Pages:
Author

Topic: Do we want Epochtalk? (Read 1515 times)

member
Activity: 364
Merit: 44
★Bitvest.io★ Play Plinko or Invest
April 13, 2024, 03:59:39 PM
#44
all we see is some ugly CSS, which can be changed when the coding is finished.

Exactly. And we have on the forum quite a number of skilled people that can add an user script and adjust the look and feel here and there if it's getting released and a big number of users won't like it.
Somewhat strange to keep telling that over years, but it's still early to criticize the UI.

For me I think what we see mat just be a sample as the work may have not reached the final stage,for me I see it a mirage which when closer may not appear the way it seem. It may be more attractive at the point of regular use.
Since I don't know the architectural or design originally given to be coded through prescription or discrimination on how the user interface should reflect I can't jump into inference of saying the design don't meet up requirements. I stand to be corrected I believe more more is still in place for me better outlook using CSS to beautier the interface and possibly add some necessary features.
hero member
Activity: 2520
Merit: 952
June 06, 2021, 10:11:40 PM
#43
I don't really care about anymore, people want it so they can have some added features like notifications for quotes/mentions and mobile friendly. For first, we have telegram bots that serve same purpose, for second, I never had problem accessing/using this forum on mobile.
legendary
Activity: 1820
Merit: 2700
Crypto Swap Exchange
April 16, 2021, 06:01:43 AM
#42
...
Anyone who is interested in donating to my new new forum project should contact me privately.  Cool

I'd give a dime for that crap! You should put this in a white paper and launch a crowdfunding campaign, or maybe even an ICO / IPO.  Wink
staff
Activity: 3304
Merit: 4115
April 15, 2021, 08:20:30 AM
#41
It is true, but migrating a forum of this size to another platform is not an easy task. On the other hand, I have seen many forums "die", as they migrated to other platforms and were unable to guarantee all the features that the community is used to on the new platform.
This was probably due to there being better alternatives to the forum, rather than the new platform scaring people away. Unfortunately, humans in general hate change, and therefore any big or small change is usually off putting, but given enough time we'll adapt to anything put in front of us. So. although at first it might seem significant that it doesn't have x feature, or you don't like the design elements, it quickly evaporates away as you become more familiar with the software.
legendary
Activity: 1862
Merit: 5154
**In BTC since 2013**
April 14, 2021, 03:52:13 AM
#40
But yeah it's a shame that after such a long time we're still on SMF.

It is true, but migrating a forum of this size to another platform is not an easy task. On the other hand, I have seen many forums "die", as they migrated to other platforms and were unable to guarantee all the features that the community is used to on the new platform.
legendary
Activity: 3472
Merit: 1724
April 13, 2021, 09:25:52 PM
#39
As far as I remember, this topic has been exhaustively discussed over the years. Most of the development was funded via money from ad slot auctions, and the high cost of remuneration for forum development (at the time, in USD terms) also had plausible explanations. But yeah it's a shame that after such a long time we're still on SMF.
staff
Activity: 3304
Merit: 4115
April 12, 2021, 06:35:21 PM
#38
If Javascript were to become a requirement, then the forum would risk losing some people.  I am not the only one to have expressed similar concerns in the past.
Yeah, I'm really big against most sites that require Javascript to function. Personally, I think as a developer you should be not enforcing something that potentially could compromise their security. Instead, either program the whole thing around without forcing Javascript, or provide an alternative site if it detects the user doesn't have Javascript enabled.

This forum software is great in terms of general use without Javascript. I've actually had to enable it a few times for moderator actions, since there were certain pitfalls while taking certain actions.
copper member
Activity: 630
Merit: 2614
If you don’t do PGP, you don’t do crypto!
April 11, 2021, 07:53:38 PM
#37
Huh I missed this memo. Porting everything over from AngularJS to Vue?

Imagine devving a forum from scratch around a stupid framework and not even releasing it before LTS ends for your stupid framework (AngularJS  Cheesy).

Everything on this forum makes me rage nowadays

Sheer incompetence.

Awww, rewriting it with a different frontend framework.  That is a classic!  It is almost as good as a total rewrite in a more fashionable language.  If I were to develop the new forum software, I would write it in C; then, I would realize that C is not Cool, and I would rewrite the whole thing in Rust!

That has been my suspicion about Epochtalk for years—since before I even had an account here:  It is intentional.

For you see, intentionally incompetent bespoke software development is often a cover for money laundering.  If you know a guy who knows a guy, there are guys who do this service to small business owners who want to save on taxes; and I reasonably suspect that a large proportion of Daily WTF-tier enterprise software consulting is graft, a conduit for senior executives to divert shareholder equity.  Come to think of it, I suppose that the same scheme would work for money raised with donations.

If done properly, the scheme is bulletproof.  An incompetent developer can never feign adequacy; whereas a talented developer can easily write poorly designed, bug-ridden, unmaintainable code that languishes in Development Hell for eternity.  To an auditor, the latter is indistinguishable from the former.

To be prepared in case of an audit, they guys offering these services do develop something plausible.  They meticulously maintain source repos of unmaintainable horror-code.  They deliver demos, alphas, and betas (but never a finished product).  And even in case of closed-source projects (which are the norm), they have no qualms about showing all of this to any investigator who may ask; if necessary, that is a part of the service.

The business can write all this off as an expense.  It can be an astoundingly large expense, because—well, have you ever seen what software consultants charge!?  Meanwhile, after the “developer” takes his cut, the money somehow finds its way into an offshore bank account.  It helps if the “developer” either is located in a foreign jurisdiction, or has such global connections as may facilitate running up his own “expenses” and “obligations” to make overseas remittances.

In case of diverting funds for graft, such complexity is, of course, unnecessary.  Taxes can even be paid, to avoid the high risk of being “Al Caponed”.  It is all so much easier, if the objective is simply to pilfer from shareholders (or donors) whilst feigning “transparency”.

I hate to mention all of this, because it is unethical to broach such speculation in public.  If my longtime suspicions about Epochtalk are correct, then unless someone is being scammed, I should mind my own business!  And if I am wrong—if this is a crazy conspiracy theory, like the notion that NFTs are 90% cover for money laundering and graft—then I risk drawing the Eye of Sauron to innocent people who are not doing anything illegal.  Rumours, gossip, reputational damage, police harassment, tax audits, unjust prosecutions—so many are the ills which may thus be caused.  To flap one’s lips on the Internet about this stuff is a lose-lose proposition.

🧍🧍🧍:live🚫:throw

Well, whatever—for the record, my longtime suspicion is the reason, and the only reason why I have never criticized the New Forum Vapourware.  I hate stupidity!  But I always chuckled at Epochtalk:  Wow, LOL, thermos has a good thing going there.  (That was my reaction because until a few days ago, I didn’t realize that the new forum software was funded by donors’ money; I presumed that it was paid for with the proceeds of a privately held business which auctions ads, and has other sources of revenue.)  Terrific amounts of BTC have been “dissipated”; and nobody can prove that it is not all a matter of
Sheer incompetence.



[ANN] Nulltalk, the new new forum software

Everything on this forum makes me rage nowadays

Me, too.  Let’s do something constructive about it.

I propose that I myself should indeed write the new new forum software.  As aforesaid, I will write it in C, then rewrite it in Rust; if I need to take more time, then along the way, I may also rewrite the code in Java, C#, Go, Javascript, Python, C++ with Boost, C++ without Boost, COBOL, MUMPS, Solidity, Visual BASIC, LISP, FORTRAN, and/or Brainfuck.  I don’t know many of these languages; thus, the schedule slippage will be spectacular as I spend time learning.  My proposed schedule is to deliver a feature-incomplete pre-alpha demo by the 2028 Halving, a beta before BIP 42 becomes economically relevant, and the official 1.0 release before the heat death of the universe—maybe.  I’m so slick!

The project is called Nulltalk, because its distinguishing innovation shall be that it autobans all users, and stores all posts in the /dev/null NoSQL database.  Thus, there shall be no talk.  Silence!  Hey—if John Cage could sell records this way, why can’t I build a forum that forbids all discussion?  Also, I shall integrate the zero-dimensional graph-theoretic /dev/null NoSQL cloud database with Blockchain, because Blockchain has maximal synergies with buzzwords in Enterprise NoSQL Cloud Blockchain.

AdolfinWolf, perhaps you should apply to join my team.  You shall write (then rewrite) a feature that battles the silence with noise:  Your module shall create new users and new posts from /dev/random, and my module shall commit them to /dev/null.  I will then use a pomo text generator to write a paper about the transgressive metaphysical singularity of a forum that, given infinite time, shall create and destroy all possible posts by all possible users, and the social subtext of Nulltalk’s design as an implicit hypostatic critique of the paradigmatic institutional framework of dominance and submission that gives rise to the dialectic of cyberbullying (ah, cyberbullying: do it for the grievance studies lulz!).

This is art!

Anyone who is interested in donating to my new new forum project should contact me privately.  Cool
legendary
Activity: 1428
Merit: 1166
🤩Finally Married🤩
April 03, 2021, 03:21:16 PM
#36
I have no excitements left for the new forum software. All gone to be honest. However let's be possitive. Hopefully someday we will migrate to Epochtalk.
I certainly feel you bro, back on 2019, I was expecting that Epochtalk will be available as Theymos already gave somethjng like Beta from what I remember that can be run by other users.
But now I do definitely lost it, though it will be such a waste if this wouldn't be continued, well, I, too, feel the same as I'd rather stick to the current one.
(Anyways too late for my reply here LoL)
this current version of SMF is so much customized that it’s not possible to update anymore and new software has been in discussions since the age of dinosaurs literally..
Another decade century will pass and it will still be in discussion 😅
copper member
Activity: 1526
Merit: 2890
April 03, 2021, 01:49:31 PM
#35
What could be done is an update of the current software.
The version used is 1.1.19. The latest version of this software is 2.0.18.
Even so, since the forum has several modifications, the update was going to be laborious, to make the modifications in the new version.

Latest version of SMF??? Forget about it... this current version of SMF is so much customized that it’s not possible to update anymore and new software has been in discussions since the age of dinosaurs literally..

https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/rfc-new-forum-software-specifications-45372

So in short let’s settle for what we have and use other resources in hand for some better experience

For example for notifications use TryNinja Telegram bot for notifications

Even if the SMF is replaced with Epochtalk the demand for separate Mobile App will always be there.
legendary
Activity: 1862
Merit: 5154
**In BTC since 2013**
April 03, 2021, 12:26:19 PM
#34
I don't think a new software is needed.

Migrating from one platform to another is not easy. There may be many tools that do this, but it is always a lot of work to configure many aspects that are different on each platform.

What could be done is an update of the current software.
The version used is 1.1.19. The latest version of this software is 2.0.18.
Even so, since the forum has several modifications, the update was going to be laborious, to make the modifications in the new version.
legendary
Activity: 1946
Merit: 1427
March 30, 2021, 03:00:26 PM
#33
Huh I missed this memo. Porting everything over from AngularJS to Vue?

Imagine devving a forum from scratch around a stupid framework and not even releasing it before LTS ends for your stupid framework (AngularJS  Cheesy).

Everything on this forum makes me rage nowadays

Sheer incompetence.

Notifications have been taken into account.

>mfw I get told for the 100th time that the new forum has notifications




>mfw I open bitcointalk on my Iphone X max SuperPro

copper member
Activity: 630
Merit: 2614
If you don’t do PGP, you don’t do crypto!
March 30, 2021, 06:50:02 AM
#32
>Vue
>Angular
>Javascript

Except for the new account registration and initial login, the forum currently works acceptably in a browser that has Javascript disabled.  I have not enabled Javascript here since I set my current login cookies in 2017; and since theymos created the CAPTCHA bypass, I have expected that I should never need Javascript here again.

If Javascript were to become a requirement, then the forum would risk losing some people.  I am not the only one to have expressed similar concerns in the past.

Most “communities” would probably disregard the loss as negligible.  Given that no-JS users are disproportionately represented amongst those who care about security, cryptography, and anonymity, the Bitcoin Forum should be different.

We went to sleep, and dreamt of a universal platform.  We awoke in a nightmare where the universal platform is the web browser, the universal language is Javascript, the universal ISA is Webasm—and the morals of youths have been corrupted so that they promiscuously run network-loaded executable code from random strangers as a lifestyle.  I want to kill myself, or at least take up a hobby of severe alcoholism.

SMF is WTF, but that is no reason to make things worse.



Discourse forums recently became unreadable without Javascript.  Pages essentially show up as blank.  I have accordingly decided that Discourse is only for morons; for example, I noticed that some of the major Ethereum development forums run on Discourse.  (eth.wiki also shows blank pages without JS.)

Just saying.
copper member
Activity: 786
Merit: 710
Defend Bitcoin and its PoW: bitcoincleanup.com
March 25, 2021, 04:10:13 AM
#31
I dig the current design but it would be really great if it could get some additions in it, like mentions, quotes, etc.

Notifications have been taken into account. You get notified (also optional by mail) if you have been mentioned with @ or your post has been quoted "you have a reply to your post". Once the merit module will be working it will be hooked up to notifications as well.
If it gets annoying you can block notifications for mentions or quotes from certain users.
hero member
Activity: 2520
Merit: 952
March 25, 2021, 01:04:42 AM
#30
I dig the current design but it would be really great if it could get some additions in it, like mentions, quotes, etc.
copper member
Activity: 786
Merit: 710
Defend Bitcoin and its PoW: bitcoincleanup.com
March 16, 2021, 08:14:27 AM
#29
I know JavaScript well. I don't think I could fix anything in the EpochTalk code without spending a couple of weeks learning the framework and even then I'd still be like someone who just learned the road signs trying to drive for the first time.

Granted I have zero enthusiasm for this project so spending even two hours learning anything about it sounds extremely unappealing Smiley

I am aware that people are not going to contribute out of the blue. You normally contribute if you use it and/or plan to build on top of it, to add extra functionality etc That being said I see the reluctance to do so. Fair point ! Guess this might change when the beta would be live (again)  Tongue

 
legendary
Activity: 3654
Merit: 8909
https://bpip.org
March 16, 2021, 07:52:38 AM
#28
Both Vue and Angular are still javascript at their core. If you know Angular that does not mean this skill is useless. It just means the learning curve is a whole lot less steeper than for others.  Wink

I know JavaScript well. I don't think I could fix anything in the EpochTalk code without spending a couple of weeks learning the framework and even then I'd still be like someone who just learned the road signs trying to drive for the first time.

Granted I have zero enthusiasm for this project so spending even two hours learning anything about it sounds extremely unappealing Smiley
copper member
Activity: 786
Merit: 710
Defend Bitcoin and its PoW: bitcoincleanup.com
March 16, 2021, 06:52:44 AM
#27
All that happened until now is that Theymos lost the passion for the new software as the time pass by and he is in his 30s now and life is much different than the exiting 20s, he has a stable job witch takes all of his time and all the bitcoin work goes to the "hobby" time, which as we all know  is less and less with every year until you retire. This is how I see it, he lost that "magic" and now it's just a thing quite far on the bottom of the "boring" ToDo list.

The forum (this one) seems more like responsibility to him than a fun project it used to be.
I hope I'm wrong.

Am I not getting the same vibe... yet  Cheesy

As far as Epochtalk is concerned to me sounds scalable and lots of new, fresh, modern ideas can be implemented, once it's up and running that is.
I guess we shall eventually see. Or maybe I'm too optimist as less years have passed since I am actively aware of the project. Could be...

TBH I'm not sure how much of a control he's excercising in this project. Like for example who signed off on moving from AngularJS to Vue and not some other framework.

Contrary to common belief most things are reviewed and approved by "El Hefe".

I don't like users being told to do it themselves when there are people getting paid to do it. Besides, if I wanted to contribute a year ago and started learning Angular or whatever it was, it would have been quite useless now that it's being converted to something else, and 5 years from now when Vue is no longer cool it will be something else again etc.

It is open source. Anyone can contribute if they want. Angular is developed by Google but plain users like me and you can still make a commit and fix/improve things even if they already have their own in-house core dev team. I was just saying there might be an alternative to making a userscript, that's all.
Both Vue and Angular are still javascript at their core. If you know Angular that does not mean this skill is useless. It just means the learning curve is a whole lot less steeper than for others.  Wink

Edit:

On the same note with @shahzadafzal's post:


https://xkcd.com/743/
legendary
Activity: 3654
Merit: 8909
https://bpip.org
March 13, 2021, 07:52:05 PM
#26
The forum (this one) seems more like responsibility to him than a fun project it used to be.
I hope I'm wrong.

Well, if that's the case he can hand it over to someone he trusts, like the Cyrus/Rizzrack gang. TBH I'm not sure how much of a control he's excercising in this project. Like for example who signed off on moving from AngularJS to Vue and not some other framework.
legendary
Activity: 2240
Merit: 3150
₿uy / $ell ..oeleo ;(
March 13, 2021, 02:36:41 PM
#25
All that happened until now is that Theymos lost the passion for the new software as the time pass by and he is in his 30s now and life is much different than the exiting 20s, he has a stable job witch takes all of his time and all the bitcoin work goes to the "hobby" time, which as we all know  is less and less with every year until you retire. This is how I see it, he lost that "magic" and now it's just a thing quite far on the bottom of the "boring" ToDo list.

The forum (this one) seems more like responsibility to him than a fun project it used to be.
I hope I'm wrong.
Pages:
Jump to: