i prefer compact block. 
Topic: [Discussion] Blocks signalling SegWit Support - page 2. (Read 1280 times)
i prefer compact block. 
I think:
pool operators, Bitcoin core representatives, and all alternative Bitcoin implementations teams need to gather to discuss their concerns and come to a compromise. Otherwise Segwit won't be activated.
pool operators, Bitcoin core representatives, and all alternative Bitcoin implementations teams need to gather to discuss their concerns and come to a compromise. Otherwise Segwit won't be activated.
I think you're wrong.
There's no need to compromise with "big blockists", as Segwit introduces bigger blocks. Simple, huh?
Graph which you mentioned probably shows 2016 blocks average. 144 blocks average is more relevant now, since signalling begun much later than
no
the RULE. the CODE. the BIP is about 95% of 2016 blocks.. (not average of 24 hours)
yes and thats why the 20% is an opinion poll because the election has not been open long enough to have vote counts. but treating the opinion poll as the metric of activation and most important, is a failure of understanding.
as you say votes should be about 41-42%...... yet votes are at 8%
again blue line=opinion poll.. red line vote count.
there is nothing wrong with discussing opinion poll.. but atleast discuss it in the context of opinion rather than factual status of votes
Graph which you mentioned probably shows 2016 blocks average. 144 blocks average is more relevant now, since signalling begun much later than
no
the RULE. the CODE. the BIP is about 95% of 2016 blocks.. (not average of 24 hours)
Graph which you mentioned probably shows 2016 blocks average. 144 blocks average is more relevant now, since signalling begun much later than
no
the RULE. the CODE. the BIP is about 95% of 2016 blocks.. (not average of 24 hours)
the important thing is
https://blockchain.info/charts/bip-9-segwit
the other metric of "average" "24 hours".. is not important.. it is just a generalised thing.
much like presidential elections.
the important thing is the vote count. however people can talk about short term 'polls' that change daily to gain some insight as to the 'ifs' and 'maybes' but choosing to think of polls as more important then the actual vote count is ludicrous, especially if the poll changes from 25%-14% 26%-16% at any time. its not a worthy metric.
if anything
use this..
http://bitcoin.sipa.be/ver9-10k.png
and yes its made by the guy that done segwit. that shows the 2 figures together
the "poll" (short term opinion) in blue
the "votes" (actual results that the code/rules look at) in red
in short.
dont expect it by christmas
dont expect it by christmas
Graph which you mentioned probably shows 2016 blocks average. 144 blocks average is more relevant now, since signalling begun much later than 2016 blocks ago.
https://bitcoincore.org/en/segwit_adoption/
2016 blocks average won't go above ~20% unless shorter term average goes up.
I think pool operators, Bitcoin core representatives, and all alternative Bitcoin implementations teams need to gather to discuss their concerns and come to a compromise. Otherwise Segwit won't be activated.
https://bitcoincore.org/en/segwit_adoption/
2016 blocks average won't go above ~20% unless shorter term average goes up.
I think pool operators, Bitcoin core representatives, and all alternative Bitcoin implementations teams need to gather to discuss their concerns and come to a compromise. Otherwise Segwit won't be activated.
You can check the current percentage at : https://blockchain.info/charts/bip-9-segwit
Percentage is currently 8% which is low If we take in consideration that we need to have 95% but It's increasing daily, do you think we are going to reach it or there is no chance and SegWit won't be activated ?
It's an open discussion so feel free to say your opinion about the whole SegWit thing and not only about Signalling.
Percentage is currently 8% which is low If we take in consideration that we need to have 95% but It's increasing daily, do you think we are going to reach it or there is no chance and SegWit won't be activated ?
It's an open discussion so feel free to say your opinion about the whole SegWit thing and not only about Signalling.
Jump to: