Pages:
Author

Topic: grin is now accepted for forum payments - page 6. (Read 5872 times)

full member
Activity: 308
Merit: 109
January 17, 2019, 02:34:52 PM
#48
And i thought Grin won't launch it's mainnet anytime soon. But looks like the client is far from user-friendly and only mid-high end GPU can mine GRIN for now.

Any chance you'll accept another cryptocurrency (XMR, ETH or perhaps DOGE) soon?

XMR is possible, but probably not the others.

For what you are accepting coins? Like what I can buy with them?
jr. member
Activity: 44
Merit: 1
January 17, 2019, 11:54:27 AM
#47
"Grin has a retarded inflation rate. How do you think its price will remain sustainable?"


Grin would have such a low inflation rate at one point that the increase of units would almost equal to 0. So...
administrator
Activity: 5222
Merit: 13032
January 17, 2019, 11:25:56 AM
#46
Will it be ok to do payments/offer services  in grin in the sections that were exclusively marked for bitcoin?

No.

Can GRIN do this? Can GRIN compete with VISA and remain decentralized and immutable with a fixed supply and no trust in 3rd parties?

s/fixed supply/predictable supply/

Yes, that combined with its privacy is what makes it so exciting. You can probably achieve even greater scaling with BTC+LN, and I consider that quite likely to be what the economy actually goes toward, but grin is a very different and interesting alternative approach.
legendary
Activity: 2296
Merit: 2262
BTC or BUST
January 17, 2019, 09:59:42 AM
#45
Grin has a retarded inflation rate. How do you think its price will remain sustainable?
While I am fond of Mimblewimble, whoever decided the coin specification decided to create a serious flaw.
Doge 2.0 with some bells on? Idea is sound, but sounds like Cryptohunter sorted out the supply
I don't understand...
60 Grins created every minute forever...
Isn't it the very definition of perpetual inflation? Oo



What exactly is so terrible about the price history of DOGE? You could have done a lot worse holding many other coins. It is worth more now in terms of USD than it was even at the peak of its early pump.

I watched this early pump, I was there, I had some sells in my trade history in the 240s.

Doge has always been one of my favorite cryptoCURRENCIES..
I love sending doge around for its small fees, confirmation speed, high liquidity, can send micro amounts, great CURRENCY..

Yeah sure it's not deflationary like BTC and you probably won't get rich hodling it long term like BTC, but BTC is more aiming to be the most secure store of value and not necessarily to be used for everyday small payments.

The FEDs in charge of fiat currencies do have a bit of a point about inflation keeping the currency flowing, they don't do that by accident..
High deflation stops currency flow in its tracks. Their are plenty of threads about why people don't spend BTC..

Since the inflation rate is so high in the first ~year, I think it will probably go even lower, probably under $1, and I'd expect the price chart of the first year to be a general downward trend. Again, I don't particularly recommend buying this stuff, and I myself am not going to be buying large amounts soon. But if it survives for several years and ends up competing effectively with other coins on scaling and privacy, then the inflation rate starts becoming reasonable even despite its unlimited supply

I think it could be the best CURRENCY yet, to actually be used as a currency..
So what if Grin will only be $0.01 each in a few years. You can still send $1,000,000 if you have enough of them..  

Satoshi created Bitcoin and this forum in order to change the world, not to create a "Cult of BTC".
if you're interested in Bitcoin for the same reasons that Satoshi created it (freedom, privacy, and interesting tech), then grin is worthy of acknowledgement.

I think their is a righteousness to the emissions rate of GRIN. The early miners aren't going to get instarich with an instamine, no premine, no ICO, and a good inflation/deflation rate in the long term for a CURRENCY..

the first really impressive, true scaling solution in crypto.

Isn't this the holy grail of cryptocurrency? To be able to truly scale and be able to do what we naively thought/hoped that BTC would do?
Bring crypto to the masses, everyone from the rich to 3rd world countries, affordable for the poor, everyone can use it to buy their coffee every morning..

This is what we need if we are going to take the power away from the elite and banks. Eliminate the last excuses to use fiat..
We all can't use BTC or any other altcoin for every transaction we all make. All of the transactions simply will not fit in any crypto while still achieving decentralization.

Can GRIN do this? Can GRIN compete with VISA and remain decentralized and immutable with a fixed supply and no trust in 3rd parties?

Isn't this what we have been waiting for to change the world?
Or is everyone just interested in what they can make a quick $ off of..
hero member
Activity: 1873
Merit: 840
Keep what's important, and know who's your friend
January 17, 2019, 09:52:27 AM
#44
Monero
Mimblewimble has privacy features, but it also has the first really impressive, true scaling solution in crypto. Privacy-wise, Monero is probably better overall, but its scaling is abysmal, and neither coin can be treated as an impenetrable black box.
This. Monero will end up a dead coin sooner because of all the bloat it implemented.

It’s all well and good to have differing opinions on what or what shouldn’t work in a cryptocurrency, that part is completely understandable. But supporting a coin like grin on literally the first day it’s genesis block is mined is just... interesting, that’s all.

Some maximilast (like theymos has been in the past) might even call it “shilling”, but what do I know. I’m pretty positive theymos knows more than I do in general about crypto, plus he is an admin of the forum, so he can govern as he sees fit... I’m alright with that. I wouldn’t have any use to buying anything like copper membership on here so it doesn’t necessarily matter to me personally, I just felt a need to point out hypocrisy as I see it.

Btw LMDB, and especially bulletproofs, are things that both helped with scaling/memory issues in the past and drastically reduced fees.

Edit: I’m not saying Monero should be accepted over grin or anything like that either... I’m just saying bitcointalk should probably just stick to accepting only Bitcoin... if not, just don’t be surprised/annoyed when swarms of people are trying to “market” there favorite favorite shitcoin too because they might have an interesting tweak to the mimnlewimble code or whatever. It’s going to open Pandora’s box in theymos’s inbox. Lol
sr. member
Activity: 742
Merit: 395
I am alive but in hibernation.
January 17, 2019, 09:23:19 AM
#43
How the forum is going to look at grin as far the payments/transactions are concerned?
Will it be ok to do payments/offer services  in grin in the sections that were exclusively marked for bitcoin?
administrator
Activity: 5222
Merit: 13032
January 17, 2019, 08:52:13 AM
#42
And i thought Grin won't launch it's mainnet anytime soon. But looks like the client is far from user-friendly and only mid-high end GPU can mine GRIN for now.

Any chance you'll accept another cryptocurrency (XMR, ETH or perhaps DOGE) soon?

XMR is possible, but probably not the others.

I guess I have already proven my point. Didn't expect it this quick though.

Quote
24h Low / 24h High
$6.92 / $261.65

Imagine FOMOing and buying it for $261.65.

Since the inflation rate is so high in the first ~year, I think it will probably go even lower, probably under $1, and I'd expect the price chart of the first year to be a general downward trend. Again, I don't particularly recommend buying this stuff, and I myself am not going to be buying large amounts soon. But if it survives for several years and ends up competing effectively with other coins on scaling and privacy, then the inflation rate starts becoming reasonable even despite its unlimited supply (see my comment here), and we could at that point see an upward price trend. Even at $1 it'd be an extremely risky investment, but in any case it's an extremely interesting piece of tech.

And I'll be periodically adjusting the forum exchange rate, BTW.

We are in a forum where we are suppose to support bitcoin. Everything we do to promote bitcoin but when a character like theymos indirectly publicly vouch for something else then it will create a mess for sure.

Satoshi created Bitcoin and this forum in order to change the world, not to create a "Cult of BTC". In fact, Satoshi recommended creating Namecoin, the first altcoin. (Though Namecoin ended up being one of the bolt-stuff-onto-cloned-Bitcoin systems that I've never really respected.) I'm not going to start jumping on every alt bandwagon and treating every cryptocurrency as just as good as any other, nor do I believe that grin is currently anywhere close to BTC in terms of overall utility. But grin has true merit, and if you're interested in Bitcoin for the same reasons that Satoshi created it (freedom, privacy, and interesting tech), then grin is worthy of acknowledgement.
copper member
Activity: 630
Merit: 420
We are Bitcoin!
January 17, 2019, 08:20:16 AM
#41
11 cent is 0.00003064BTC when price is $3,590. Consider the price $20k, more hash difficulties more more btc as payment fees. Multiply that with the rate $20k. This was what happened when bitcoin had it's ATH. In dollar currency people even paid more than $10 for transactions.

If you extrapolate the same 0.00003064 to $20,000 that's still only $0.61. A lot has changed between now and a year ago to help keep tx fees down, in terms of satoshis. The last time fees were this low was 2 years ago, when the price of BTC was about $390.
If the price spike up like it did for the ATH the this plain equation is not gonna work. Sure it will be a lot more in terms of dollar. Anyway, my point is that... We are in a forum where we are suppose to support bitcoin. Everything we do to promote bitcoin but when a character like theymos indirectly publicly vouch for something else then it will create a mess for sure.

I could not agree more with this user...
This is what we call indirect endorsement. Just wait for the cryptonews media to handle the rest publicity. Very soon you'll see news likes  
Quote
Cryptocurrencies biggest and oldest forum "bitcointalk" co-founded by satoshi himself accepts GRIN as a means of payment
and the so called crypto-experts on twitter and YouTube will add to the hype by adding it to their top altcoin to watchout for in 2019. Some might even say GRIN is the new BITCOIN Grin. although If I was a part of this project the news above (grins added as means of payment on bitcointalk) will be advertise on grin site. This wasn't the intention of theymos although when a forum like bitcointalk accepts you as a means of payment it's an indirect endorsement sending signals to potential investors that the project is a go for...

Once this Bcash guys will discover this they will take it to another level.


Quote
To get a forum credit of 0.00208333 BTC via grin, send 0.694443333 grin
7$ vs 3.7$

By the time the friday price increase comes, you might buy a membership with a few cents


Blow me I should have seen this before. I just paid for my copper membership in BTC LOL.

Hey, I believe we should only have BTC as payment method. We are Bitcoiner guys. Is n't it should be the whole point?
legendary
Activity: 2912
Merit: 6403
Blackjack.fun
January 17, 2019, 08:18:08 AM
#40
So, anyone dumping their BTC for grim n ?

Theymos, if you really want to add grin as an alternative payment method for the forum, any plans on adding it for the Donator rank? And I suppose the price in grin will be always the same, like the one in BTC  Grin

This way in probably one year it will be cheaper to purchase a donator rank than a copper membership  Grin Grin


Quote
To get a forum credit of 0.00208333 BTC via grin, send 0.694443333 grin
7$ vs 3.7$

By the time the friday price increase comes, you might buy a membership with a few cents

legendary
Activity: 3010
Merit: 8114
January 17, 2019, 08:11:11 AM
#39
11 cent is 0.00003064BTC when price is $3,590. Consider the price $20k, more hash difficulties more more btc as payment fees. Multiply that with the rate $20k. This was what happened when bitcoin had it's ATH. In dollar currency people even paid more than $10 for transactions.

If you extrapolate the same 0.00003064 to $20,000 that's still only $0.61. A lot has changed between now and a year ago to help keep tx fees down, in terms of satoshis. The last time fees were this low was 2 years ago, when the price of BTC was about $390.
legendary
Activity: 3654
Merit: 8909
https://bpip.org
January 17, 2019, 07:54:11 AM
#38
I guess I have already proven my point. Didn't expect it this quick though.

Quote
24h Low / 24h High
$6.92 / $261.65

Imagine FOMOing and buying it for $261.65.

The cost of mining it is somewhere around $1-2. A lot of early miners might be hoarding it and it's not on large exchanges yet so that distorts the market somewhat.
legendary
Activity: 2744
Merit: 2462
https://JetCash.com
January 17, 2019, 07:29:40 AM
#37

Here's a thought: Use LN for domain sales.


I thought of that, and I think Lightning is a great concept. Also, it supports my opinion of Bitcoin - I think Bitcoin is a store of value. I decided not to use it, mainly because it requires me to maintain another wallet, and it has centralised control. Speed of confirmation is not so important with domain name sales. Especially when you consider registrar transfers, pushes are better, but they can still involve delays. This is why I believe that trust and escrow are more important than confirmation speed.
copper member
Activity: 630
Merit: 420
We are Bitcoin!
January 17, 2019, 07:25:24 AM
#36
Not trying to suck up but I'm pretty sure he's allowed to do whatever he wants.
He can but a lot depends on what he does. He is a public character for Bitcoin and the entire community. Anything comes from him will have million times market affect than you and me or others.  Smiley

I am sorry theymos, did you lose your confidence in Bitcoin because the transaction fee is high or something?

Have you transacted in bitcoin lately? The median tx fee is currently 11 cents; not exactly a dealbreaker.

https://bitcoinfees.earn.com/



11 cent is 0.00003064BTC when price is $3,590. Consider the price $20k, more hash difficulties more more btc as payment fees. Multiply that with the rate $20k. This was what happened when bitcoin had it's ATH. In dollar currency people even paid more than $10 for transactions.

The last bitcoin transaction was only two days ago which I did to buy a service.  Smiley
legendary
Activity: 1652
Merit: 4392
Be a bank
January 17, 2019, 07:22:44 AM
#35
I started to look at Grin and Beam as alternative payment methods for domain name sales. I'm also looking at Dash. It would be great if we could have somewhere to discuss these on Bitcoin Talk boards. I have had the alt boards on ignore for months now. In view of this move by Theymos, please could we have a Grin discussion board.
Alt boards I find useful for knowing which Legendaries are secret lemonade drinkers monero advocates.
Is this thread not what you need? https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/ann-grin-pow-mining-electronic-transactions-for-all-community-driven-5090427  [ANN] Grin | PoW Mining | Electronic transactions for all. Community driven.
There's some good discussion there eg https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.49266991 onwards
donator
Activity: 1414
Merit: 1051
Spondoolies, Beam & DAGlabs
January 17, 2019, 07:15:08 AM
#34
but did you pay dogie back?
Dogie canceled his bogus claims.
ah. but didn't correct your red trust. weird huh
Cancelled the court claim.
legendary
Activity: 1652
Merit: 4392
Be a bank
January 17, 2019, 07:11:49 AM
#33
but did you pay dogie back?
Dogie canceled his bogus claims.
ah. but didn't correct your red trust. weird huh
donator
Activity: 1414
Merit: 1051
Spondoolies, Beam & DAGlabs
January 17, 2019, 07:08:33 AM
#32
but did you pay dogie back?
Dogie canceled his bogus claims.
legendary
Activity: 1652
Merit: 4392
Be a bank
January 17, 2019, 07:07:05 AM
#31
Alright Guy, but did you pay dogie back?
donator
Activity: 1414
Merit: 1051
Spondoolies, Beam & DAGlabs
January 17, 2019, 07:03:04 AM
#30
Monero

Mimblewimble has privacy features, but it also has the first really impressive, true scaling solution in crypto. Privacy-wise, Monero is probably better overall, but its scaling is abysmal, and neither coin can be treated as an impenetrable black box.
Guy from https://beam.mw, https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/ann-beam-mimblewimble-private-scalable-no-ico-no-pre-mine-5052151 (ex Spondoolies) here.

Theymos, Mimblewimble allow non-interactive CoinJoins, when you couple it with a modified version of Dandelion that does TX merging in the stem phase + decoys outputs when needed, you get very good unlinkability.
The mechanism can be upgraded and improved without a hard fork. I believe that it's stronger than Monero, but we still didn't do a rigorous academic analysis, It will be done.
Currently, Beam implements it, Grin does only CJs with decoys but they can add it. We discussed it with Grin's devs: https://gitter.im/grin_community/Lobby?at=5bebe2c36b9822140d29e4b2 (Valdok is Beam's lead dev).
More information here: https://github.com/BeamMW/beam/wiki/Transaction-graph-obfuscation and https://medium.com/beam-mw/on-linkability-of-mimblewimble-da9ba71e83b4
In essence, when needed (e.g. not enough outputs), the node participating in a Dandelion stem phase routing, add random outputs that look like any other outputs. Those decoy outputs are later being spent forward as inputs by the node (each decoy has random block counter).

You can see it live in Beam's Block Explorer: https://explorer.beam.mw

Some real world huge blocks that happened:
https://explorer.beam.mw/block/713611c3876b6e38507a9971a95f73fcafc4c780e87237fdddc96207e5211530
https://explorer.beam.mw/block/64e037499a1d67b1c897db6be1b5870a372bbb6192303d2a0ac760ec88ecbd35
https://explorer.beam.mw/block/bbaa04e1afcde879c95941e5f3498788a81759ace4a81988f357270498f46009
https://explorer.beam.mw/block/af7725a6699a895a4ddb4490671da50834881733062c7bc1456a35001a1f154c

The interesting question is how many of those TXs (Each kernel represent a Tx) where CJ in the Dandelion stem phase and how many by the miner / pool (in the open P2P layer).
We will try to analyze open P2P data and improve the mechanisms if needed.

Guy

PS:
Regarding scaling: https://medium.com/beam-mw/whats-the-difference-between-monero-zcash-and-beam-953eafd89354

PPS:
One of Mimblewimble most interesting features is very fast initial sync, low resource requirements (storage, network) and the fact that FlyClient wallet is already implemented in both Grin & Beam. A true (almost) trustless mobile client (wallet) that connects directly to the P2P network.

legendary
Activity: 3010
Merit: 8114
January 17, 2019, 06:40:08 AM
#29

I thought we will act selfish and will only promote Bitcoin. Endorsing another coin and that is coming from theymos does not look good to me for a forum where we all are here to promote bitcoin.

Not trying to suck up but I'm pretty sure he's allowed to do whatever he wants. Its an interesting take on the whole idea of cryptocurrency and I'm happy to learn about it...

I am sorry theymos, did you lose your confidence in Bitcoin because the transaction fee is high or something?

Have you transacted in bitcoin lately? The median tx fee is currently 11 cents; not exactly a dealbreaker.

https://bitcoinfees.earn.com/

I regularly use 4 cent fees if I'm not in a hurry.
Pages:
Jump to: