Not exactly
You are missing one point.
Gold already has a market and demand for it (it exists, its proven, and everyone on the earth wants it). Gold has value today and will have tomorrow.
On other hand they created (wait... they want to create) something that MAYBE will have a value. See the difference?
First they need to deliver the product, second they need to make you, me and everyone else to have a desire to buy more and more ethers..
Another thing, presale or IPO are usually used to make some money that will help "company" or project grow.
In their case it is not capped(!) they are ready to take as much as we can give them, even if they dont need it....
Another aspect to consider - presale or IPO usually(!) benefit those who risk their money before everyone else with reward for the risk they take. Here, again, it is questionable, are you sure that next year there will be enough demand to reward risk of your investment today?
here is my post from another topic:
Ethereum is out now.
I wanted to "invest", the idea is good... but now, after I learned more...
I just looked at their website they already "raised" about 3000 bitcoins... The odd thing is from what I learned is that there is no cap on number of coins and the future coins coming to the market just a percentage of "presale", which makes me think of a very strange strategy...
as many people invest the less value of each coin will have...
Their prelaunch is actually will dictate next years number of coins, so if there will be 1.000.000 coins mined next year or 300.000.000 coins is simply dictated by their prelaunch... And such a difference in number of next year(s) mined coins will have an impact on coins value for sure... Apparently, more people invest in ethereum the lower value of each coin will have... What the hell??
It appears they settled on the fixed percentages a long time ago. the difference in 1 million coins released an 100,000 coins mined the following year is the same as 1 coin released and .1 mined the following. your saying the more people want to buy gold the lower its price? its interesting concept. I dont see how more excitement and a large ipo could ever lead to a lower price in the future. if it fails horribly the price would be low anyways