I believe they were grading the wallet app on Trezor's website, not the Trezor hardware itself? But I'll try to talk to them and show the questions in the topic. It shouldn't be hard for them to reply, if they have the time.
Eventough this is a valid assumption, it doesn't take away the fact that newbies reading this list will most likely jump to the wrong conclusion that it's better to create a wallet with an online wallet provider than to invest $100 for a ledger or a trezor. If you're a legit company and you publish a spreadsheet like this, newbies can suffer the consequences of your actions.
You're nitpicking, but I can see your point. I already pointed Verihpi about said criticism, and this topic. I believe a simple clarification near the top of the spreadsheet would do.
Hi Everybody, This is Maciej from Veriphi, my twitter handle is @CepnikMaciej.
Thank you for starting this thread, we're happy this got so much traction. You were right about your presumption when we mention Trezor and Ledger, we are talking about their online platforms. This is specified in the related article when we point out this is a software analysis only. Indeed, in a perfect situation someone using a ledger or trezor with the electrum wallet has really strong security.
We agree this might not be clear enough, especially for people that fall upon the table without the associate article. We will be adding a comment specifying the difference. Thank you all for pointing this out.