Do you check a project's GitHub while doing ICO analysis?

AlisaWhishie

member

Activity: 322

Merit: 20

Quote from: ifanxu on June 23, 2018, 09:26:14 PM

No, I usually do not check them because I do not understand the code, I often use ICO ratings and Google search information to determine whether an ICO is reliable.

I also used to do the same, but from my experience ICO raitings are not something reliable and I wouldn't use them to decide where to invest my money actually, I'm not a lot into all of these concpiracy theories about all raitings being paid where each point of raiting costs some certain amount of dollars, but personally I've seen pretty enough projects with good raitings even from ICObench which turned out to be scam.

ifanxu

newbie

Activity: 140

Merit: 0

No, I usually do not check them because I do not understand the code, I often use ICO ratings and Google search information to determine whether an ICO is reliable.

AlisaWhishie

member

Activity: 322

Merit: 20

Quote from: guizi6 on June 22, 2018, 02:31:57 AM

I want to say that I really want to see their source code, but I'm not a technical person, I don't know where to look for source code, and even if I know it, I can't read it, even if I understand what this means? ? Is the project good?

Honestly, I'm not a technical person either, but I find it very important to take a look at how the project spends money that it raises. And this thought I have got from one of the cryptobloggers on Youtube, IvanOnTech, I think he's pretty popular whithin the community. So he has several videos about how exactly to check project's GitHub and what to look at if you are not good at codes and all of this technical stuff. Here is the video with all these basic things: https://youtu.be/g9QBn1V-8ZA

Eddieboy

newbie

Activity: 36

Merit: 0

Github is a collaboration tool used mostly by programmers, but other types of people use it too. Github allows people to share files, change files in a group setting, manage changes to files so that they don’t affect other files, and keep track of changes to files over time. Github also provides a web-based interface that makes it easy to browse files and other parts of a project. The beauty of Github is that anyone can access it – you don’t even have to sign up.😎

Github is a GREAT PLACE for researching ICOs because all information is available to the public, so you’ll always have access to the latest about an ICO.👍👍👍

visionary

hero member

Activity: 966

Merit: 587

Yes, it is quite important but it's not the main part of my analysis. White paper, hard/soft cap, team, and advisors are more important imo.

AmericanBit

sr. member

Activity: 630

Merit: 250

I check ICOs at www.icoguide.com before making decisions, and I can suggest to look at this platform as the rates are very real.

Ociwiw

jr. member

Activity: 378

Merit: 1

Although I do not understand the Github language, but nevertheless I consider this to be important, so I always check the availability of Github!

guizi6

newbie

Activity: 82

Merit: 0

I want to say that I really want to see their source code, but I'm not a technical person, I don't know where to look for source code, and even if I know it, I can't read it, even if I understand what this means? ? Is the project good?

BitNaija

member

Activity: 322

Merit: 10

GitHub is a technical site. I have not known GitHub to be a good check site for ICO. Now that I know, I will study that site to understand how it works. This is good information.

Dr.Sponge

member

Activity: 616

Merit: 10

I usually read through their community, if this community is good or not. Also, I usually read the bounty hunters, if they wanted to sell or not after hit an exchange.

dididou

newbie

Activity: 59

Merit: 0

Github is an important part of an ICO project. It allows you to understand the progress of project development, and plans for the future. Inspection is indispensable. Serious reference is to reduce the risk of investing yourself and blind investment is not recommended. There is no good result.

abaidudez

full member

Activity: 504

Merit: 101

Honestly I don't really check github in most of the ICO's I participated. I just check the whitepaper for I think that's the major thing that will give you information on how the project will be doing? What is the goal, who are in the team and what will be the project road map or plan. Github helps in other way but not all people know and understand the code.

shiningstar

full member

Activity: 420

Merit: 100

Qravity is a decentralized content production

No i don't check github because i don't understand anything about programing so even if i check the github i only look at the activity and nothing else. I also saw that some project don't want to show their github because they are not an open project and afraid the competitor will steal their idea or something else. Also most ico github is still empty because they haven't start the development.

Akselrod

full member

Activity: 434

Merit: 104

Quote from: AlisaWhishie on May 26, 2018, 06:03:01 PM

Everyone knows that's it's necessary to check a project's social media pages and whitepaper while analysing ICO projects, but first of all we are investing in the technology, not in the marketing. So the main thing to take a look at should be GitHub of the project, and looking at it we can get the overall picture about how the team is working and whether the funds that are being raised are really spent on the development of the project.
Do you agree with this? How important is GitHub for you in ICO analysis?

Certainly GitHub is very important from a technical point of view. But since I'm not very good at this, I try to look at other aspects of the project. I think that the team and a well-written whitepaper play an equally important role.

Lerikaweb

member

Activity: 392

Merit: 12

The Fourth Generation of Blockchain in DeFi

If i were able to read the source code, checking a team's GitHub could be of more use:)) if there is a blankpage - i will stay away for sure, but if there is some code i cannot judge on whether it works or it was copy-pasted from anywhere.

BluRPie

hero member

Activity: 896

Merit: 504

Quote from: AlisaWhishie on May 26, 2018, 06:03:01 PM

Everyone knows that's it's necessary to check a project's social media pages and whitepaper while analysing ICO projects, but first of all we are investing in the technology, not in the marketing. So the main thing to take a look at should be GitHub of the project, and looking at it we can get the overall picture about how the team is working and whether the funds that are being raised are really spent on the development of the project.
Do you agree with this? How important is GitHub for you in ICO analysis?

First of all most of projects have not any github section due that they have not anything to upload. They just have simple ERC token and nothing more. Some of this ICOs was successful.

jatoman

newbie

Activity: 98

Merit: 0

Quote from: AlisaWhishie on May 26, 2018, 06:03:01 PM

Everyone knows that's it's necessary to check a project's social media pages and whitepaper while analysing ICO projects, but first of all we are investing in the technology, not in the marketing. So the main thing to take a look at should be GitHub of the project, and looking at it we can get the overall picture about how the team is working and whether the funds that are being raised are really spent on the development of the project.
Do you agree with this? How important is GitHub for you in ICO analysis?

There are numerous criteria evaluating an ICO project. Certainly one of them is assessing the team's ability to deliver the technology.

If you have a strong technical background, reviewing technical assets such as specifications, code, and test cases are important milestones you can verify.

Many, perhaps most, ICO investors don't have such a background.

What probably is a better criteria is the background and track record of the team. This will show whether they have a consistent record of delivering significant software projects. Any ICO investor can assess this.

bit..what?

jr. member

Activity: 294

Merit: 1

That's a good idea. I have not thought of that yet.
I think that's what i would do in the future. Thanks for the tip.

Tipstar

sr. member

Activity: 1764

Merit: 280

Smart World Global Token

If the project is open source, github makes a difference where you can meet up volunteers and developers and discuss about the product.
But that is not the case for most of the ICO tokens. What would you check for?

mariayaz

jr. member

Activity: 294

Merit: 3

GitHub is an important part when investing in ICOs but you also can not ignore marketing aspects. I guess after looking at marketing/ rating and authenticity of ICO we can go to check GitHub.

Topic: Do you check a project's GitHub while doing ICO analysis? (Read 204 times)