Activity: 281
Merit: 250
Tread updated. Let me know if anything new appears.

I dont see any updates am i right ?
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Tread updated. Let me know if anything new appears.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Thread updated and no new chips deliveries reported.
Yifu, ooooooooooo Yifu ...........  Angry
legendary
Activity: 1470
Merit: 1000
Want privacy? Use Monero!
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
hero member
Activity: 532
Merit: 500

Thanks! That was fast I'll admit.
Only few days passed since zefir received shipping confirmation.

Gridchip June;



Zephir Aug;

full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner

Thanks! That was fast I'll admit.
Only few days passed since zefir received shipping confirmation.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Really really nice work!


Actually TGB was sloppy and confused about the difference between a "Master Air Way Bill" and a "House Air Way Bill". One is the identifier for the whole delivery of the shipping company, the other one for each individual recipient. Both are visible on the parcels and they are labeled with n/24. The conclusion is obvious, I guess.

My estimate was 187200 chips and guaranteed less than 374400 chips. Order #3 with 200000 chips maybe?

Thank you Smiley
To be honest I didn't go in details checking the number. Maybe good way to find out is to know weight of one package alone?
I go by this logic; If they made a mistake and wrote 135 boxes how possible is to make two mistakes and write 853 kg for weight of shipment?
So it is 6.31kg per package if there was 135 boxes or 35.54kg per package if there was 24 boxes.
I believe Zefir can confirm what is the truth by letting us know what was the weight of package or what is the weight of one chip.
I am aware not only chips adds to package weight of course, but we can conclude pretty accurate was there 135 or 24 boxes.

Edit:update from zefir by PM
Quote from: zefir
I'd say the first is true - definitively below 8kg. I put one of the smaller packages on our kitchen scales: 3368 chips are 2.15 kg, so 6.5 for 10k chips is quite accurate.

So it looks like impossible to have two mistakes in one tracking form from shipping/forwarding company and based on weight we can conclude there was 135 boxes after all.

legendary
Activity: 1106
Merit: 1026
Really really nice work!


Actually TGB was sloppy and confused about the difference between a "Master Air Way Bill" and a "House Air Way Bill". One is the identifier for the whole delivery of the shipping company, the other one for each individual recipient. Both are visible on the parcels and they are labeled with n/24. The conclusion is obvious, I guess.

My estimate was 187200 chips and guaranteed less than 374400 chips. Order #3 with 200000 chips maybe?
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
List updated and some minor mistakes corrected.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Thanks for the work tiros. I made a spreadsheet out of your data in combination with the avalon payment address (1FGAftzSTztFSB8LMwsrdCKTyqGY6zr3sU).

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AiLYkKIHJaIsdHpIaGdUOWRYVUdncTNpNlVKbVhCbEE&usp=sharing

Info about the data in the spreadsheet:

Order: There are some payments that don't have the hole payment amount in one transaction, these have the same Order "ID". For example order 4 -> Payment 1: 700.6, Payment 2: 55, Payment 1: 26.5.

In total there are 54 orders, containing 97 * 10.000 Chips.

Group Buy Date didn't match payment date
1. There is no payment for SebastianJu Batch #2 on:
Code:
2013-05-18: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-27 ---> - 23 days

I added it to an order made on 2013-05-22. Anyway the bitcoins are still here 1ECoeDfK79CNm1Mzx6NMMkZrHVocwNg6Sp not transfered to the bitcoin address with 75k Bitcoins.

2. There are some group buys you have listed that don't show up on this bitcoin address. I added this group buys on the end of the table.

What do you think is this spreadsheet usefull? Are there any infos on other delivered batches?


Its correct, 4 of our batch payments went to the collecting address but one payment is still lying at the address i had to pay to at bitinstant, so its a bitinstant controlled address. I wonder why Yifu lets lying around so much bitcoins at a website since everybody knows how often it happens that a website goes scammy or dies or whatever. I dont feel very good when i know my bitcoins out at another website.

Only great master of Y(oda)ifu can answer that one, I guess.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
To clarify, being late can't be seen as a scam .... it's common knowledge.

But this is not being late, that is the issue.

What is common knowledge is taking product that was paid for, manufactured for and allocated to a specific set of customers, and reselling that product to another 2nd customer for a higher price, is illegal and fraudulent.

In this situation the group buy payments (millions of dollars) were used to secure manufacture of product from TSMC, Yifu then turned around and resold that paid for product to a higher bidder. That is plainly illegal.

Even if Yifu then takes this higher bidder funds to purchase another round of TSMC chips and deliver those, it is still illegal. Doubly so since the time value of the product has been destroyed. Yifu promised a time schedule and purposefully broke that to profit himself with zero compensation to customers.

So the statement that it's common knowledge that being late is OK, is both wrong and absurd in this case.



Can you prove your saying about selling to higher bidder? People and companies are being late all the time.


thank you for your effort to bring up all that we need in one place

thx again

no problem Smiley
member
Activity: 92
Merit: 10
thank you for your effort to bring up all that we need in one place

thx again
legendary
Activity: 2674
Merit: 1083
Legendary Escrow Service - Tip Jar in Profile
Thanks for the work tiros. I made a spreadsheet out of your data in combination with the avalon payment address (1FGAftzSTztFSB8LMwsrdCKTyqGY6zr3sU).

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AiLYkKIHJaIsdHpIaGdUOWRYVUdncTNpNlVKbVhCbEE&usp=sharing

Info about the data in the spreadsheet:

Order: There are some payments that don't have the hole payment amount in one transaction, these have the same Order "ID". For example order 4 -> Payment 1: 700.6, Payment 2: 55, Payment 1: 26.5.

In total there are 54 orders, containing 97 * 10.000 Chips.

Group Buy Date didn't match payment date
1. There is no payment for SebastianJu Batch #2 on:
Code:
2013-05-18: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-27 ---> - 23 days

I added it to an order made on 2013-05-22. Anyway the bitcoins are still here 1ECoeDfK79CNm1Mzx6NMMkZrHVocwNg6Sp not transfered to the bitcoin address with 75k Bitcoins.

2. There are some group buys you have listed that don't show up on this bitcoin address. I added this group buys on the end of the table.

What do you think is this spreadsheet usefull? Are there any infos on other delivered batches?


Its correct, 4 of our batch payments went to the collecting address but one payment is still lying at the address i had to pay to at bitinstant, so its a bitinstant controlled address. I wonder why Yifu lets lying around so much bitcoins at a website since everybody knows how often it happens that a website goes scammy or dies or whatever. I dont feel very good when i know my bitcoins out at another website.
legendary
Activity: 2674
Merit: 1083
Legendary Escrow Service - Tip Jar in Profile
Where are those 135 boxes of chips we saw?

STOP saying this. There were 24 boxes of chips, NOT 135.  The tracking number was for the entire shipment which included other items. The boxes were clearly labeled as 1/24, etc.   It was still 24 boxes of chips, but not nearly as many as people think it was.

What were these other items?
legendary
Activity: 1153
Merit: 1000
To clarify, being late can't be seen as a scam .... it's common knowledge.

But this is not being late, that is the issue.

What is common knowledge is taking product that was paid for, manufactured for and allocated to a specific set of customers, and reselling that product to another 2nd customer for a higher price, is illegal and fraudulent.

In this situation the group buy payments (millions of dollars) were used to secure manufacture of product from TSMC, Yifu then turned around and resold that paid for product to a higher bidder. That is plainly illegal.

Even if Yifu then takes this higher bidder funds to purchase another round of TSMC chips and deliver those, it is still illegal. Doubly so since the time value of the product has been destroyed. Yifu promised a time schedule and purposefully broke that to profit himself with zero compensation to customers.

So the statement that it's common knowledge that being late is OK, is both wrong and absurd in this case.

full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Ok, now something completely off topic.


Eight Signs to Help You Detect Whether Someone is Lying to You!
http://socyberty.com/psychology/eight-signs-to-help-you-detect-whether-someone-is-lying-to-you/
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
I think the main group buy organizers should band together and contact the FBI regarding this $10M scam. At this point it is clear that Yifu sold chips to the highest bidder destroying any future ROI for customers on chips he may or may not deliver. This is a larger scam than pirate and the government developed a case and took him down.

Engaging the government on illegal actions such as this only helps strengthen and legitimize Bitcoin.

Most people I know are into Bitcoin because it is a currency that the bankers can not debase and reward just themselves. That is a legitimate goal. We don't want to see Bitcoin turn into a den of thieves that only transfers abuse from bankers to guys like Yifu and pirate.


Maybe we also send ....



...... ?

To clarify, being late can't be seen as a scam .... it's common knowledge.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
I don't know can we/you manage to link all the orders with payments since there was no obligation for group buyers to buy from wallet address they used to collect funds, and some also used escrow?
SebastianJu' batch #2 was paid, and order status was changed to "chips ordered" as per Sebastian's OP, but I will let him know about this so we can "hear" what he "says" about it.
I have to clarify that I have full confident in Sebastian and I appreciate all the effort he did to justify his role as group buy leader, so if anything wrong happened I would see it as mistake and nothing more.

Oh, I think you understand me wrong, there is the payment for batch #2 -> https://blockchain.info/de/address/1ECoeDfK79CNm1Mzx6NMMkZrHVocwNg6Sp - it just doesn't show up on the "big" avalon payment address. There is a big gap on this addresse between 2013-05-11 14:57:58 and 2013-05-22 02:17:07. Seems there are actually more orders than the 97 batches on 1FGAftzSTztFSB8LMwsrdCKTyqGY6zr3sU.

my bad then Smiley , anyways I sent PM to Sebastian so he will probably reply later.
member
Activity: 99
Merit: 11
I don't know can we/you manage to link all the orders with payments since there was no obligation for group buyers to buy from wallet address they used to collect funds, and some also used escrow?
SebastianJu' batch #2 was paid, and order status was changed to "chips ordered" as per Sebastian's OP, but I will let him know about this so we can "hear" what he "says" about it.
I have to clarify that I have full confident in Sebastian and I appreciate all the effort he did to justify his role as group buy leader, so if anything wrong happened I would see it as mistake and nothing more.

Oh, I think you understand me wrong, there is the payment for batch #2 -> https://blockchain.info/de/address/1ECoeDfK79CNm1Mzx6NMMkZrHVocwNg6Sp - it just doesn't show up on the "big" avalon payment address. There is a big gap on this addresse between 2013-05-11 14:57:58 and 2013-05-22 02:17:07. Seems there are actually more orders than the 97 batches on 1FGAftzSTztFSB8LMwsrdCKTyqGY6zr3sU.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Thanks for the work tiros. I made a spreadsheet out of your data in combination with the avalon payment address (1FGAftzSTztFSB8LMwsrdCKTyqGY6zr3sU).

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AiLYkKIHJaIsdHpIaGdUOWRYVUdncTNpNlVKbVhCbEE&usp=sharing

Info about the data in the spreadsheet:

Order: There are some payments that don't have the hole payment amount in one transaction, these have the same Order "ID". For example order 4 -> Payment 1: 700.6, Payment 2: 55, Payment 1: 26.5.

In total there are 54 orders, containing 97 * 10.000 Chips.

Group Buy Date didn't match payment date
1. There is no payment for SebastianJu Batch #2 on:
Code:
2013-05-18: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-27 ---> - 23 days

I added it to an order made on 2013-05-22. Anyway the bitcoins are still here 1ECoeDfK79CNm1Mzx6NMMkZrHVocwNg6Sp not transfered to the bitcoin address with 75k Bitcoins.

2. There are some group buys you have listed that don't show up on this bitcoin address. I added this group buys on the end of the table.

What do you think is this spreadsheet usefull? Are there any infos on other delivered batches?


I don't know can we/you manage to link all the orders with payments since there was no obligation for group buyers to buy from wallet address they used to collect funds, and some also used escrow?
SebastianJu' batch #2 was paid, and order status was changed to "chips ordered" as per Sebastian's OP, but I will let him know about this so we can "hear" what he "says" about it.
I have to clarify that I have full confident in Sebastian and I appreciate all the effort he did to justify his role as group buy leader, so if anything wrong happened I would see it as mistake and nothing more.
legendary
Activity: 1153
Merit: 1000
I think the main group buy organizers should band together and contact the FBI regarding this $10M scam. At this point it is clear that Yifu sold chips to the highest bidder destroying any future ROI for customers on chips he may or may not deliver. This is a larger scam than pirate and the government developed a case and took him down.

Engaging the government on illegal actions such as this only helps strengthen and legitimize Bitcoin.

Most people I know are into Bitcoin because it is a currency that the bankers can not debase and reward just themselves. That is a legitimate goal. We don't want to see Bitcoin turn into a den of thieves that only transfers abuse from bankers to guys like Yifu and pirate.
member
Activity: 99
Merit: 11
Thanks for the work tiros. I made a spreadsheet out of your data in combination with the avalon payment address (1FGAftzSTztFSB8LMwsrdCKTyqGY6zr3sU).

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AiLYkKIHJaIsdHpIaGdUOWRYVUdncTNpNlVKbVhCbEE&usp=sharing

Info about the data in the spreadsheet:

Order: There are some payments that don't have the hole payment amount in one transaction, these have the same Order "ID". For example order 4 -> Payment 1: 700.6, Payment 2: 55, Payment 1: 26.5.

In total there are 54 orders, containing 97 * 10.000 Chips.

Group Buy Date didn't match payment date
1. There is no payment for SebastianJu Batch #2 on:
Code:
2013-05-18: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-27 ---> - 23 days

I added it to an order made on 2013-05-22. Anyway the bitcoins are still here 1ECoeDfK79CNm1Mzx6NMMkZrHVocwNg6Sp not transfered to the bitcoin address with 75k Bitcoins.

2. There are some group buys you have listed that don't show up on this bitcoin address. I added this group buys on the end of the table.

What do you think is this spreadsheet usefull? Are there any infos on other delivered batches?
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Great topic.. finally one place to check the status all the group buys..

Lets see if some chips show up "soon"...

Thanks, it is good to see people find it useful.


Very helpful. Will you be updating it daily?

I plan to.
legendary
Activity: 924
Merit: 1000
Think. Positive. Thoughts.
Very helpful. Will you be updating it daily?
sr. member
Activity: 349
Merit: 250
Great topic.. finally one place to check the status all the group buys..

Lets see if some chips show up "soon"...
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
From bizwoo GB
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/closed-avalon-chips-0082btc-k16-miner-assembly-60eur-200067


Batch 1
Order #10605 made on June 8, 2013. Order status: chips ordered. @20/06/2013
Batch 2
Order #11321 made on July 6, 2013. Order status: chips ordered. @08/07/2013


Thanks, added.

Great info! keep it up Roll Eyes

Thank you, I appreciate your comment Smiley

Well there is at least 60,000 chips ahead of steamboats group buy #1. Hopefully group buy #1 is included in the 130,000 chips shipped, but highly doubt it.

Probably not. Our orders are most likely tip of an iceberg.


Where are those 135 boxes of chips we saw?

STOP saying this. There were 24 boxes of chips, NOT 135.  The tracking number was for the entire shipment which included other items. The boxes were clearly labeled as 1/24, etc.   It was still 24 boxes of chips, but not nearly as many as people think it was.

Many tend to disagree with you on this mater.
And I dare to think that if you employee logic you will disagree with yourself also.

Where are those 135 boxes of chips we saw?

STOP saying this. There were 24 boxes of chips, NOT 135.  The tracking number was for the entire shipment which included other items. The boxes were clearly labeled as 1/24, etc.   It was still 24 boxes of chips, but not nearly as many as people think it was.

Ummm ... it is 135.  Unless 135 means 24 in which case the world is less sane than I thought it is:

http://www.track-shipments.com/track-trace.aspx?pref=AWB&awbno=87150508076

Quote
Most surprisingly, there is evidence that there were actually 135 boxes in the shipment that arrived for these photographs. This would indicate 593 TH/s at the standard 282 MH/s clock speed, or a monstrous 842 TH/s overclocked to 400 MH/s per chip. Given the high estimate, that would add almost 500% to the network speed.
(http://thegenesisblock.com/latest-shipment-of-avalon-asics-could-increase-network-hashrate-by-500/)

Marto74 Batch 1 ordered 17-June:

Order sent in (and fees, refunds etc sent): http://blockchain.info/tx/2fc131341eb95774aaa07d4e30b78e5488fb2d2f430dee14871455854fcec5e7

Order #10945 made on June 17, 2013.

Batch 2 ordered 06-July:

2-nd batch order
Quote
Order #11321 made on July 6, 2013. Order status: processing.


Thanks, added.

full member
Activity: 143
Merit: 100
So sexy, it hurts.
I'll be doing a review of chips group buy order date and deliveries concluding this day - 2013-08-18
+1
legendary
Activity: 966
Merit: 1000
Marto74 Batch 1 ordered 17-June:

Order sent in (and fees, refunds etc sent): http://blockchain.info/tx/2fc131341eb95774aaa07d4e30b78e5488fb2d2f430dee14871455854fcec5e7

Order #10945 made on June 17, 2013.

Batch 2 ordered 06-July:

2-nd batch order
Quote
Order #11321 made on July 6, 2013. Order status: processing.
member
Activity: 98
Merit: 10
Where are those 135 boxes of chips we saw?

STOP saying this. There were 24 boxes of chips, NOT 135.  The tracking number was for the entire shipment which included other items. The boxes were clearly labeled as 1/24, etc.   It was still 24 boxes of chips, but not nearly as many as people think it was.

Ummm ... it is 135.  Unless 135 means 24 in which case the world is less sane than I thought it is:

http://www.track-shipments.com/track-trace.aspx?pref=AWB&awbno=87150508076

Quote
Most surprisingly, there is evidence that there were actually 135 boxes in the shipment that arrived for these photographs. This would indicate 593 TH/s at the standard 282 MH/s clock speed, or a monstrous 842 TH/s overclocked to 400 MH/s per chip. Given the high estimate, that would add almost 500% to the network speed.
(http://thegenesisblock.com/latest-shipment-of-avalon-asics-could-increase-network-hashrate-by-500/)
legendary
Activity: 2198
Merit: 1000
legendary
Activity: 966
Merit: 1000
From ragingazn628's GB thread:

https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.1960159

10k chips ordered 27-April.
sr. member
Activity: 252
Merit: 250
Where are those 135 boxes of chips we saw?

STOP saying this. There were 24 boxes of chips, NOT 135.  The tracking number was for the entire shipment which included other items. The boxes were clearly labeled as 1/24, etc.   It was still 24 boxes of chips, but not nearly as many as people think it was.
sr. member
Activity: 266
Merit: 250
Well there is at least 60,000 chips ahead of steamboats group buy #1. Hopefully group buy #1 is included in the 130,000 chips shipped, but highly doubt it.
legendary
Activity: 2198
Merit: 1000
member
Activity: 98
Merit: 10
Call me impatient one, but here is what I think about it.



Pretty much this.  It's a clear disappointment with respect to someone who appeared to be a honest and a "no BS" kind of person.
full member
Activity: 504
Merit: 102
CLEARSIGHT- THE #1 BLOCKCHAIN JOB PLATFORM
From bizwoo GB
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/closed-avalon-chips-0082btc-k16-miner-assembly-60eur-200067


Batch 1
Order #10605 made on June 8, 2013. Order status: chips ordered. @20/06/2013
Batch 2
Order #11321 made on July 6, 2013. Order status: chips ordered. @08/07/2013
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
Just another miner
Hi,

just wanted to see where we stand in terms of Avalon chips deliveries. There is probably many more, but these are most known (at least to me).
I'll be doing a review of chips group buy order date and deliveries concluding this day - 2013-09-01:

Zefir - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/closed-avalon-asic-chip-distribution-177827
Code:
2013-04-30: Batch 7 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-09 ---> - 56 days
2013-04-30: Batch 6 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-09 ---> - 56 days
2013-04-28: Batch 5 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-07 ---> - 58 days
2013-04-24: Batch 4 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-03 ---> - 62 days
2013-04-20: Batch 3 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-06-29 ---> - 65 days
2013-04-18: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-06-27 - delivered - 2013-08-23 - 58 days late
2013-04-16: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-06-25 - delivered - 2013-07-24 - 29 days late
Big Time Coin - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cancelled-big-time-coin-selling-90-ghs-bitcoin-mining-devices-batch-a-180093
Code:
2013-04-17: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-06-26 - delivered - 2013-08-27 - 63 days late
ragingazn628 - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/group-buy2-avalon-asics-chips-1-chip-078btc-282mhash-189220
Code:
2013-04-27: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-06 ---> - 58 days
Steamboat - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/liquid-synergy-designs-inc-asic-mining-hardware-192916
Code:
2013-07-06: Batch 6 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-09-14 ---> + 14 days
2013-06-05: Batch 5 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-14 ---> - 18 days
2013-05-28: Batch 4 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-06 ---> - 27 days
2013-05-22: Batch 3 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-31 ---> - 33 days
2013-05-11: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-20 ---> - 44 days
2013-05-01: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-10 ---> - 54 days
SebastianJu' - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/group-buy-avalon-asic-chips-sebastianju-batch-6-ordered-closed-187660
Code:
2013-07-07: Batch 6 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-09-15 ---> + 15 days
2013-06-13: Batch 5 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-22 ---> - 10 days
2013-05-27: Batch 4 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-05 ---> - 28 days
2013-05-23: Batch 3 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-01 ---> - 32 days - refunded - 2013-09-01
2013-05-18: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-27 ---> - 36 days - refunded - 2013-09-01
2013-05-11: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-07-20 ---> - 43 days - refunded - 2013-09-01
t13hydra - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/closedavalon-chips-0081-btc-globalescrow-batch2-secured-189582   Sample chips unboxing  - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1FLE59Hzck
Code:
2013-06-30: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-15 ---> - 18 days
2013-05-23: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-01 ---> - 32 days
kslaughter
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.2370446
Code:
2013-06-01: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-10 ---> - 23 days
2013-05-28: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-06 ---> - 27 days
bizwoo - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/closed-avalon-chips-0082btc-k16-miner-assembly-60eur-200067
Code:
2013-07-08: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-09-16 ---> + 17 days
2013-06-08: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-17 ---> - 15 days
marto74 - https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/group-buy-avalon-chips-escrow-john-k-please-check-refund-list-until-sunday-217316
Code:
2013-07-06: Batch 2 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-09-14 ---> + 14 days
2013-06-17: Batch 1 ordered - Expected date of arrival (10 weeks) - 2013-08-26 ---> -   6 days

Total 230K of chips
190K are already late
40K still in time frame

When we sum up these ones being late as they are, 230K of chips that Avalon didn't deliver, and Yifu's stating "130K chips gone out", it is clear it will not cover just for these three groups of buyers.

at the moment of writing, another 130k chips have gone out, and will proceed to ship more as we get them. ( and no, they are not samples.)

Where are those 135 boxes of chips we saw?
http://thegenesisblock.com/latest-shipment-of-avalon-asics-could-increase-network-hashrate-by-500/

Maybe you think Yifu offered to clear all unanswered questions? Take a look and see for yourself.
http://avalon-asics.com/

Call me impatient one, but here is what I think about it.


New update from Avalon
http://avalon-asics.com/
Combined spreadsheet with the avalon payment address (1FGAftzSTztFSB8LMwsrdCKTyqGY6zr3sU).

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AiLYkKIHJaIsdHpIaGdUOWRYVUdncTNpNlVKbVhCbEE&usp=sharing

Info about the data in the spreadsheet:

Order: There are some payments that don't have the hole payment amount in one transaction, these have the same Order "ID". For example order 4 -> Payment 1: 700.6, Payment 2: 55, Payment 1: 26.5.

In total there are 54 orders, containing 97 * 10.000 Chips.


News letter from Avalon 2013-08-31
Anyhow, If people think I'm trying to screw the people who ordered from 15th to the 22th of June that is just silly, and false in their assumption. Here's the new deal,

The form will extend to orders made before the 22nd, which is exatly 10 weeks. and every order after, on the date it is suppose to ship, we'll send out a email asking if a refund is desired.

While I have no problems issue refunds, compensating for delay and such, I got no patience for people complaining when their orders are not late. Not too surprisingly, the people complaining the loudest are people whose order are not late yet(so more people refund and they can get their chips earlier maybe?), and people who have no orders(standard trolls of bitcointalk).

Most people who have chip orders are much more understanding to the situation, whom are either taking refunds, or working out some sort of compensation model.  

Showing himself in very positive light and doing what should be done, more then few batches were refunded immediately.
Thank you Yifu for doing the right thing and finally listening to your customers!

Refunds will be noted in a way - first in, first out - so shipping delay can be calculated fairly.
If you have more group buys with known status, link and day when ordered, just post them and I will add them to OP.
Jump to: