Pages:
Author

Topic: Do you think 100% fan speed harm the fan? (Read 1639 times)

hero member
Activity: 1008
Merit: 1000
July 25, 2017, 10:24:27 AM
#29
If you feel the need to run them at 100% then you need better cooling, it is as simple as that.

A few C lower temp will not make the gpu last longer, what WILL kill the gpu is inconsistent temps and big swings as well as over temp.
legendary
Activity: 4326
Merit: 3519
what is this "brake pedal" you speak of?
yes it's easier to replace fans but that's a bit of a hassle too, isn't it?

when i replaced the fan on my HD6870 i found on it on ebay. took about 10 minutes to swap it out. actually took longer to find it on ebay than to do the replacement.
member
Activity: 130
Merit: 11
in conclusion, never run any fans at 100% it's more damage for no efficiency(or very little)

I try to keep mine usually at 70 or below but never above 75%, yes it's easier to replace fans but that's a bit of a hassle too, isn't it?

rather downvolt your cards instead if your cooler can't handle high temps at 75%

hero member
Activity: 2926
Merit: 722
I talked to 2 fan sellers, they both said that there was no different between 70% and 100%. If this is true, I would like set the GPU fan speed to 100% to make GPU cooler, what do you think about it?

 Clueless sellers.

 The higher speed DOES increase wear on the bearings (or on the SEALS for sleeve-type and variant-sleeve-type fans like Rifle and FDS etc).

 This WILL cause them to wear out faster.

 It's not a cut-and-dried thing as to HOW MUCH faster they will wear out, though - in particular on fans that NEED seals temperature also plays a factor.


Fan sellers will surely told such thing because they would love for you to buy fans over and over again since those fans who are set in 100% will really worn out soo fast compared to those who ran on a lesser percentage. If i were you for OP, better listen to those people who suggested on here since most people here do have experience when it comes to mining. You should lessen up the fan speed, they are just the same better to go below 80%.
full member
Activity: 350
Merit: 100
thanks all, I will set my fan to 85% and check the GPU temp.
legendary
Activity: 1498
Merit: 1030
I talked to 2 fan sellers, they both said that there was no different between 70% and 100%. If this is true, I would like set the GPU fan speed to 100% to make GPU cooler, what do you think about it?

 Clueless sellers.

 The higher speed DOES increase wear on the bearings (or on the SEALS for sleeve-type and variant-sleeve-type fans like Rifle and FDS etc).

 This WILL cause them to wear out faster.

 It's not a cut-and-dried thing as to HOW MUCH faster they will wear out, though - in particular on fans that NEED seals temperature also plays a factor.

sr. member
Activity: 1246
Merit: 274
Put a $20 box fan on the rig. It will lower the temperature of all the GPU's, so you don't need to run the card fans as high. Also cheaper and easier to replace. A box fan will draw about ~75 W, so you need to take than in consideration for your total power draw. I have one box fan on low covering a total of 10 cards on two rigs and all my cards fans are at less 71 Celsius and 70% fan speed. The fans on the cards directly in front of the box fan run at less than 50%

Yes indeed, we have a 20" box fan (2600CFM) set up cooling 2 6 GPU rigs each (2 stacked open air frames) and it works really well in our mining room with a commercial exhaust vent sucking the hot air outdoors on one wall and an open window on the other wall to let fresh air in. That setup is cooling 10 6 GPU rigs quite well and most likely could do double that if we had a bigger electric supply.
legendary
Activity: 4116
Merit: 7849
'The right to privacy matters'
Regardless if you run them at 70% or 100%, they will eventually die.
70% will last longer, however how many have actually had GPU fans die on them? It never happened to me. Aren't fans rated at like 100.000 hours or something?

that is not the point  the point is you are wasting power  once you get into the 90-95%  range  the cooling is not improved and you waste power.

Since the idea of running the gpus is making money  then why waste power by setting them higher then 90%


GPU fans don't consume any significant amount of power. The power draw increase from when a fan isn't spinning to when it goes to 100% does not exceed 4W, and therefore a 10% increase is much less significant. Some fans are event more efficient than that.
Though it is pointless running at 100%.

the power draw  at 90 to 100 is 1 watt  extra per fan  2 fans per card = 2 watts  6 cards  = 12 watts  yeah  maybe all blowers = 6 watts.

10 rigs = 60 to 120 watts  which is 1.5 to 3 kwatts  a day for no purpose. If you run 60 gpus.  Bigger farms  the same thing.  How about a 1000 card farm  set at 90% to 100%  when 80-85 works as well.

 As that boost in fan speed from 90 to 100   does not cool better.

sr. member
Activity: 420
Merit: 251
Regardless if you run them at 70% or 100%, they will eventually die.
70% will last longer, however how many have actually had GPU fans die on them? It never happened to me. Aren't fans rated at like 100.000 hours or something?

that is not the point  the point is you are wasting power  once you get into the 90-95%  range  the cooling is not improved and you waste power.

Since the idea of running the gpus is making money  then why waste power by setting them higher then 90%


GPU fans don't consume any significant amount of power. The power draw increase from when a fan isn't spinning to when it goes to 100% does not exceed 4W, and therefore a 10% increase is much less significant. Some fans are event more efficient than that.
Though it is pointless running at 100%.
hero member
Activity: 1036
Merit: 606
Put a $20 box fan on the rig. It will lower the temperature of all the GPU's, so you don't need to run the card fans as high. Also cheaper and easier to replace. A box fan will draw about ~75 W, so you need to take than in consideration for your total power draw. I have one box fan on low covering a total of 10 cards on two rigs and all my cards fans are at less 71 Celsius and 70% fan speed. The fans on the cards directly in front of the box fan run at less than 50%
legendary
Activity: 4116
Merit: 7849
'The right to privacy matters'
Regardless if you run them at 70% or 100%, they will eventually die.
70% will last longer, however how many have actually had GPU fans die on them? It never happened to me. Aren't fans rated at like 100.000 hours or something?

that is not the point  the point is you are wasting power  once you get into the 90-95%  range  the cooling is not improved and you waste power.

Since the idea of running the gpus is making money  then why waste power by setting them higher then 90%

member
Activity: 110
Merit: 10
To the Moon!
While dual mining ethereum/sia coin I made the mistake of letting my fans stay too high (kept them around the ~85-95% marks) and 2 of the fans on my R9 390 Strix have shit the bed. It had been used for gaming about a year before I started mining, and was mining for about 1 month before the sleeve bearing went kaput. So I would say even if you had to get an external house fan (you can get one from amazon for like 15 dollars that will move a lot of air) and blow it inside your case to reduce the gpu fan speeds.
sr. member
Activity: 420
Merit: 251
I talked to 2 fan sellers, they both said that there was no different between 70% and 100%. If this is true, I would like set the GPU fan speed to 100% to make GPU cooler, what do you think about it?

yeah on the long run, yes, because there is a maximum of rounds that a fan can do, it's not unlimited, so by setting it at 100% you are aksing for more rounds per minute, and then you have a less lifespan
That's not the reason. The bearings heat up more due to increased friction and therefore their lifespan is reduced.
Ball bearing fans have significantly less friction than sleeve bearings and are not affected by this as much.

100% speed on GPU fans not only is very noisy, it's also pretty much useless as after a certain point the fan stops being a bottleneck whatsoever.

legendary
Activity: 2590
Merit: 1022
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
I talked to 2 fan sellers, they both said that there was no different between 70% and 100%. If this is true, I would like set the GPU fan speed to 100% to make GPU cooler, what do you think about it?

yeah on the long run, yes, because there is a maximum of rounds that a fan can do, it's not unlimited, so by setting it at 100% you are aksing for more rounds per minute, and then you have a less lifespan
sr. member
Activity: 2226
Merit: 347
I talked to 2 fan sellers, they both said that there was no different between 70% and 100%. If this is true, I would like set the GPU fan speed to 100% to make GPU cooler, what do you think about it?
100%? If you are really willing to replace them for sometime and wouldnt matter on the cost then its your decision but  the usual percentage would be only on 70-80% the lesser it is the longer span of your fans life. Im hating on changing stuffs why would bother on 100 since the cooling would be still the same as far as a i observed.
sr. member
Activity: 378
Merit: 250
You will decrease the operating life, but like another user mentioned does it matter. These fans usually have been tested properly, depending on the brand.
legendary
Activity: 4326
Merit: 3519
what is this "brake pedal" you speak of?
Not all fans are same, for example with good ball bearing fan can last very long even on 100%.
But yes on 70% will for sure last longer, and better to have problem with fan then with vrm or gpu.

this. ball bearing fans will way outlast sleeve bearing fans. ive had ball bearing fans running 100% for years (case fans) and for gpus my ball bearing sapphire 5830s ran 100% for like two years 24/7 back in btc/ltc gpu mining days. fans are fine.

i try to buy only gpus with ball bearing fans. and as dadesu mentions a fan its cheaper than blowing a gpus vrms. the cooler the electronics, the happier they are. cooler gpus also draw a bit less power also.

that being said running say 85% vs 100% there is little difference in cooling, at least in my experience. and lower fan speed does equal longer life but a good fan will outlast the useful life of a gpu anyway.

i run most of my mining gpus locked at 85%.
legendary
Activity: 1456
Merit: 1005
I talked to 2 fan sellers, they both said that there was no different between 70% and 100%. If this is true, I would like set the GPU fan speed to 100% to make GPU cooler, what do you think about it?


It is not true, running at 100% fan speed will burn it out faster. They all burn out eventually, but that speed will guarantee it goes quicker.

There is no use to put 100% fan speed to cool your card. I think 80-85% is more enough you will get a good result and the card life will be safe. Still, your card is getting heat then put one small fan to your cards that's it. don't burn your card to put high speed.
full member
Activity: 210
Merit: 100
I talked to 2 fan sellers, they both said that there was no different between 70% and 100%. If this is true, I would like set the GPU fan speed to 100% to make GPU cooler, what do you think about it?


It is not true, running at 100% fan speed will burn it out faster. They all burn out eventually, but that speed will guarantee it goes quicker.
hero member
Activity: 751
Merit: 517
Fail to plan, and you plan to fail.
I talked to 2 fan sellers, they both said that there was no different between 70% and 100%. If this is true, I would like set the GPU fan speed to 100% to make GPU cooler, what do you think about it?

Yes, fans could die in only 3 years instead of the usual 5. The real question is, does it matter?
Pages:
Jump to: